Rated 4.65 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review This brow pencil is just perfect. No, SERIOUSLY! Perfect!
My eyebrows don't grow all the way out. The start off super thick & pretty but get then towards the ends. I've always filled them in with MAC's spiked eyebrow pencil which works great but I hate to go all the way to the mall. This product is even better & has a very useful brush at the end of it. Plus, I don't have to go so far to get it. I can not be caught without my eyebrows done. This product & the company (Ulta) that sells it just screams convenience! This is my go to.. love it ❤️
Most Helpful Critical Review Perfect, just not for oily skin
As someone who absolutely needs her brows filled in everyday, I'm extremely picky with my brow products, especially with pencils. I'm Asian with black hair, and the shade 4.5 Neutral deep brown was the perfect shade for me. The shade range is really impressive, making a match much easier. The brow pencil was extremely easy to apply, making thin strokes a breeze. The pencil wasn't too waxy or too creamy, just the perfect balance to glide over the skin and make hair like strokes. As much as I loved the application and color of this pencil, I wasn't impressed with the lasting power of it. It lasted about half my day before it started to wear off. It definitely is waterproof since I wore it swimming and it didn't budge, but by the end of my day, it was no match for my oily skin. It rubbed off easily with the slightest touch, which was disappointing. I had higher hopes for the lasting power because I really wanted to covert to a brow pencil. I currently use It Cosmetics Build a Brow gel stain and that stuff does not budge. I would recommend the Benefit precise brow pencil for those with normal to dry skin but not for those with oily skin. It performed well in all areas except staying power. I received this complimentary for reviewing purposes.
Reviewed by 6057 customers Great eyebrow pencil
Christena from Shreveport, LA
Love this eyebrow pencil, easy to use and blends nicely. Brows look smooth and the pencil lines disappear into the brow easily. Quick apply.
Fi from New York
This brow pencil is pretty good. The color selection isn't my favorite as in there are better products for my preferred color. But the formula is pretty good.
nolla from Lancaster, Ohio
Definitely works good. Be careful how much you expose the pencil though, it's very thin and will break easily. I always make sure to spin mine all the way back in before I put the cap back on.
Looks natural, definitely fills in my bald eagle brows. Because I basically have none. Sucks that it's expensive, but I've bought a few times and it's never let me down. Lasts awhile too. I always use the spooly on the end to blend it in to my natural brow.
Will keep buying as long as it exists
Not worth it
Becka from Miami, FL
I was impressed by the wide range of color options and I was really motivated to buy based on the hype but unfortunately, I wasn't impressed at all. A pencil is a pencil is a pencil. I've used the cheapest of brands, but my decision to purchase what I thought would be higher quality eyebrow product was for longevity. I honestly get more wear with drug store brands that are half the price.
Color is not brown, it's red.
Becks from Utah
Wish there was a safe way to see the color before a purchase is made. Will be returning.
This product is amazing!
Vani from Perris, CA
This product is the only eyebrow pencil that works for me. It stays on all day and is truly worth every penny!
Favorite eyebrow pencil
Mrs. M from New Jersey
Use everyday for eyebrows. Matches perfectly. Only lately the pencil seems to be very dry and break off.
Doesn't last long at all.
Excellent for Precise Brows
Bobbie from Florida
I have used this pencil for 2 years. It works great for outlining the brow. CON: The end of the pencil tends to break off easily, which creates waste.
This makes doing brows SO EASY
Ria from Oklahoma
I love this just to fill in my brows really quickly on a day to day use. Brow products were intimidating to me as someone new to make up, but this made it SO easy and it looks really good. I've also had a hard time with other pencils being either TOO blonde (ie yellow) or TOO brown, and so the neutral blonde color was perfect for me.
Glad I tried it!
Livinlife from South Carolina
I bought this during the 21 Days of Beauty sale. I've purchased several different brands of eyebrow pencils and none looked even close to natural. This one was a perfect color. I also use the Gimme brow sealer. Great combination! This is a product I'll keep buying!
Best brow pencil
Customer from Richland Wa
Love this pencil. Love the color. Love how easy it is to apply! Just purchased a couple more to have when traveling and home!
Cash from Maryland
I really enjoy the product. I get the #4 and it looks pretty good seeing as though it a perfect match but this is my second time getting this product and not being able to enjoy it fully. I literally purchase this item on Friday used three times and by Wednesday the product is completely gone. I have used countless brow products and never had this issue. It didn't break and I'm not pressing super hard on my brows with the product so I don't be understand.
I would buy this again!
Ruizy from Houston, Texas
I bought this product for the first time. I love it! My eyebrows are super thin.
This definitely helps to add natural looking volume.
love the fine tip - adds fullness in clean sweeps
kiki from roseville mn
Yes I would definitely purchase this product again.
Virginia from San Antonio
This product applies smoothly but more importantly stay on all day. I love it
my new fav
Rosie from St Peter's Mo
long lasting, doesnt smudge off when I wipe my hand across my fore head from exhaustion
best pencil ever
PJ from California
Best color match I have found. Have a drawer full of rejects, always come back
bekah from kentucky
lasts you a super long time and is great! amazing pigment love the brow brush. would recommend to buy with the brow gel.
Ev from Ann Arbor, mi
Use this to fill in thin eyebrows. Looks great and stays on all day. Someone actually thought I had microblading done! W
Kay Way from Florida
Love this precise pencil with brush. Easy to use and love performance.
Ride or Die
Blue biker from Texas
This is my staple brow pencil snd nothing compares. Period!
Love it! I have bought this product repeatedly.
LRae from Granbury TX
Easy to apply and blend in, looks natural.
This is a fine product
Good Consumer from Netcong, NJ
This product is very good.
Hannah from Kansas City
Love this pencil, lasts all day and the shade is perfect!
Better than Anastasia
Maddie from Detroit Michigan
This eyebrow pencil is my absolute GO. TO. Its creamier than Anastasia's eyebrow pencil, it has less wax so its more pigmented and you use less pressure so theres less chance of pencil breakage. They have a wide range of shades and its a great formula. If I had ti choose one makeup product to use for the rest of my life it would be this one.