Product Reviews Rated 4.08 out of 5 stars
468 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Glides On I found that as I age my eyes get more and more sensitive and I have allergies and reactions to certain cosmetic lines. I used Clinique years ago but because of the price stopped using this line. I have had to go back because of the sensitivities that I have. I do love the way it goes on, no pulling or tugging and I can adjust how thick I want to apply it. It does smear a bit until it dries and it is harder to get off. But it does have a bold look which I like. I can also wear this on the water line with no irritation. Just wish it weren't so expensive.
Most Helpful Critical Review Soft pencil The color Cloves (?) is a cool mauve-like brown. Sort of greige. It's a great option on days when I want a soft non-black liner.
The mechanical pencil won't keep a very fine point, so it's best for working into the lash line and blending out a bit with the sponge tip. I appreciate that it doesn't pull on the eyelid skin.
I probably will repurchase, although I wish it wouldn't smear and fade so quickly. I can't get more than 3 hours' wear out of it. (I've had other Quickliner colors that lasted much longer on the eyelid.)
Reviewed by 468 customers Intense clove!! 5
Someone from California
For reference I'm 43 with hazel eyes and light olive skin. Intense clove is a beautiful color. Not only is it beautiful but this liner is so easy to use. I also love Chanel eyeliners so that's what I compare this to. I can't speak for every color since sometimes the formulation changes with different colors but intense clove is great. I'm going to pick up another color next time it's on sale but intense clove is worth full price.
Clinique Eye Liner 5
donnatella from Midlothian, Texas
Narrow point eyeliner is easy to use!
Great for sensitive eyes 5
Phyllis from Freehold, NJ
Love the color & that it does not irritate my eyelids.
Eyeliner 5
Tina from OH
Love Clinique products, I have sensitive eyes, when I can afford it, I buy it.
I would buy again 5
Nan from New York
Like all Clinique products, top quality. Also hypoallergenic which I need
Smooth and rich 5
JMM from VT
It's hard to find an eyeliner that is easy to apply and has staying power for the duration of the day. This one is perfect. I prefer a twist pencil vs one that needs sharpening. It also has a sponge tip for blending, which is handy. Great color options. Just wish it wasn't so pricey.
The best eyeliner! 5
DonnaB from Texas
I have blue eyes and have always used brown or black eyeliner. I went to the Ulta store and the sales associate suggested I try the plum to bring out the blue in my eyes. That was 3 years ago and I haven't looked back! I love this eyeliner!! It goes on smooth and the smudging tool on the opposite end makes it so easy to smudge the lines. No need to sharpen the pencil (another reason to LOVE this). I always have at least two of these in my makeup bag at all times!
What's up with dispenser? 3
Patricia from Scottsdale, Az
Lots of comments like mine. Please, fix the problem? Or at least admit it.....
Ran out after 3 weeks of light use. 1
Marlene from NJ
I bought this at Ulta. After about 2-3 weeks of light use - (just a little on the bottom lid maybe 4 or 5 times a week), it ran out. There was no way I had broken any off, so I figured either the twisting mechanism was messed up or I had a defective product. I brought it back and Ulta replaced it with a new one. The exact same thing happened 2-3 weeks later. The previous Clinique pencil (no longer available) used to last me for 6 months! This is a total joke. Do not buy. Also, Aubergine color was a bit disappointing. Very hard to see any of that eggplant color, more like a dark brown.
Waste of money. Product is good, but device does not work 1
Kate from Scottsdale
Device is terrible. You can not twist device to move/ dispense additional product. Don't waste your money
Defective 1
Dice from Virginia Beach
This liner won't dispense more product when I twist it. Probably just a dud pencil I've never had this problem with Clinique before.
Would purchase again 5
Sass from Waco TX
Best eyeliner ! Been using for quite a while!
The liner is smooth, no tugging. Lasts all day 5
Pam natural health consultant from CT
Easy glide. Good color saturation
I do not recommend this product 1
Faith from Long Island NY
Not happy with it at all
is there any coupon give away. I'm using this a long time. 5
Ellen from Alexandria, VA
Glides easy, looks really good with my brown eyes. stay 24 hours. i used the intense PLUM. I have been buying this product hoping to get some coupon or gift
No I would not buy again. 1
MK from FL
You have to push hard and product still doesn't come out right. This is second time I've tried this item. I forgot this was item that didn't work. I won't forget again.
Goes On Easy 5
Jenn from SC
Easy to apply and smudges easily, no tugging on my lids. Provides a nice slim line & no sharpening needed. Also wears well, stays on all day and is easily removed with cleanser.
This is a great eyeliner. 5
LR from TN
I have very sensitive eyes, and I really love this eyeliner. The color is intense, but not too much. It stays in place and doesn't run or smear into my eyes.
Horrible 1
Maz from Chicago
Do not waste your money on this. I used three times and when I went to twist up for more product it would not work! It is way to expensive for this to happen. Will never buy again!
I would buy this again 5
Lynne from Novi, MI
I wish Clinique had navy blue mascara to go with it.
Only 1 use worth 1
Grace from Minnesota
It worked good for one or 2 uses but when I tried to twist up more there wasn't anymore to twist up.
My favorite eyeliner! 5
MT lady from Billings mt
Use this product daily on upper eyelid. Not on the bottom as the color is intense.
Doesn't go on well 3
Tiramisu7 from Southern California
It goes on well on my hand, when I test it. As an eyeliner, it didn't have the same richness and didn't glide on well.
This is the best eyeliner I've ever used! 5
New User from Phoenix, AZ
great eyeliner, would purchase again
Love the color. Don't love the staying power. 3
TXmom from Amarillo, Texas
This pencil is beautiful. I wish it did not transfer and move around on my eyelids.
