Rated 4.65 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review HIT BY A CAR... BROWS STILL ON FLEEK.
I was hit by a car while out on a run. I walked away with multiple broken bones a broken nose blood everywhere annnd perfect eyebrows. if you are considering getting this product BUY IT. - @chloeoliviamusic
Most Helpful Critical Review Serious Quality Issues
I am writing to you as a loyal customer of your Anastasia Brow Wizard. I have loved this product for many years and have faithfully spent my money purchasing it. However about a year ago or a little over, you changed the plastic you use to make this product. You lengthened the brush side to match the pencil so the user cannot easily tell which end is the brush and which is pencil. I understand that was probably more cost effective. But the worst result of your "cost cutting" is that the brush piece now breaks off after only a few uses. I have now bought 5 new brow wizards and every single one has this problem. You have a quality control issue and I wish you would correct it. I will no longer purchase Anastasia products and I will leave this review on every makeup site where I have purchased your brow wizard until you correct this quality problem. That makeup product is not inexpensive and your customers deserve better.
Reviewed by 19341 customers Don't waste your money
NR from Ohio
I tried this and it's not worth it. It was clearly broken when it arrived because it barely went up and down when I twisted it. And when the color would come out it broke off immediately. The brush on the other end is nice, but it's not a good product overall
Finally found awesome brow pencil!
Laura from Riverside, CA
I love this brow pencil! I used to just use dark eyeshadow and a fine brush but this pencil is much much better! I like that the tip is small so it offers more control over what you fill in. And the brush on the other side of the pencil gives the perfect blend result.
Brooklyn from Illinois
This is the first pencil I have EVER found that matches my hair color. I have light orangey-red hair. Most brow products only have one color option for gingers, which is usually a dark brown auburn that looks ridiculous on me. Brow Wiz in Strawburn is perfect for redheads with lighter color hair! This and Glossier's Boy Brow in Auburn are my holy grails!
jess from Atlanta
I have used this eyebrow pencil for years. I tried to switch to cheaper ones but nothing compares to this. I use dark brown and I get compliments all the time on my eyebrows. I sometimes use the brown gel to hold the hairs in place if it's going to be a long day and after 13 hours my brows look like I just did them! The color doesn't wear away like the NYX dupe that I tried (that started to wear off after like 2 hours). Some of the other reviews say the spoolie breaks and I will say this has happened to me twice now so they must have changed the packaging because it used to never happen. I always stock up when they're on sale because this is a staple that I know I will not be changing.
Best eyebrow pencil I've ever used
Patsy from North Fort Myers , Florence
Best I've ever had for eyebrows and in 70 years I've tried a lot.
Does the job easily
Nana from North Richland Hills, TX
Gets those eyebrows covered quickly and easily.
Not getting the hype
Kim from MA
Purchased two of these eyebrow pencils during the 21 Days of Beauty event.
I'm not sure if I just received a bad batch but it seems like there is good pigmentation and then large sections of just clumps of wax(?). I have to write on my hand with it until the pigmentation comes back.
Perhaps the formula didn't mix properly at the factory but I would not purchase this again. I'm thankful that it was purchased at a deep discounted price.
Mrsbigsky from Wi
I've been buying this eye pencil since it came out. I love the blonde shade. The last three months I've go through two brow pencils. I thought the first one was a fluke. Wrong! This company is charging us the same amount for less product which means you'll be running to the store. Dumb. I'm switching to the NYX pencil.
Only One that I buy
nana from Long Island, NY
long lasting and easy to apply
Less product than usual?
Balloons from Somewhere
I've been buying this product for a couple years now, I use it almost every day and it usually lasts me around 3 months. Last time I bought it was maybe a month ago and I ran out today…maybe i bought a defective product or they are manufacturing less product in the pencil and charging the same price. Either way I think I'll be trying a new product next time if this one is only going to last me a month now after lasting several months in the past.
The perfect taupe. Will definitely buy again.
Tres from Moline, IL
Love it. Easy, precise application and the perfect taupe color!
NurseB from IL
This has non my go to for years but the last 3 pencils have broken at the spoolie. Fix the cheap and/or defective packaging already.
All time favorite
hailey from NY
natural finish, and can last for up to 3 months for me, repurchasing so many times.
Dana D from charleston, sc
nice color selection, easy to use and like that it has a spoolie at the end. I would recommend.
Heyyyy Brow Wiz
Shoelover from Torrance
I enjoy majority of ABH products. However, I've noticed my pencils don't last long, like I'm missing product. I'm not heavy handed nor do I apply daily brows. Hoping for more product within pencil!
Uhm, yes ma'am.
Peggy from San Diego
Started using the pencil instead of pomade because it was making me lose brow hairs, the pigment is so nice and so smooth as it goes on, I always do my brows first. I've used the same pencil for 8 months, and I use it everyday. I go for a softer brow look though, nothing to heavy or super filled in.
red-headed, matches perfectly.
Irish Princess from New Bern, NC
I have red hair, and you can never ever find an eyebrow pencil that actually looks natural for redheads, they're blonde there Brown they're black there Auburn, I bought the color Strawburn, absolutely matches my hair perfectly, it went on easily I was able to fill my brows and they look beautiful. I love it! I'm 63, sometimes it's hard to find a brow product that you can have look natural during the day, or give you some drama at night, but doesn't look fake. This is the ticket. Went on easily, field nicely, the spoolie at the end was very very nice and easy to use.
I love the slate color for me and the color goes on easily.
Granma G from Medford, Wi
I have grey hair so the slate color is perfect and you don't find that color very often.
Excellent Brow liner
Carley B from Detroit, MI
Product apply a smoothly covers well aswell as leaves sharp crisp edges, low smudges
Does the job but expensive
KW from Thousand Oaks
Goes on smoothly & covers well
The most natural looking color for light blondes
KJ from Orlando
Most natural looking eyebrow pencil for light blondes. I like the fine point
Lauren from PA
As far as I'm concerned this is the only brow pencil worth buying and using. It has great functionality, looks great, feels great and looks natural. It's so easy to use and I always get compliments on how great my brows look.
good brow pencil
hailey from new york
i don't know if there are better pencils out there but this one is really good, it's consistent and a good pencil even though it's pricy
Jody from Tennessee
I like to do my brows after foundation so I can clean up my brows with concealer. I could not get any pigmentation to apply because the pencil was just dragging and picking up what foundation I had on. I tried doing brows before foundation and I'm still not a huge fan. I've tried cheaper products that do a lot better.
Do I even need to leave a review?
Shelby from Kentucky
You already know this is amazing