Rated 4.65 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review This brow pencil is just perfect. No, SERIOUSLY! Perfect!
My eyebrows don't grow all the way out. The start off super thick & pretty but get then towards the ends. I've always filled them in with MAC's spiked eyebrow pencil which works great but I hate to go all the way to the mall. This product is even better & has a very useful brush at the end of it. Plus, I don't have to go so far to get it. I can not be caught without my eyebrows done. This product & the company (Ulta) that sells it just screams convenience! This is my go to.. love it ❤️
Most Helpful Critical Review Perfect, just not for oily skin
As someone who absolutely needs her brows filled in everyday, I'm extremely picky with my brow products, especially with pencils. I'm Asian with black hair, and the shade 4.5 Neutral deep brown was the perfect shade for me. The shade range is really impressive, making a match much easier. The brow pencil was extremely easy to apply, making thin strokes a breeze. The pencil wasn't too waxy or too creamy, just the perfect balance to glide over the skin and make hair like strokes. As much as I loved the application and color of this pencil, I wasn't impressed with the lasting power of it. It lasted about half my day before it started to wear off. It definitely is waterproof since I wore it swimming and it didn't budge, but by the end of my day, it was no match for my oily skin. It rubbed off easily with the slightest touch, which was disappointing. I had higher hopes for the lasting power because I really wanted to covert to a brow pencil. I currently use It Cosmetics Build a Brow gel stain and that stuff does not budge. I would recommend the Benefit precise brow pencil for those with normal to dry skin but not for those with oily skin. It performed well in all areas except staying power. I received this complimentary for reviewing purposes.
Reviewed by 6083 customers I would definitely buy this product again
SASSY from SC
I use this product daily and it stays on very easy to outline my brows and fill in. I'm completely satisfied.
hannah7919 from PA
i like how it goes on smooth but its long lasting. i prefer this over anastasia brow wiz. i feel like there's more color selection
In love with the 2.75
Ashley from Fleetwood
This is the only line I use for my eyebrows, I love all their products. I am soooo happy they came out with 2.75, its such a beautiful auburn color, perfect for red heads!
BEST BROW PENCIL EVER!
The Bon from Morgantown. PA
Love the fine tip which allows you to draw actual lines where you need them!
My Absolute Favorite
Jake from Austin, TX
The micro tip is great for giving brows a full fluffy look without the sketched on appearance. The shade range is great too, with multiple undertones to suit all skin tones and hair colors.
Benefit Cosmetics Brow Pencil
Dee from Michigan
I enjoy using this brow pencil. It works great on my brows.
My go- to eyebrow pencil
HoneyBaby from Phoenix, AZ
Ive tried a few eyebrow pencils and I keep going back to this one. My 19 yr old daughter even loves it.
I would not buy again
Pamela from Nevada
I put it on in the morning
Adi from California
This is my favorite eyebrow pen! It glides on smoothly and creates define lines. This is the only eyebrow pen that matches my brow shade
TA from Virginia
Easy to use! Perfect color and it doesn't change
I love it
Maria from Salem, OR
This is the only product I would buy over and over
I would buy this product all the time
Laura from Naples , Fl
I love this eyebrow pencil.
Holls from Seattle, WA
Did not fill in as easy as I thought it would. I had to really push to get anything to show and then it looked fake
kitty from WI
I was impressed on how this pencil went on easy and covered my thin skin brows. Haven't had a chance to try the waterproof part. But will this winter.
Absolutely 💯 love
Smikke from Washington state
I can get my browser on point every time. Color 5 is perfect for me.
Best brow product there is
Leesa from Brownsville Oregon
Precisely brow is the best brow product there is. Never smudges and lasts all day. Benefit products in general are amazing by precisely brow is my favorite.
Goof Proof is better
Linds from USA
I bought this and another one by mistake during the last BOGO sale. This one sucks! It takes WAY too many strokes to get it to show up. I usually use the Goof Proof brow pencil by Benefit and it is so much better. Also, why is Benefit packaging this product this way? I feel like the packaging has more quality than the product itself.
It's AWESOME brow pencil
Sonya from Mcdonough, Georgia
Make your brows perfect I always purchase it
THIS IS IT!
Angel from Michigan
I originally saw this on Tiktok (don't judge me 😜). I used to have beautiful eyebrows, but I have hypothyroidism and my brows have practically disappeared. I've literally tried dozens of brow pencils. When I saw this I thought "Why the heck not?!" I wasn't nuts about thit price, but after trying it I won't use anything else. I love the texture and the color, and it's lasts all day with minimal touch ups. Until I have the guts to have my brows microbladded, I'll be using this!!!
streaky and hardly any product
ojitos from new york, ny
there are many superior brow pencils on the market and some are even half the price. this is not it!
Moose from Norwood nc
The fancy tube is way to ornate, make it basic and lower the high price of the product !!
Best brow pencil ever !!!!!!!!
Pebbles from Grayson, Ga
So easy to use, looks great and stays all day!!!
Definitely purchase this
Classic makeup lover from Shreveport, LA
Great eyebrows pencil. Benefit spoolies are the best ones IMO. I love ABH products and have used her eyebrow wiz pencil for years. I believe the Benefit pencils are a very good competitor. I highly recommend this product, particularly if you are a beginner.
Laurisa from Ur mom
I took a shower and nun didn't come off at all
Best eyebrow pencil 😊
JAG46 from Tennessee
This is the best eyebrow pencil 😊