Product Reviews Rated 3.94 out of 5 stars
232 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Thought I had a problem... Used for a few weeks (loved it!) then began having issuess. Seemed to be dried out as if it were used up...after a few weeks? Kept trying but eventually gave up, filing it away as a lost cause. Months later, came upon it while organizing/tossing old makeup. Couldn't bring myself to get rid of it, then had an idea...(what could I lose?). Got out my brush cleaner, sprayed a bit in my palm. Swirled the tip around, rinsed and dried. Good as new! Those little bristles just got dirty and dried out! So glad I didn't give up on it!!!
Most Helpful Critical Review I half like it, half don't I bought this product in the shade black. First of all, it is not at all black in pigment. It's more like a charcoal gray. That being said, I don't hate the color. Although I like the applicator and the packaging itself, the formula of the product is streaky. When I applied it to my eyes, the color needed to be built up and when I tried to build it up, it rubbed off what I had already drawn. Hopefully that makes sense. It was really difficult to apply. I wore it for a few hours and I did not see too much running but I did notice some chunks that had bunched up and flaked on to my lids. But the liner looked good otherwise. So I'm kinda in the middle about this product; I don't love it, don't hate it. Side note: I heard that the Ultra Black shade is better than the black shade. So I might try that one next time.
Reviewed by 232 customers new favorite! 5
maddie s from Chicago
This is my new favorite eyeliner! I was in love with the Nyx matte liner, and when it was discontinued I had to find something new. This is so good, and it has a super smooth application as long as a super-fine tip for a precise wing! So amazing, I will buy it again and again!
Favorite eyeliner 5
Elaine from NYC
Easy to apply lasting for long time
Fav liquid liner 5
EB from ky
I haven't found a pen liner I like as much this one. It stays put, has good longevity, the product layers well and doesn't crack, and I find the brush tip really easy to use.
Must buy!!!!! 5
Leelo from My
I've been using this liner for over 7 years. Every other liner that I've tried does not compare. Kat von D's liner is similar but doesn't have the same lasting power. I love that you can layer this liner and it won't cake up or crack. The applicator makes it almost impossible to not have crisp thin lines. Make sure you buy "ultra black" though, "black" it's pretty much dark grey.
the brown is super pretty! 5
shannon from mission viejo
its hard to find a liner that is a nice brown shade without being shiny or wearing off. this one has been lovely
Best & affordable eyeliner I have used so far 5
grumpy pandadada from MA
I didn't have high hopes for this eyeliner because most eyeliners smudge on my eyes. Those that don't smudge are difficult to apply. But when I put this PF eyeliner on, it went so smooth! Best affordable eyeliner so far.
Black 2
M from Milwaukee
Very disappointed. I ordered the black and it was more gray than black. Also it was hardly wet.
Go to eyeliner! 5
rye_renee from California
I love this eyeliner. It goes on smooth and the lash boosting serum is a plus. Stays on all day and doesn't smudge. I would recommend this over other prestige brands. One thing I noticed when first using the product is that it first comes out a bit watery/translucent so you have to shake it and push down on the tip lightly so that the product comes out a more darker consistency. The application is flawless after the first initial use.
Worst brown liner ever 1
Kendra from Vegas
It bleeds horribly, takes forever to dry down, and cannot be applied in a thin line. It's also a bright reddish brown, not an espresso brown. It's so bad that I will be returning it.
I am so excited to find this 5
SL from San Francisco
I have tried so many eyeliners (I mean over 20) which claim to be smudge free across from name western branch to J-Beauty brand among Asians. I am trying to find one eyeliner that doesn't make my under eye area look like raccoon/Smokey by the end of day. Also I don't like the type of eyeliner that breaks down into micro powder in my lid by the end of day and makes my eyes painful(you know what I mean if you have used some) For eyeliner test, I usually sleep during the day which makes my eyes closed for a few hours and see if my under eye area are affected. I didn't have any expectation for this cheap drug store eyeliner. But its performance exceeds my expectation! I can't believe there is no single mark or stain on my under eye lid. I don't have smokey under eye anymore! I bought the brown one and it's natural and deep enough to give my eyes a lift. Thank you so much PF.
Just Okay 3
Stormiela from USA
I used this in place of the KVD beauty tattoo liner when a certain brand owner was still running it and it's just okay. I don't find it as long lasting. I've gone back to the KVD one.
Best eyeliner for any eye look 5
Satisfied Customer from Houston, TX
It gives you so much control and just the right amount comes out to create whatever eye look you want that day. It never smudges and lasts for hours.
Great product, but... 2
Melanie from San Diego, CA
I like the product a lot, however it appears I'm allergic or sensitive to this eyeliner. Every time I wear it my eyes are itchy and I know it's this product because every time I stopped using it, the itchiness is gone. It's sad because I liked using it but I don't want my eyes to itch again. I also tried the black one and it did the same thing!
Awesome eyeliner!!! 5
LauLau from Boston, MA
This stuff never dries out!! I'm always thinking it's going to be today, nope. Like shake it up and it's still there. I have deep brown and black. Amazing liquid liner. Easy to use, and it doesn't budge on top of my primer and shadow. I'm super oily too....it's amazing! Stila dried out in 1 month on me. This has been a year!!! Crazy good!!
I would not buy this again. 3
Spring from Tampa, Florida
The color is too light and does not stay on.
Goes on too light. Prefer other brands that stay on longer. 3
Zulema from Tampa, FL
Color is too light. Had to use another brand on top of it.
I returned it. 2
Dana from Long Island, NY
I tried this twice before returning it. The first time I used it it came off especially in the corners after following instructions. I was excited to try a new eyeliner and I admit I am very picky about liquid eyeliners and tend to stick to the Stila tried and true one but am eager to find a cheaper alternative. The color black was very light, dry, and didn't stay put. I thought maybe it was just because of something with my makeup that day so tried again another day and determined I was going to return it sadly. Maybe I just have very oily eyelids so it doesn't work for me. I can't speak for the lash boosting aspect.
Barely any product 1
Ss46 from NY
Was excited for this based on the reviews. Followed instructions and shook before using. Upon applying, barely any product comes out. I have the darkest shade as well and it goes on streaky on clean eyelids. I drew this on several times and it's still very streak—even going over the spots that didn't properly fill in with this liner.
Highly do not recommend and it's more expensive than drugstore eyeliner! Sticking with L'Oréal next time since the liquid liner applies more smoothly and consistently.
Too dry 1
Samira from Cleveland
I don't know if is just mine, but this eyeliner is way too dry. I struggle to make a simple line, so I'm surprised that it has good reviews. It's not worth it at all
by far the best liquid eyeliner I've ever used 5
M from norcal
first off, if you're looking for an eyeliner with intense staying power than this is not going to be for you. I hate waterproof eye products and I like my eyeliner to be easily removable at the end of the day so this has been perfect for me. I've been using this product for almost 4 years now and it has never failed me! I love that it has a brush tip and the formula is super smooth and easy to correct without smudging if you mess up. If I'm out for a while I will reapply because it doesn't have a fantastic staying power, but the precision of the brush and lightweight formula makes up for that in my opinion. m
Wish it worked for me. 3
R C from CA
I wanted to love this product after hearing so much great reviews. Unfortunately, it did not work on my sensitive eyes. Item sweared within an hour after application and does not glide on smoothly has I hope for.
Surprised 1
Krissy from Providence, RI
I rlly don't know how this has such good reviews I'm shocked. This was so bad, I bought "Ulta black" and had to double check if I didn't get brown instead - & nope I didn't it was just super watered down and on top of this it smeared and flaked once dried down. I'm not sure if I just got a bad/old one but I will stick to my KVD tattoo liner & my Stila stay all day. Unless you like your liner to look grey or brown and not super black I say stay away from this. This was not it for me at all.
New favorite! 5
Hijo from Cookeville, TN
It makes a precise, thin, quick line that is perfect for my hooded eyes. Easiest wings from any liner I own (and that includes many high end liners). Love the brown color, it's still sharp, but looks much softer than the usually harsh black liners.
eh 3
jorcha from ny
I did not have any luck with this. You know when you get to the end of a eye liner and you have to keep putting pressure on the tip to get the liquid out, thats what this was like. Its fine to thicken up a lash line but horrible to make a wing (mind you i have hooded eyes) i also think its more of a soft black and not a brown at all.
Goes on smooth 5
Jvholland from Pikeville, Ky
I've tried different brown liquid eyeliners and this one goes on with just the right amount of brown. Other liners weren't nearly dark enough and you couldn't even see them. This one is just right.
