Rated 3.72 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review HOLY GRAIL!
I can not believe more people aren't talking about these!
They are PERFECTION!
Longlisting, waterproof. You have a moment to smudge and manipulate these, then they set budge proof.
You can use these all over.: Upper lashline, lower lashline, waterline..etc.
The colors are AMAZING! Very vibrant and actually show up on the eyes. They aren't patchy or dry. They don't drag. Super easy to use.
Seriously incredible. I have purchased all the colors over the past few months and I literally have gotten rid of all my other liners.
Most Helpful Critical Review Extremely disappointing/waste of money
I love the idea of long wear. It goes on smooth and creamy and does stay put. However, there's no way to twist the applicator up to get more product and no way to sharpen it as it's in plastic packaging.
In reality you are paying a high price for just the tip of the eyeliner, that will last you about a week if you wear it daily and that's if you are lucky enough for it not to break on you, as it is very soft.. Extremely disappointed in how little product you actually are getting. I feel very mislead and will not purchase this again. I've gotten sample products with more product than this full price/size item provides.
Misleading and feel very cheated.
Reviewed by 127 customers Never wasting $$ on this again. Feel like false advertising.
Estestest from Scottsdale, AZ
Used it daily for 9 days. Liked it, went on smoothly. But now it's just the plastic holder. What you see at the end of the pencil is all you get. Super weird & stingy. Staying away from this brand. There is too much competition in this market to pay for nothing.
Transfers off and doesn't have staying power
Clearwater from Clearwater, Florida
Was hoping to love this.
I'm a fan - it does smudge
Smudge lover apparently from Florida
I'm a fan of these, although they still tend to transfer to my upper lid, that doesn't deter me from using them, the brown brings out the green in my eyes amazingly.
No you cannot sharpen it! The tip is all you get.
sh from ar
No you can NOT sharpen it. Stayed on phone with Ulta over 30 minutes to make sure this was correct. They immediately gave me a refund.....so incredibly disappointing! I did like the wear and easy to apply....
I would buy again
Brenda from Plymouth, OH
Glides on smoothly, lasts
All day! Definitely recommend and will buy again!
Very little product!
Carola from Reedley, CA
I would use it every day if it was not so costly. Will not last very long the way I use it. I loved how it goes on.
doesn't stay put!
SarahEJ from New York
I purchased 2 different colors of this eyeliner to use for daily wear. within 2hrs of wear, the eyeliner had moved to give me huge undereye circles when I used very little product to start with. it does not stay put in low humidity situations even when I used setting products. very disappointed
petgirl30 from NJ
First off, you can sharpen this. It really blows my mind how simple people are. I used my regular old eye/lip pencil sharpener, and magically more eyeliner appeared. It is a full size product, all you have to do is look at the size/ounces. Second, the product itself is pretty good. This stays relatively well in my waterline with minimal smudging. I'm pretty happy with this purchase.
Lasts all day
Pmb15 from Massachusetts
I have tried MANY eyeliners over the years hoping to find one that truly last all day. I teach middle school and put this on at 5:30 am, taught all day, and came home at 5:00 pm and it was still perfect! I have never had an eyeliner capable of making it through a whole day of teaching (you teachers know what I mean!). Love this liner. BTW, you CAN sharpen the pencil with a sharpener.
Nicenurse from Keavy, Ky
This eyeliner is awesome. I'm a nurse and wear full PPE including face shield. Even my favorite eyeliner before this one smeared. This one does not. It stays put. The only fault I have is that it doesn't stay sharpened very long.
My replacement for Marc Jacobs
Alexis from Indiana
I absolutely loved this! It stayed all day and was so pigmented. Killer Chocolate is my favorite
All day cleanup
Jenna from southwest VA
The liner was easy to apply and glided on without any pulling or tugging on the eyelid. However, my BIGGEST pet peeve with liners is transfer. The packaging even says "transfer resistant". I spent the entire day cleaning up transfer from the liner, and the other half looking like I had a weird cut crease.
Reading the Reviews
TLC from Tucson
It blows me away how so many people complain that all you get is the tip. Reading the reviews, so many are stating you HAVE TO USE A SHARPENER on this!!! I am ordering, just to see, for myself how well, long this product lasts when applied. I am POSITIVE it is NOT only the tip, I will use a SHARPENER when needed to get more product!!!
Favorite Nude liner!
Ashley from Anaheim CA
Does eventually wear off but still gets the job done. I knocked off a star because I dont think its worth $20. Essence also carried an eyeliner similar to this thats less than half the price!
Patti from Texas
There is no gel pencil to sharpen! The pencil is only the tip, that's all. You can't twist up any more because the pencil is empty! You are paying for a empty pink plastic tube with nothing inside. This has got to be the biggest rip-off ever!
You can sharpen it lol
Jess from USA
The killer liner I have thats down to a stub is proof of that. This is holy grail and frankly, wayyy better than MUFE liner.
No name from Las Vegas
Perfect for the waterline to add brightness. Long lasting and doesn't hurt to apply in the sensitive waterline.
doesn't stay on
Comes off instantly from Los Angeles
I purchased the nude color but every time I wear it and instantly comes off. I would not recommend this eyeliner
Ari from Yakima, WA
I love the color and the way it blends. I wasn't sure how to sharpen it at first but I used my normal pencil liner sharpener and it worked great. Definitely worth its price.
You can definitely sharpen this.
Dani from Los Angeles
I read another review that talked about the tip being everything you get but you can actually sharpen it. It's very similar to the nyx jumbo liners in terms of sharpening- not your traditional wooden pencil.
With that said, doesn't last 36 hours. But still….pretty good.
Don't buy- sample sized but regular price.
Embolina from Cedar City, Utah
Look at the picture. That tiny tip is ALL THAT YOU GET. You can NOT push it up for more product. You can not sharpen this. Total waste of money. I have never had a Too Faced product I didn't love but with but this one is terrible and is the size of a sample product. I expected to be able to use it for 30 days but it was 4 days. I did like the long wear and glide. Too bad it was so short lived for a big price tag.
Love the colors
Nana J from Ponte Vedra FL
The killer eyeliner did not stay on as it should. I live in Fl and is was pretty much gone in 8
Dee from Lynnwood Washington
I have worn this twice. One day I worked all day at a desk than golfed. 15 hrs later the liner was still perfect.
Today I worked all day at a desk then ran 6 miles. 15 hours later, the liner is still perfect.
The pencil looks like a plastic case but it isn't. You can sharpen it and it shaves off like a wood liner.
It applies easily and the staying power is great.
It came off easily with a creamy cleanser.
Jules13 from Ohio
I have no idea how anyone doesn't love these! I have five shades and they apply smoothly, sharpen well and stay on all day. I have backups of these on hand. They're easily my favorite.
Alicia from CT
This eyeliner doesn't last past a couple hours of wear.