Product Reviews Rated 4.65 out of 5 stars
19401 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review HIT BY A CAR... BROWS STILL ON FLEEK. I was hit by a car while out on a run. I walked away with multiple broken bones a broken nose blood everywhere annnd perfect eyebrows. if you are considering getting this product BUY IT. - @chloeoliviamusic
Most Helpful Critical Review Serious Quality Issues I am writing to you as a loyal customer of your Anastasia Brow Wizard. I have loved this product for many years and have faithfully spent my money purchasing it. However about a year ago or a little over, you changed the plastic you use to make this product. You lengthened the brush side to match the pencil so the user cannot easily tell which end is the brush and which is pencil. I understand that was probably more cost effective. But the worst result of your "cost cutting" is that the brush piece now breaks off after only a few uses. I have now bought 5 new brow wizards and every single one has this problem. You have a quality control issue and I wish you would correct it. I will no longer purchase Anastasia products and I will leave this review on every makeup site where I have purchased your brow wizard until you correct this quality problem. That makeup product is not inexpensive and your customers deserve better.
Reviewed by 19401 customers My Favorite Brow Pencil—It's the Best 5
GracefulBrows from Florida
When it comes to makeup, brows are my specialty. I spent the majority of 2021 trying all new things out because I simply wasn't happy with my brow routine. Whether it was the color, undertone, the consistency, the quality, the price—nothing seemed that great. I just continued using a basic pencil. Then it all changed when Christmas came and I received the Anastasia Bae-sic brow set in Dark Brown which included (2) Brow Wiz and (1) mini Clear Brow Gel. I have tried the Anastasia Pomade in 2016-2017 and it was my absolute favorite at the time so I was super excited to try this. Upon trying it, I was obsessed. It literally transformed my brows. Any time I have ever done my brows, I never mess them up or have a bad brow day. These pencils are such good quality. I will never buy anything else again. I will buy more when the gift sets come out.
I love the color! 5
Janeane from Pocatello
Once warmed up, the pencil adds the perfect amount of color. I love the new Strawburn color. Finally my brows match the copper of my hair!
Great brows 5
J S from Cconroe, Tx
Love this product for defining brows. Easy to work with, great color. Needs no sharpening.
Favorite eyebrow pencil 4
Missy from Midlothian Tx
This is a terrific pencil. It has a fine point and makes tracing the eyebrows and fillig them in super easy. Will continue to buy and recommend. Love it!
The best 5
I love vacations from Midwest
What can I say- this is the best brown detail pencil, others have tried to emulate but cannot imitate. The color selection is also great. I use it to fill any sparse areas of the brow and to define.
Design problem but would buy again 3
JP from Bend, Oregon
Again - great product, but needs too much TLC before ends caps won't stay on.
my holy grail 5
gg from tx
i have used up at least 20 of these in my life. this is the best brow pencil on the market and i will continue to purchase it over and over again
SO AMAZING 5
Emme from Tennessee
This product is heavenly.
So easy! 5
ShopperStephanie from Kendallville. IN
I got this as a free sample and absolutely love it. I've always hated doing my eyebrows but this product makes it so simple. My only complaint is that it wipes off very easily so I have to try not to touch my eyebrows throughout the day or reapply.
Broke 2
Kbakker from SD
I was super disappointed in this purchase. I've only used a couple times and 1) felt it was hard to apply…as far pressure to get color & 2) it broke in my makeup bag…in its case! Bummed about what I received versus what I paid.
Wonderful brows 4
Native American Female from Sacramento
The use is well worth the price but I am needing to buy two at a time.
Just so good 5
Audrey from Madison
I've tried other pencils to try to save money, but I keep going back to this one. The formula and color are just right for me, it's not even worth trying others any more. Brow Wiz for life.
I love it 5
tonksfan:) from Texas
I tried this yesterday and it worked soooo well I have sparse and thin eyebrows and this helped me create my perfect brows they were fluffy an hair like and perfect.
Very pleased - will buy again 5
Terri from New Haven, CT
I have salt and pepper hair. The ash brown blends nicely with hair and olive complexion.
Changed the formula 3
Bunny from San Diego
This has been my favorite brow pencil for a long time but they did change their formula the new formula is waxy and doesn't go on the same so I've been using an old one till it runs out and then I have to find a new favorite:(
keep going back to it 5
ggggg from florida
the brow wiz in taupe is amazing and the perfect shade for my blonde hair. i keep trying cheaper alternatives and never like them as much as i love the brow wiz. it's worth the extra $ and it lasts so long for me!
Smooth 5
Mary from East Los Angeles
I adore how thin it is and I'm able to do any size or shape of eyebrow.
Used to love this 1
RH from ATL
Been using this for years but I recently bought a new one and it's so hard to blend
Pencil came out of tube 2
MMW from Philadelphia
I have used this for many years (ash brown) but find myself disappointed in this purchase. The ink/ pencil cartridge came out of the apparatus and just really annoyed me because there is no saving it after that. For the price point this should be a better quality product. I don't know if I bought an old pencil, if it was an Ulta stock issue or if ABH needs to up their quality control but it was disappointing.
I'm sure I will try buying this again in the future but if I have another problem I will return it and not purchase this item again.
Perfect color 5
BeachTeach from Orchard Park, NY
I use it to fill in my brows when going out. It goes on smoothly and easily. It matches perfectly to my hair color.
Best on the market 5
Arod from New York
I love buying a darker and lighter tone to create a more natural look or dimension, using the darker color to fill in and lighter around the edges.
Classic brow product 5
Natasha from USA
I'm still pretty new to doing anything to my brows. These days, I tend to use brow products to fill them in if they're left looking light and faded after I apply foundation and setting powder to my face. I'm sure a drugstore brow pencil would serve me just as well to get that done, but still, I enjoy this one by ABH. The tip is very thin, so it makes nice hairlike strokes, and it's also a soft formula, so I don't have to press the pencil hard to draw anything in. The brush end is super useful for getting the hairs just how I want them.
I have used this for the past 10 years 5
Rosie from San Marcos Ca
I use this on my eye brows.
STRAWBERRY BLONDE GET THIS 5
Katherine from Pittsburgh
I got the shade strawburn for light red hair and let me tell you it has changed my life. I have never found a shade to match my naturally strawberry blonde hair but this matches perfectly and I will never buy another pencil again. I may have to buy more just in case they stop making it which I hope they never do. It's literally Perfect.
Just ok. 2
Sera from FL
Not as great as described from another customer.
