Rated 3.6 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Love this liner!
I do a pretty dramatic winged liner look every single day, so liquid liner is a must. I have looked at tons of reviews and tried several, and so far I am happiest with this one. I have been using it for over 6 months now, and it doesn't have the problem of "felt tip" liquid liners of drying out after just a few uses. It stays on ALL day (over 12 hours at least), and the color doesn't fade, crack, or "transfer" up to my lid after a few hours (however, I do always use an eyeshadow primer, and eyeshadow before putting liner on). My only problems with this eyeliner are that on the corners of my eyes, it occasionally runs slightly (probably due to the fact that my eyes tend to water from the corners at times), and that the tip of the applicator doesn't stay quite as precise as I would like it to over time. For this reason I am on the hunt for a liner with a very, VERY precise tip that won't wear out and that you still dip into a little pot like this liner. However, until I find a better one, I'll be sticking with this liner!
Most Helpful Critical Review Wasn't what I expected.
This bleeds all over the place and doesn't go on smoothly at all. Not for mature eyes and not for women with small eyes. The applicator is a stick, not a brush, and it is hard to use.
Reviewed by 234 customers Not Dark Enough
Mar from Los Angeles
This is not as black as I'd like. It's easy to work with but I have used many other eyeliners that give the intense cat eye I go for. This ain't it, L'Oreal.
Angie from Portland
I got this to replace of the Revlon eyeliner I usually use to tight line my eyes while I was down in Florida visiting my family and oh my gosh! I think within 30 minutes of me being outside I looked like a straight up raccoon. Then came back to Oregon without all of the humidity, but it did the exact same thing! Was smearing and smudging, in my living room! Definitely would not buy again and would not recommend.. well maybe to my enemies.
Best drugstore brand
Kittygurrrl86 from Smyrna, TN
I pay for high-end makeup but keep coming back to this drugstore brand for liquid eyeliner. It's great for the price point.
Smears within an hour
Mizzliz from Houston, TX
I gave it a good use for about 4 months, I don't wear make up daily but when I do this didn't last but an hour or so before smearing, I work in a bank so we have AC on and I don't move around to much to where I would sweat and mess up my make up. By end of day I would have to redo my eye makeup like 3 times do to this eye liner not holding up.
Will never buy again
Nikki from Beaumont, TX
Worse eyeliner ever.
Everything's so good, except the applicator
Lizzie from NYC
I bought the waterproof one and when I say it holds, IT HOLDS. I have slept with it on and wake up and it still looks perfect. For weeks I dipped another applicator in it and then used it, but it's easy to get used to the applicator and it is SUCH A GOOD AND CHEAP EYELINER
no no no no NOOOOOOO
Kate from Gulfport MS
Ya'll..... so I wanted something that dried matte and I thought felt tip ehh why not try it? That was THE WORST applicator I've ever attempted to use!! Skipped on my skin, couldn't create a sharp edge.. I'll be returning this tomorrow!
Zu420 from Santa cruz california
I dont want to completely shut down this eyeliner saying its god awful because it is beautiful it looks very dark and pigmented, it just doesn't stay on my eyes personality. Causing it so smudge, smear and almost cause raccoon eyes. The end of my wing stays put while the inner part closest to my eye always smears and disappears even after a few hours. So wearing it I have to always be checking in the mirror and carry it with me to do touch ups.
If you have "dry" skin this eyeliner would be wonderful
I have more oily eyes and eyelids which is the cause of it not staying for extended periods of time.
It stays along my lashline and end of my wing just that part closest to my eye refuses to stay on
Not the best
E_xo from Michigan
Gives great length but could they have not engineered a worse way to get the wand back in the tube? I mean seriously... You have to work at it which is super annoying. Tried to get it in the tube once and it flung mascara all over my face and fingers. Not worth the hassle... Next!
MsTica19 from Ca
So you can go as thick or as thin as you like. But be super quick or it dries and becomes a little lumpy and will flake
andyreed55 from New York, NY
A wonderful product that works as it is intended to do.
I wouldn't buy this again.
Nina from Lompoc
This eyeliner is very black and dramatic BUT it smudges and smears so easily, The staying power sucks. I'm happy I found milanis stay put
Love it and so does my husband
Housewife from San diego
My husband loves me wearing black eyeliner and this works so good. I have small eyes and my crease is small and this eyeliner doesn't transfer at all it stays on all day and looks fresh all day. I will keep buying this
Survives Through Anything!!!
Jay Z. from Oregon
This the best drugstore eyeliner hands down! This has been my go to liquid eyeliner for 4 years now. I love it so much. This eyeliner has stayed on from drunk parties, to running in the rain and sometimes even from giving my man some sloppy top. I worn this eyeliner through serval volleyball games and it still was on. It does rub off a bit if you touch. I love it so much but I wish L'ORÉAL was cruelty free and for that it gets 4 stars.
Makupgirl20 from The Woodlands, TX
I don't understand why this has bad reviews. Ever since N.Y.C discontinued their liquid liner this is definitely the best alternative. Stays on all day and super black, this dries matte. Only thing is you have to work quickly bc it dries super fast. Love the formula!
Seems to do the job
Ma from Toledo ohioy
Seen a lot better
Mo from Iowa
I thought it would be better considering it's price but it comes off so easily and gives me even darker under eye bags :(
christig83 from San Diego
This use to be my favorite eyeliner, but the past two times I've bought it, it has been very watered down. When I go to make my wing, it seems to remove it's self and clump up. Coverage lasts, but probably cuz I have to over line a million times for it to stick. I won't be buying this product anymore.
Why is this watery?
eyeliner girl from PA
I have read several reviews, and they match my experience. Along with being hard to find, this is super watery and will not shake up or mix up. There is no way I enjoy putting tinted water on my eyelid. What's up with this?
Will not buy again
Baby girl from Arkansas
Will not buy again
Best liquid liner!
Ahaas from Hamburg, PA
This is my ultimate favorite eyeliner. I always get compliments on how it stays put during my 12hr shifts. It's not watery and has good dark coverage. You only need one coat.
twatso2 from Chandler, AZ
i love this liner. It goes on smooth and i can quickly get the job done.
DonnaHurst from Harrison, NY
Sample and loved the scent, hue and results of useage
username4breeze from Byron, GA
Precise and accurate for just what I have been looking for.
bethanieadams from Malone, NY
This is a great & wonderful product that is awesome.