Product Reviews Rated 4.47 out of 5 stars
64 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review The Best Concealer I've Ever Tried I am over 40 and absolutely love this concealer. It doesn't dry or crack under my eyes. I only put a dot under each eye and I press it in my skin with a damp beauty sponge. I never use powder to set it. It sets itself and never budges. I always suggest to start out with little product and build to your liking with any makeup product. I have one complaint, and that is the color selection. Because this product color selection is so light, I only use it under my eyes to brighten. I'm very fair with pink undertones, red hair, and blue eyes, and I feel that the color selection is even too light for me. I am having a hard time finding one that matches my skin tone. I have tried Soft Cream, which is too light under my eyes, so I am going to have to go darker in color to Vanilla Bean or Custard to see whether either of those are more suited to my skin tone.
Most Helpful Critical Review Too drying and not even a little waterproof While the pigment is very strong and coverage full, the formula is too dry for me. There's a little more creasing than I'd expect from such a dry formula, and when I set it with my beloved Aquasurance powder foundation (or any other powder I've tried), I get bunching. Normal eye moisture causes this concealer to break up, so it's not waterproof at all. It took a lot of work to make it look smooth around my eyes. It's also extremely light in color. I bought a shade that's 2 shades deeper than what I'd usually select, and it's still a little too light (see photo). Basically, you can use this to point conceal or highlight smooth oily places on the face--but I would keep it away from any place with lines or dryness or moisture. At this price point, I'd get Elf camo instead.
Reviewed by 64 customers Highly recommend this!! 5
Jackie from Kansas
I got this in Banana. I've never tried anything in this brand before. It went on perfectly, not too dry, and I just noticed here at the end of the day that my undereye isn't showing any fine lines, which is Never the case!! And no dry signs at all!! I'm ordering more in a buff shade. I've tried so many brands, and this one is at the top!
I'm 62 and use a bit of eye cream that I let set in before putting on my makeup in the morning.
AMAZINGGGG 5
Z from Ga
I absolutely love this concealer!!! Way better than tartes shape tape . It's not too drying but doesn't rub off fast ! Only complaint is the shade range :( please provide more shades for darker complexions 💕💕
GORGEOUS 5
Julia from U.S.A
Ordered this thinking it wasn't going to be anything special. HOW WRONG COULD I BE??? First of all it wears for literally 24 hours. I put it on at 8am and wore it all day, fell asleep with it and woke up with my under eyes completely covered still. It's absolutely water proof and this is the first product I have loved so much I just HAD to write a review on. If you're in doubt about if you should get it or not, THIS is your sign to get it.
By far the best I've ever used! 5
Did from Wisconsin
I swear I have tried them all. The expensive recommended ones and I kept going back to Nyx HD and can't stop, but this one is my favorite.
I do prep my eyes with cerev eye cream, then Garnier Bright Eyes (another life saver), I can dab this one on, I don't even use that much with this and if I'm in a hurry and don't set with powder or spray, I'm still in good shape later. This is the only one that takes less effort! Looks natural, not heavy but for certain full coverage.
Finally, thank you!!!
Perfect dupe for shape tape 5
Mariah from Michigan
Better and fuller coverage, better staying power, and wayyyy better price. I'd give this ten stars if I could. Love using this with my MAC foundation. Can't wait to try it with J.CAT's pressed powder. This concealer even blends well when I need a touch up through the day if I rub some off, but is still more transferproof than anything else I've used. I have this in three shades depending on how I'm wearing it. I'm a full coverage girl but a few swipes of just this concealer gives me a flawless natural look when I want to wear my makeup light. I've used shape tape religiously for years but Tarte will never see my money again lol. So glad I tried this!!!!!
best concealer I've used so far 5
Linzee from canton
I've been testing out different makeup brands, and I really love J.Cat beauty so I decided to give this a shot. I'm so glad I did too. a little bit of this concealer goes a long way, trust me. I dont like when people cake on their makeup, I used 3 little dots of this under my eyes, and it was more than enough! but, it blended out very nicely and it didn't smear or smudge after 8 hours of wearing it! I do wish I had gotten 1 shade lighter, but I'm still going to wear the one I have every day! 10/10 recommend!
5 STARS! 5
Aj from Fl
This concealer is absolutely amazing and it's SO full coverage!! I bought 2 these because I just felt like I had to! This literally replaced my $40 hourglass concealer, this does the job 10x better!!!
2nd tube - OBSESSED 5
SpookiBabi from Las Vegas
I love love LOVE this concealer. Perfect shade, doesn't oxidize, I do have some fine wrinkles under my eyes but it doesn't settle or cake up. Brightens up my face and is very flattering. Never using a different concealer. My tried and true! Also, I'm writing this review in June - broke a record of 117 degrees and while my foundation was practically melting off my face my concealer stayed in place. Perfection!
Great product if you prep your skin first 4
Mae from Ohio
This is a great concealer provided you moisturize your undereyes well first. Otherwise, it can look a bit dry. The color in the tube can be a bit misleading. I bought Soft Cream, which looks very pink & I thought it would be too dark. But once blended out, it looks lighter & more neutral. I love that there are so many options for pale skin, which can be hard to find (I'm usually in the lightest shade in most brands, but not with this). It's got good medium buildable coverage, is long lasting, and has minimal creasing if you set it lightly.
Beware if you have dry under eyes/skin 2
Kristin from Davison, MI
I have oily skin but in the winter very dry forehead and under eyes. This does have great coverage and the lightest color does a great job brightening but it is super drying and made my under eyes look extra creased and flaky. May be a good product for brightening high points of the face for oilier people or for people with very oily under eyes.
This is my go to concealer 5
Hidden gem from Utah
This concealer is the best concealer I have found out there and I have tried every kind you can think of. You have to work with it fast so it doesn't dry to fast. I like to use my beauty blender to buff out any creases and then set it immediately. I personally use I heart revolution coconut powder. My skin is really dry so I only set with the powder puff under my eyes. I also have bad dark circles under my eyes and this covers them up without needing to color correct. It is amazing and I will never use anything else. And, how can you beat the price? It's seriously such a hidden gem, I'm so glad I tried it.
The consistency is very dry 1
SCPugMom from SC
I was disappointed in the way this concealer made my skin look and feel once it dried. I had to add moisturizer on top of it because it highlighted every crease and wrinkle under my eyes.
horrible 1
grace from Juban crossing
cakey and dry makes skin look wrinkled
Amazing! 5
Rose from New york
I ordered this concealer not expecting it to be that great but i was wrong! This concealer is so smooth and blends so easily. I use this as an eyeshadow primer and as an under eye concealer and it works wonders! I haven't had a single issue with the eyeshadow staining my skin since I've used this. Not to mention I'm really pale but i still like a little highlight on my under eyes and no other concealer had been able to make that happen until i started using this. I highly recommend this! (Not to mention im a avid makeup user and i do extreme makeup looks)
I really like this product. 5
JoAnn from TX - Texas
The color I got is a little darker than I'm use to right now. I know when summer hits or warmer days I'll get darker. It'll be perfect!
Impressed! 5
NotDeadYet from Burbank
So glad I got this, lies well on my mature skin. (Tarte Shape Tape did me NO favors)
Amazing product 5
Lanes from Charlotte NC
Skip paying for Benefit or Mac concealers... this little tube is flawless and really does not smudge. Can wear all day long, I recommend 100%
BEST CONCEALER SO UNDERRATED 5
Liberty from St Louis
This is my favorite concealer of all time, it's so underrated. Please always keep it cost efficient!! It literally feels like a little great secret bc no one talks about it but it's incredible. Never creases, dries quickly, full coverage but not cakey. It's better than shape tape!!
Incredibly underrated 5
MissL from Indiana
So smooth underneath my eyes and great coverage! I only use one or two dots underneath each eye, pat it out with my ring finger, and then use a sponge to blend in. If it's creasing you are using too much! I feel pretty and awake every time I wear this. We did holiday photos lately and it looked like my natural skin. Highly recommend.
PERFECT for the fairest skin tones! 5
Compared to JSC & Tarte from Southeast Missouri
Unbelievable product. I have so much trouble finding something white enough to even classify as a concealer. I'm an extremely fair completed redhead with dry skin, and I will NEVER use another concealer.
The Best Concealer I've Ever Tried 5
Anne from Indiana
I am over 40 and absolutely love this concealer. It doesn't dry or crack under my eyes. I only put a dot under each eye and I press it in my skin with a damp beauty sponge. I never use powder to set it. It sets itself and never budges. I always suggest to start out with little product and build to your liking with any makeup product. I have one complaint, and that is the color selection. Because this product color selection is so light, I only use it under my eyes to brighten. I'm very fair with pink undertones, red hair, and blue eyes, and I feel that the color selection is even too light for me. I am having a hard time finding one that matches my skin tone. I have tried Soft Cream, which is too light under my eyes, so I am going to have to go darker in color to Vanilla Bean or Custard to see whether either of those are more suited to my skin tone.
Gets 5 stars for shade range 5
Lauren from Snow
If you are very fair like me, finding a concealer that go light enough is annoying- thank you j.cat for including pale people!
Choose your shade carefully! 4
Emma from Pittsburgh
This is a really amazing concealer, especially for the price, but they have an odd color range - lots and lots of really light colors, an not so many medium and dark shades. My shade sits right between two, and I find that it works fairly well for highlighting and contouring, but I'd like a wider range of shades. Also, the shades are not well represented online, just a heads up.
good for under eye! 5
abbbbyyyy from Salt Lake City, UT
LOVE!!! I was using shape tape for under eye concealer and it would be creased and cakey by the end of the day. I tried this instead and it's exactly what I wanted! good coverage but not too thick for under the eyes. I think it looks better applied with a damp sponge than a brush. I really recommend this, especially considering the price.
The product I was skeptical of became my holy grail! 5
NaomiK96 from Las Vegas, NV
I was sooo skeptical since it's affordable, I've used tarte shape tape which is expensive, Estee Lauder which is expensive so many expensive brands to find a product that matched my skin tone since I'm a true porcelain. This product matched, no oxidization, very light weight so it didn't dig trenches in my fine lines and then I even tested its waterproof claim and it truly is water proof unless you scrub viciously which you should no do lol.
