Rated 4.51 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Balm CHICKA Balm Balm
This eye balm I absolutely love! I have fair skin so this one works well for me. I love using it with and without makeup. I feel this one blends the best with makeup versus it's sister product. I have pink undertones to my skin so this one works well for me. It feels amazing on my eyes when I first wake up. I have also noticed awesome results with it helping my dark under eye situation. I look more awake and can re-apply during the day and blend into my makeup with no issues. I like the pink highlight shimmer it has but understand that is not for everyone. The cooling sensation is addicting so...DO NOT OVER USE! LESS is MORE with this product. If you do over use, you will feel a burning sensation. I have both the rose glow and the original one in the blue tube. If I had to choose between this one and the blue one, I would choose this one 100%. This one is well worth the investment! Excellent product!
Most Helpful Critical Review Not for people of color/rash
I was so excited to try this product. I have dark circles around my deep set eyes and this got some good reviews. My skin is kind of sensitive... I don't know what to exactly, but I can use some wild cheap stuff and not have a reaction, and then break out into hives from detergent. Anyways, I read that this had a shimmer to it, which I thought would be kind of fun, but the sparkle is white. I am black. It looked like I was using too light of a weird under eye concealer. I was able to kind of dab it in to make it less noticeable. There is a product quiz you can take (which I didn't realize until after buying the product) that asks if you're light or dark skinned and it recommended the other under eye that is orange... which I am assuming is because it has gold glitter, not white. So that was my initial complaint, but then my skin around my eyes started getting itchy and breaking into a rash. I have small red bumps all around my eyes and a couple of large red bumps that kind of look like acne around my eyes as well. I don't get acne, especially not around my eyes, so I know it was this product. I am sad though because I liked the cooling sensation, and the product did work! My dark circles are less dark. So unfortunate about the bumps though.
Reviewed by 3452 customers Did not love it
HippyChick from Huntsville, AL
I ended up returning this. It did absolutely nothing for me, and it kind of irritated my eyes. I guess all the TikTok users are 20 years old, so it looks amazing on them. I'm almost 60, and didn't think it helped me at all.
This is amazing!!!!
Miss.F from Northern New England
This is my first experience with Tula and it's so great!!! It gives a nice cooling sensation and depuffs me nicely. It goes on under make up good as well. I definitely recommend trying
Beware allergic reaction
Emma from Connecticut
Had a delayed allergic reaction resulted in hives and swollen eyes. Be sure to patch test reaction happened about three hours later.
Love love love
Jen from WY, USA
Brightens under the eyes. Cooling. Also a great cream highlighter. I recommended it to my mom too
Lisa from Sarasota
Sadly, this product increased puffiness and caused redness and stinging around my eyes. I had to return.
Small red bumps all around eye area
AlexTzo from USA
This product does brighten, but it left me with small red bumps and puffiness later in the day. It might be great for some people but I just can't use it.
Not what I expected
Barb from Waukesha, WI
I usually use Becca product but seems they didn't have it so the girl suggested this product. Not at all what I thought it would be. Rather disappointed for the price.
JLT from Alabama
This stuff is awful it burns not cools. If you want to feel like you put icy hot under your eyes buy this stuff.
Meg from Delran NJ
Caused my eyes to break out in a rash and all puffy
H from Wooster
One of my favorite products that I use is a very tired and broke and stressed college student. This is a lifesaver during those weeks where I am up all night studying doing homework or working one of my jobs.
I will buy this product again.
adri from Los angeles, CA
simply apply Tula on clean under eyes to moisturize.
yoni from baltimore
this product gave me redness, itchiness, puffiness, and irritation around my under eye area. it doesn't even work that well to decrease darkness/puffiness.
doesn't do anything
hsilverman from San Diego
The blue calming stick is far more effective. I don't see any results when I use the pink stick. I regret buying this one. After 6 months of constant use and using as directed I don't see any change. It doesn't brighten my under eyes, it doesn't calm puffy eyes, and it doesn't work at all with my makeup. Save your money and by the blue one.
Had an Allergic Reaction (Contact Dermatitis)
Sarah from Newark, NJ
I do not have sensitive skin or any known allergies, but this product gave me an allergic reaction ~3 hours after application. That's when I started feeling itchy and noticed moderate swelling around my eyes. I applied it in the morning, and by evening my skin was very red, puffy, and developed dry flaky patches. I have never had such a reaction to any skincare products until trying this.
Also, the brand is involved in a $5 million class action settlement agreement for allegedly mislabelling their products as probiotic.
aJane from Nebraska
If I use this product as intended, around my eyes, it's a no go. The cooling sensation on that sensitive skin feels more like burning and irritation. BUT! This makes the best highlighter I've ever used. It pairs so well with my cream blush, I rub it back and forth a couple times and then lightly dab to blend with my fingertip. It leaves the best natural glow, no glittery shimmer. Stays on all day, even through sweaty workouts with nyx setting spray.
María from Alameda
Everything Tula is holy Grail status. This makes my eyes look like I've slept 12 hours even if I've slept less than five.
I have one in my purse so I can touch up throughout the day. It's cooling, brightening and Gives the most beautiful lit-from-within glow! Something i will ALWAYS re-purchase.
Gorgeous for me!
Flowergirl from Laurel Park, NC
This is the best decision I made! Wishing to soften and brighten my eye area (mature skin) I ordered this with OSea eye cream. This is beautiful. Applies easily and does what it says. Pink tones suit my skin.
cooling and de-puffing
t Osberg from Salem Ohio
love this! I have noticed a big improvement in my dark under eye circle and bags. no irritation at all and I've been using it daily for about 6 weeks. will definitely buy again!
Brightens under eye
Barkart from Colorado
I like the way it feels and works.
Cool To Eyes
Lady Ru from Sacramento
I like it so far because it does feel cool applying under the eyes but it's only been a week of use and I hope that it will help with this fading the darkness from under my eyes as well.
Not worth it.
Biz from Atlanta Ga
I tried this and the original at the same time. Neither does anything but put a colored sheen on your skin. This one is a pink pearl color. Gives no hydration and only made my eyes water.
girlysmile from us
Works But Irritated My Eyes
msharp from KY
This product definitely delivered on the brightening aspect; it made my dark under eyes look so much brighter and less tired! It looks pretty under makeup. But, like many others, it irritated my eyes & skin. Redness, itchiness, burning, and bumps. I've tried it multiple times to just make sure because I really wanted to use it, but I can't😩
Solid pink streak on your skin that doesn't blend.
Swags from PA
I love anything in a stick form but this was a miss for me. It's solid pink and is dry and does not blend out. If you try to blend it, it pretty much just wipes off. I have light skin so it shouldn't be showing up this way on me.
Brightens your eyes
Lulabell from Los Angeles, CA
Love this cooling pen and eye brightener. I take it with me everywhere and glide it on a couple times a day in this hot heat. I'm sure it will be once when Winter hit but I'm really liking it regardless. Tula Brand is great and I will continue to buy so long as their products stay the same.