Rated 4.44 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review BEST THING EVER! (Shade terra)
This product is absolutely phenomenal! You can just scribble it all over your eyelids and blend out the edges for a synthetic brush or your fingers and have a 30 second eyeshadow look that is very chic looking but with practically no effort. It does not dry down too quickly so you can apply it to both eyes before you start blending and still have sufficient working time. However, once it sets, it is set! I have never had an issue of it fading or flaking or creasing at all. I currently have the shade terra and it is a gorgeous color for my fair olive skin (for reference nars custard concealer matches my face perfectly). It absolutely does not crease on me and therefore it is a great base to build off of if you want a more smokey or dramatic look. I am going to be buying 2 more colors (taupe and fig). Highly recommend!
Most Helpful Critical Review Creased mess
Creases terribly after just 4 hours, basically gone after that. Trying to buff the product with my finger to even out the creases just removes it. I used it alone on my eyes and also over a mattifying face primer (Soap and Glory One Heck of a Blot) which I frequently use under my eyebrow makeup. It might work over my normal combo of 2 eyeshadow primers (MAC Paint Pot and NYX HD Eyeshadow Primer) with a powder to set but at that point, it's lost all its benefit of being a easy-to-use, on the go, minimalist product.
I like the packaging a lot, the mirror inside is very nice! I've put all my at-work makeup in it and it's great to hold my eyebrow pencil, eyebrow gel, and lipstick.
I got the color 'Angel' and for being a 'light rose gold' it is mostly just champagne/gold. I wish it were cooler in tone, all of their shades are very warm!
Reviewed by 652 customers Spirit is the best!
LKMS7 from MS
I love this eye pencil. It's the perfect one and done shadow stick. It's easy to apply, and it lasts pretty well.
My go-to eye colors
Emily B. from Miami, FL
I have about 10 different shades and use them daily. I've almost completely stopped using powder shadows because these sticks are so convenient and versatile. They are easy to blend, mix together or wear as a solo shade, and they wear for the entire day. Also they are great for travel. They last for about 18 months before they start to dry out. Nudity, Spirit and Burnish are my top 3 shades.
MelR from undisclosed
I find this color to be very dry. Doesn't blend well at all. Tried it a few times. Won't be using it anymore :(
Jo from Eureka, CA
The form and color are great but the stick seems kind of brittle. Maybe too much wax in this formula??
Tess from Virginia
Sadly, the Nudestix Magnetic Eye Color is just not for me. I really wanted to love this product, as I have been looking for the perfect crayon-form eyeshadow to simplify my makeup routine. What I don't love about this product is that it's incredibly hard to blend, even with the use of primer. The crayon is dry and very crumbly. I've tried giving this eyeshadow a few chances, but it has just made my makeup routine more time consuming and frustrating. Bummer!
Easy look for every day
debra b from Tidewater VA
The Nudestix Magnetic Luminous Eye pencil was my first introduction to the brand and I still think it's their best product. It glides on easily - no tugging at delicate skin - and stays on without smudging or creasing. I use the Nudity shade as an all-over quick eye brightener- it's become my must-have for on-camera days (zoom meetings). It adds luminosity without being too shiny, and there's no glitter or flakes to mess with my contacts.
Copper Foil Magnetic Eye Pencil
Kelly D from Windom, MN
Copper Foil is a beautiful color! Love all of the Nudestix eye pencils
Go to eyeliner and shadow
Deb R. from Little Rock, Arkansas
This was my second purchase of taupe ... it's my go-to for eyeliner and shadow, and I also use it on my brows. Perfect for making blue eyes stand out!
Perfect shimmery olive
Anahita from Washington DC
Love the color and how creamy it is. Nudstix shadows are my favorite eyeshadow sticks
I wish I could return it.............
Lisa G from Boston, MA
Very unhappy with this, I wish I could return it. It is very dry, hard to blend and color is not as described, it's dark and flat.
Mackenzie from Missoula, MT
Really happy with how easy this is to use! I honestly wish I had bought more colors because this goes on so well, even as a beginner makeup user, I can make my eyelids look good without even trying!
Lauren from New York
Love the mattes. No other brand can get a matte creme stick like Nudestix. Such a great formula
I like it, but don't love it
gabi from Erie, PA
I bought this a few months back as a way to simplify my makeup routine before work. I purchased the shade "Twilight." After only a couple uses, the eyeshadow broke deep down and fell out of the pencil.. It also doesn't apply as easily as I had hoped. I think I was hoping for a creamier texture.
k575 from Texas
Beautiful shade, smooth application and stays for a long time
Cathy Valenzuela from undisclosed
My product arrived damaged. Difficult return process not worth pursuing.
Almost too good to share (Pink Seychelles)
BabyBird from Florida
I got this in a kit last year or maybe the year before. I loved it. I used it until it was a nub. I looked everywhere for it and tried all the colors that seemed close. I tried other brands that looked similar but no luck. I am so glad you added it to the regular lineup. It is a perfect nude pink with subtle shimmer. I just bought several of these in case they discontinue. Seriously, I cannot imagine this color not being flattering on anyone. I have blond hair, blue eyes and fair skin for the record. I use it for a quick five minute face and for a full face of makeup. I'm almost hesitant to share because what if everyone buys them all up? For real, buy it; you won't be disappointed.
EYE Love this!!
Betsyclaire54 from Wayne, PA
I am such a fan of this creamy stick eyeshadow! It goes on smoothly and lasts all day. Beautiful selection of colors, also.
MR10128 from NYC
Color Terra cannot be beat! Long lasting. Pairs well with several looks.
Was strutting down the street
Katie from New York,NY
So easy to apply and wears great throughout the day I had a new confidence in myself
I really like!
Kat from Texas
Goes on very smooth - love the color!
I do wish this was available in a twist stick rather than having to sharpen.
Spirit Nudestix is the only color i use!
Jenn from Colorado
Love this product! One of the best I've used! Already bought my second one! Thanks!
Will purchase more
Jenn from Memphis
Have a taupe one and burnish. Love them both. Use them under eye as a smokiest shadow eyeliner. Go on easy and come with a sharpener. Will keep adding to my collection.
Great - bring back Army!
ML from New York, NY
Great colors, blendable. But bring back Army! (A perfect khaki green)
fibregirl from Denver, CO
Really pleased with this color. So easy to use and stays pretty.
fibregirl from Denver, CO
Beautiful color, long-lasting, very flattering. HIGHLY recommended!