Rated 3.97 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Works on UNDER EYE CIRCLES!
This is one of those products where I was initially happy and over time the slow burn of my love of this amazing pencil grew stronger and stronger.
Works great for:
Highlighting along lash line
Bridge of nose
Concealing under-eye circles!!! The peachy yellow fleshy shade and size is perfect to run that line right along the point where my undereye area sinks in. It STAYS PUT and it doesn't sink into creases. I also use it to mask redness in my nose creases and conceal the bridge of my nose where my glasses and nose strips tend to leave redness.
I have purchased a plethora of concealers and color correctors over the years and this has replaced them all.
The only con I can think of is it takes a little bit of effort to blend, but not too hard considering the staying power of this product.
Most Helpful Critical Review Good Color, but Didn't Last Long
I liked this because it is a great color to open up your eyes without being super noticeable, but I find that it does not last but maybe an hour on my waterline. I tried setting it, but it still disappears really quickly. I will keep using this product though because, well, I spent quite a bit of money on it as well as it is not difficult to reapply. It is one of those colors that won't ruin your eye look if you mess up on reapplying it throughout the day.
Reviewed by 155 customers Did nothing to me either
Tute from Chicago
Returning even though snatched it half price deal but it's useless. Did nothing. Neither felt or looked wide awake lol
Not worth it
Eliza from Michigan
I can't notice a difference! It's like nothing is there. I'm returning mine, not worth the money.
I can see a difference
Tara from Dallas
I love this product! I prefer this Nude color over white because it truly looks more natural.
Destroyed my contact lenses
Hannah from Bozeman, MT
I usually use the drugstore brand nude liners which have worked great. This left oily, blotchy spots on my contacts that obstructed my vision and would not come off with solution and lots of rubbing. Ironic because it says safe for contacts right on the box. Save your money!
Kris from Oklahoma
It looked good for about five minutes then wore off. Loved what it did when I applied it though.
Amber from Kenosha, WI
I am a 31 year old mom and I've been using this for 4 years now. I think I'm on my 11th pencil already? It's a daily use pencil that goes perfectly with my natural makeup look. I look awake and refreshed.z
Andrea from PA
Love this liner.
Not worth the money at all
Carolyn from Missouri
Honestly a lot of the low rated reviews say it all, this product does just about nothing. I was so excited to try it and hopefully have it give me more of an "awake" look but instead it looks like you have pink eye. Its hard to apply and even when you do, you can barely see it and it's gone after a couple minutes. Its just nothing that I expected and the yellow color isn't flattering.
Barbara from Coppell, TX
I use it on my water line to decrease redness. I like the color better than a previous brand I used which was too peachy. It should last a long time, despite the cost.
krnorman from MN
Definitely makes your eyes look brighter! Applies nicely! Would definitely buy again!
Really works well
Vicki from IA
I can't believe that this actually works! So much better than a white pencil. Goes on easily. I love it!
Not worth the money
Kat from Dallas
Not a smooth or creamy type application at all! Pulls at your eye. Can barely see anything IF you do get some of it on.
Adds the oomph I'm looking for
Jessosaurus from Colorado
Love this eye highlighter! Applies very smoothly and blending sponge attached to it works well with the product. Makes my eyes pop :)
I would buy this product again
Nicmarie from New Jersey
I do love this product (I put it on my water line) but the only downfall is that it disappears within a few hours. I'm going to try to line under my bottom lashes and see how that goes.
LOVE LOVE LOVE!!!
Pottsjl0827 from Kentwood, MI
Use on water line and under bottom lash line. Really brightens up your eyes! Wish I would have found this years ago!!! Glides on and has some staying power!
Megan from Alabama
Love this stuff for early mornings
Um... what's this supposed to do again?
April from Knoxville, tn
No directions on the box.. so it's kinda a.. you're on your own. Figure it out. I put it in the corner of my eye, as well as on my water line. Not sure what it's supposed to do.. doesn't seem to really make me look awake.. it's so light that it doesn't even really show up most of the time. I feel like you can get the same effect just using lighter eyeshadow around your eye.
Jessica from Indiana
Pop this on your waterline for an opening effect!
Will purchase again. I love it!
Sweetnbreezy from Port Angeles, WA
This product brightens my eyes perfectly. The color is light and bright without being too much. I've been using it every morning.
Luna from Caldwell, New Jersey
This did nothing for me. Absolutely nothing. Returning it.
Does Not Go On Smooth
Eastcoastncgal from Wilmington, NC
I love the idea of this, I just didn't like the way it went on. It sticks in your eyelashes if you get it too close to them. I felt like it needed to be blended after applied. I feel like I can get the same look with concealer and I already have that in my makeup bag, so I returned this.
Exactly what I was looking for
JW from Virginia
I have been looking for a nude eyeliner for a while to wake up my eyes without being obvious but no other line has a shade like this at my Ulta. It does the job perfectly. However it is officially now the most expensive liner I own. But it does what I want and does not irritate my sensitive eyes so I really cant ask for more.
Jen from Cleveland
Returned this. Wasn't what I wanted it be. It just looked like yellow, thick liner that was uneven from wearing off.
Dan from Ohio
This does exactly what It says It does when I'm wearing It I look more refreshed and awake! It seems to satay on well too not sure if it's water proof but I have allergies so my eyes water a lot and It stays on
J from Ca
Looks brighter. Love all tarte