Product Reviews Rated 3.93 out of 5 stars
92 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review FINALLY!!! I have been searching for this my entire makeup-wearing life. I have pretty long lashes, but they are board-straight and grow at a downward angle, so nothing has ever kept them curled... until now. I use a lash curler in the morning before I apply my single coat (that's all you really need with this mascara, tbqh), and I am good to go. Side note: this mascara doesn't really seem to GIVE you curl (that is why I still use my lash curler), but it absolutely holds the curl all day long once you get it. Also, it is allergy season and my eyes are super sensitive, and this didn't irritate them, which is a feat in and of itself. Highly recommend, I literally have no need for another mascara.
Most Helpful Critical Review brush is super huge! I bought this online and when I opened it and saw the humongous brush head I was actually disappointed. I can manage a brush like the BTS mascara, but this one made the application more challenging. It also smears on the top when applying. I am typically careful and take my time when putting on my makeup especially mascara, but this one takes more effort and despite the brush head size it is difficult to cover lashes evenly because it is too big and fluffy, I did get length and lashes look dark. I used about 2 coats and did clump up a bit. I will add that it was easy to remove. I will try again a few times, but may return it if I continue to need extra time to apply in order to avoid smearing my entire eye area
Reviewed by 92 customers Incredible Volume 5
Makeupfan from Kingston, ny
Incredible! Makes your lashes thick and long...loved it!
Thick lovely lashes! 5
Foofie from North wales PA
Thick long lashes
It's my top 3 5
Angel from Arizona
One of my biggest complaints about mascara is that I lose the curl after a couple of hours and my eyelashes are back to laying flat. This is one of the few that are able to keep up and hold the curl for at least most of an eight hour shift. Rule of thumb for me is to not do more than one coat on the bottom lashes and a little goes a long way.
No 2
Powerhouse from Westwood Ma
Would never buy again , used only 3 times I think I'll return as it's scary to use : I've tried all mascaras I believe this is the the most difficult to use. As I love all Stella Products
Sooo good 5
Haley from Chicago
I am the pickiest person with mascara! After trying maannnnny mascaras, I resort to ONLY Thrive causementics and L'oréal Telescopic. I received the travel size of this mascara in my monthly birch box and I honestly wasn't expecting much from it. I was so wrong! It's soooo good! Definitely a thickening mascara rather than a lengthening mascara. Also, this is the blackest mascara I've ever used! Buying the full size tomorrow
Not the best mascara 1
Carol the makeup freak from Florida
The brush on this mascara is way too fat. The formula clumps & smudges. Did not like it at all.
I love this mascara 5
Love love love! Must have mascara! from Covina, CA
I love this mascara! It definitely adds tons and tons of volume and length to my lashes. The brush is big but it definitely helps for the added volume. I've literally tried every mascara claiming extreme volume and none have done what this mascara has! I have tried to use other mascaras after using this one and they just don't compare. I have to rebuy and stick to what works!
Only mascara I use now 5
yancaxo from Hershey, PA
I already have long lashes, but I like the extreme, voluminous look. I've tried SO many hyped-up mascaras that supposedly are better (Tarte Lights Camera Lashes, Too Faced Better Than Sex, Benefit roller lash, Benefit they're real, etc) and somehow this is still my favorite. One coat alone looks amazing and when I wear two coats or more I've been asked if they're fake. 10/10 needs more hype.
The brush is huge as others have said, but it isn't anything unmanageable.
Long lash mascara 5
Karla from Bryant Ar
Lengthens lashes
Don't understand the hype 2
Katie from Minnesota
An Ulta employee with huge eyelashes recommended this mascara to me. I thought, alright I'll give it a try. I do not like the brush, as it makes precise application very hard and actually clumped my eyelashes together (even when I combined it with my fine-tooth mascara wand to try and separate lashes). The formula is also very wet, which makes it prone to dripping below my lower lashes. I will say that as I continued to use it and there was less mascara on the wand, the drippage issue became less prevalent. Two stars.
Stila mascara rocks! 5
Dog mama Katie from Jersey Shore
Use it daily, lasts for months, so with it!
For Big Eyes Only 5
Scarlet Says from Houston, TX
I've read the reviews and have some advice for the "cons". I have really big eyes and long light brown/blonde lashes. This mascara adds the color and definition that I want. Yes, the brush is big which means you can't use it in the same manner as a small brush. With a smaller brush I have to brush and brush and brush to get all of lash area. With this brush I tilt my chin up and look straight ahead, not up, to apply with just 2 strokes. If you look up, you will get it on your brow. I don't have a smudge issue since I don't use this mascara on my bottom lashes, ( I prefer the false eyelash look).
Terrible! 1
Lady Lawyer from Rochester, MI
Horrible! I wore this mascara for approximately 5 hours and began looking like a raccoon around hour 2. Flakey and smears all over. My under-eye area is well set with concealer + setting powder but even that was not enough to prevent this from smudging all over. Do not waste your money!
I would NEVER EVER buy this again! 1
Sorry from Atlanta, ga
This is THE worst mascara I have ever purchased. I love the Stila eyeliner and mistakingly thought their mascara might be good. Should have done more research...the worst! Wand is huge and brush way too big and the product is gooey and horrible...ugh...money wasted. Do not buy it.
Absolute NO 1
NNharb64 from Birmingham, AL
This mascara was absolutely horrible for me. First of all, it's very flaky, to the point it flaked all day long, keeping my eyes very irritated. And then there's the HUGE brush......I really don't understand why cosmetic companies have gotten on this "huge" mascara brush bandwagon. IMO, a truly good mascara does not have to hide behind a good brush. Our eye area and lashes aren't very big to begin with, so a huge brush just makes a mess. All you need is a good product and a well made brush. So, I have gone back to my favorite which is the Huge Extreme Lash, also by Stila - it beats this one hands down IMO.
Smudges and doesn't add length 1
Janelle from California
I do not like this mascara at all. Right when I put it on, I found it to be not as lengthening as my Maybelline mascara. I decided to not judge it and just see how it wears. At the end of the night, I looked in the mirror and it was all over the under area of my eye... smudged like crazy!! I will definitely be sticking to maybelline which is less than half the price of this mascara and adds more length without smearing.
Not for me 2
KAT from Li
I think the brush is too big. It didn't seem as dark to me. I do like stila huge mascara much more.
Mascara! 4
Staci from OR
Starting over after 20 years with makeup and I love this mascara
My new Go To Mascara 5
Ineed2shop from Nashville TN
This mascara has some type of moisturizer as it goes on smooth. The mascara elongate the lashes and it doesn't clump. Long wear and doesn't smudge.
My new favorite 5
EveryDayIsAGift from Las Vegas, NV
This mascara is all I use now. I've tried dozens from Lancôme to Urban Decay, and this is the best I've found. It doesn't flake and smear, which is my #1 problem with with most mascaras that create volume and length. The oversized brush was a challenge my first try, but I got the hang of it fairly quickly and I am far from a pro at makeup application.
If you haven't tried this yet, you really should. It's worth every penny, and I will recommend it to everyone.
AMAZING BEST MASCARA EVER 5
Sam from Pa
Amazing! Looks like you are wearing false lashes! The brush is big and intimidating but it doesn't even touch your skin! The brush just grabs every lash and leaves no smears on your eyelids! Love it!
Great mascara!! 5
Cguz from Houston
My new holy Grail! Gives my lashes length and volume!
Great product 5
Charlotte from Huntsville Alabama
I got a travel size as a free gift when I shopped at the store so I gave it a try and I absolutely love it it gets every lash it makes them look longer and fuller the brush even gets my bottom lashes which I've always had trouble with the brush getting them at the bottom because it's so small down there but this was a great product I will be going in to get a regular size products of mascara even though it's almost $25 I feel like it is a good product and hopefully it will last a long time
C
Best mascara in years 5
Stacie from Dallas
This mascara is amazing. Has a huge round brush gets every lash. The lashes look stunning. I'm constantly asked if they are my real lashes!
Amazing 5
Baren from Ohio
This amazing mascara literally gives sooo much volume with one swipe !!! Omg I get so many compliments. It's way better than two face better then sex! I love it. I don't even apply to lower lash because my tops look so freaking amazing !
