Product Reviews Rated 3.84 out of 5 stars
111 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review FINALLY!!! I have been searching for this my entire makeup-wearing life. I have pretty long lashes, but they are board-straight and grow at a downward angle, so nothing has ever kept them curled... until now. I use a lash curler in the morning before I apply my single coat (that's all you really need with this mascara, tbqh), and I am good to go. Side note: this mascara doesn't really seem to GIVE you curl (that is why I still use my lash curler), but it absolutely holds the curl all day long once you get it. Also, it is allergy season and my eyes are super sensitive, and this didn't irritate them, which is a feat in and of itself. Highly recommend, I literally have no need for another mascara.
Most Helpful Critical Review brush is super huge! I bought this online and when I opened it and saw the humongous brush head I was actually disappointed. I can manage a brush like the BTS mascara, but this one made the application more challenging. It also smears on the top when applying. I am typically careful and take my time when putting on my makeup especially mascara, but this one takes more effort and despite the brush head size it is difficult to cover lashes evenly because it is too big and fluffy, I did get length and lashes look dark. I used about 2 coats and did clump up a bit. I will add that it was easy to remove. I will try again a few times, but may return it if I continue to need extra time to apply in order to avoid smearing my entire eye area
Reviewed by 111 customers Soooo baddddd 1
Sam from San Diego
Seriously. It's not even about the price. But this is by far the most horrible mascara I have ever come across. It's super messy to apply, due to the fat wand. But it flakes uncontrollably after drying a couple minutes. I mean flakes everywhereeee! I try new mascaras constantly and this one just really sucked.
Do not buy 1
Darla from New Braunfels
Was told this product was not clumpy and smooth application. The employee was wrong. Ulta should educate employees on products.
Flakes 2
Yevecast from RGV
Makes my lashes thick dark and w volume. Although even tho I set my concealer w setting powder i still get smudges under my eyes makes me look like a raccoon
The Worst.. Ever 1
Emily from Harrisburg, PA
I love Stila eyeliner so I thought I would stray from my usual Urban Decay Perversion mascara and give this a whirl, the idea of the larger brush was super appealing. Unfortunately this is by far the worst mascara I have ever attempted to use. It's so clumpy you can't get a single stroke of clean application, most of the time is spent trying to even out the little clumps of product hanging off your lashes. It also comes off immediately with any introduction to sweat or water. Save yourself the trouble and buy $6 Covergirl if you want this quality.
This mascara didn't work for me 2
ABCS from New Orleans
I was excited to try this mascara unfortunately it did not work for me. The formula was too heavy and clumped no matter what I did. Also the brush is too big.
Love love 5
MomJoe from Pataskala, Ohio
I use this everyday. I received a sample in the mail and fell in love. The best mascara I have ever used. My lashes were so soft, it didn't flake. It's a bit pricey and doesn't last as long as I would like it to for as much as I use it but I will keep buying it.
Love this 5
C. Fry from Lima,Ohio
Makes my lashes thick and long! Absolutely love this product
Raccoon 1
G from Chicago
I use this product on a normal daily basis. Unfortunately it bleed under my eyes. I noticed the mascara flaking from my lashes at times and leaving particles of mascara on my skin
New Fav!!! 5
Sandy from Dallas Texas
I have tried numerous different mascara and I love this one!!!
Best mascara ive tried 5
Jackieee from Texas
This is one of the best mascara i have tried. It stays on all day and is dark black without the million coats. The brush does clump a little but that can easily be fixed. The only thing i would change is the price, but well worth it!
Favorite mascara so far 4
MirandaA from Birmingham
Gives volume to my light sparse lashes. I really like it! Only con is that sometimes it gets gummy before it runs out. For the most part tho, little to no clumping.
good for full lashes! 4
Haley from Kansas City
This mascara is super good for DARK full lashes! I will say that application is pretty messy (on me at least) due to the thickened of the wand but your lashes look feathery and full after you clean up. This mascara is SUPER black too. I didn't give it 5 stars because I have noticed this mascara smudges if you use it on bottom lashes
Real falsies in a bottle!! 5
G from Pennsylvania
I use this mascara everyday and work long shifts! (12 hours) never have any flaking! This is the best mascara I have ever tried in my life! And I've tried many high end mascaras from nars, to Dior, lancome, better than sex, urban decay, they're real, you name it! This literally gives the look of false lashes and I'm hoping they never stop making this! One coat and your good to go or you can even layer it up hours later for a party and you will get insanely long lashes!
Love this Mascara 5
Reena from Los Angeles, Ca
I've been using Stila Huge Mascara for a couple years, I have always loved it. I received the magnum as a sample. Immediately feel in love and made the switch over to it. All the women in my life will be getting this for Christmas this year.
I would not buy this product again 1
Tania from Fall River,Ma
I wouldn't buy this product again. I only apply to upper lashes and should not have it smudge to my under eyes. Looks awful!
Doesn't flake and great lash definition 5
Budgeting Mom of 4 from Minnesota
STILA Magnum XXX is by far my personal favorite and worth the price. I have used many top line brands such as Too Faced, Urban Decay, Bare Minerals, Better Than Sex, but they always seemed to flake by the end of the day. In my experience, this does not flake or clump, and also has great lash definition. Do not let the thicker brush throw you off, it is terrific!
Would not buy 2
DJ from Omaha
Attempting to use this mascara and it's just so clumpy and messy. Do not recommend
Love this mascara 5
Hannah from Columbus, OH
not too thick. and makes the lashes look extra full
I love the full lashes and big brushes 5
Patricia from Tulsa ok
I bought the travel size and loved it! I had to go back and get it for me and my daughter, they were sold for weeks at the 41st store so I drove to 71st to get it
Incredible Volume 5
Makeupfan from Kingston, ny
Incredible! Makes your lashes thick and long...loved it!
Thick lovely lashes! 5
Foofie from North wales PA
Thick long lashes
It's my top 3 5
Angel from Arizona
One of my biggest complaints about mascara is that I lose the curl after a couple of hours and my eyelashes are back to laying flat. This is one of the few that are able to keep up and hold the curl for at least most of an eight hour shift. Rule of thumb for me is to not do more than one coat on the bottom lashes and a little goes a long way.
No 2
Powerhouse from Westwood Ma
Would never buy again , used only 3 times I think I'll return as it's scary to use : I've tried all mascaras I believe this is the the most difficult to use. As I love all Stella Products
Sooo good 5
Haley from Chicago
I am the pickiest person with mascara! After trying maannnnny mascaras, I resort to ONLY Thrive causementics and L'oréal Telescopic. I received the travel size of this mascara in my monthly birch box and I honestly wasn't expecting much from it. I was so wrong! It's soooo good! Definitely a thickening mascara rather than a lengthening mascara. Also, this is the blackest mascara I've ever used! Buying the full size tomorrow
Not the best mascara 1
Carol the makeup freak from Florida
The brush on this mascara is way too fat. The formula clumps & smudges. Did not like it at all.