Product Reviews Rated 3.54 out of 5 stars
307 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Great and a nice size It makes my eyelashes better than anything ive had before including smashbox etc. I love it and it seems like the handle is longer than my normal ones which is a nice touch. Add dimension volume its wonderful.
Most Helpful Critical Review Bring back flawless definition mascara!!!!! I got this in a holiday kit and it is the worst! It's clumpy and goopy and takes forever to dry. I love bare minerals and use many of the products religiously. The fact that so many of my favorite products, like flawless definition mascara in espresso, keep getting discontinued is beyond frustrating! What is even worse is there are no viable alternatives that can replace the quality. I am afraid I will be purchasing mascara elsewhere from now on, which is even more frustrating because I loved the convenience of getting everything I needed on auto delivery. Anyway, end rant. Bottom line, don't waste your money on this mascara! It really is a bad product
Reviewed by 307 customers A Staple in my Cosmetic Bag 5
LAD1 from Florida
Clean, volume building mascara that is easy on the eyes. I wear contacts and have to be thoughtful about what I put next to my eyes.
Great mascara which thickens and lengthens 5
Schnickerfritz from undisclosed
I really like this mascara! It thickens and lengthens my lashes to a dramatic size. I look like I'm wearing false lashes if I really build It up.
It doesn't smudge or smear.
Gets clumpy fast 3
teebsfor68 from Dover DE
Color is nice however it seems to clump rather quickly on the brush. I feel like not even a week in I have to be brushing it on the sides as I remove it from the tube. Not my favorite that's for sure.
Love it 5
Kamjack from Powell TN
I love bate minerals foundation so I thought I would try the mascara. Absolutely love it. My lash have never looked so long. Also I wear contacts and others mascaras have bothered my eyes but this one does not. Love the brush and it goes on great!
Shocked! 5
Leighlahfionna from Tennessee
I'm shocked! This is the bomb. I thought it would be horrible. I received it as a birthday gift. Will be buying more.
i love 5
syd23 from san francisco
i really like this mascara..... very soft and easy to remove, therefore feels very healthy and natural for my eyelashes! The tube is also much cheaper than other mascaras if you compare the ounces! (i.e. glossier or milk makeup)
Love Hate 3
Baileeeb from undisclosed
I received this mascara as a Christmas present and at first I really loved it. It didn't clump and looked nice on. After awhile though I noticed that when I pulled the brush out, there was too much on it and I had to scrape some off on the top of the bottle before I could use it. Because of this, some crusts and dries around the opening so it gets pretty messy. I don't think I would buy it although I had no issue while actually wearing it.
Yes 5
Don't have one from Odessa, Texas
Does not irritate my eyes which is a plus.
Not for Contact Lens Wearers 1
msjennks from Kansas City, MO
This mascara flakes into the eye when it dries down after application and feels like tiny shards of glass in my eyes. If you wear contacts, this is not the mascara for you.
I would buy this product again 5
Angie from New Jersey
This is the best mascara I have ever tried.Very natural looking when applied
wonderful, big lashes 5
L.A. from L.A.
I'm surprised this doesn't get better reviews, definitely works to make my little, short lashes look thick, long and wonderful!
Disappointed 2
beth899 from Ohio
I was so excited to try this mascara. It went on nicely and looked great. No matter what I do it flakes off and specks of it end up in my eyes. It is a nightmare for contact lens wearers like myself. I tried it for at least a month and couldn't take it anymore. Sadly I bought a 2 pack so one will be going in the trash. What a waste of money.
Best Mascara 5
mfeldma from Corvallis, OR
I bought this when it first came out, and yes the applicator is large and it took a while to be able to apply it without making a mess, but it really volumizes and lengthens my lashes plus it keeps them soft so less breakage!
No Stars.. 3
Justine from Florida
I am a big fan of Bare Minerals products but they failed with this mascara..
It goes on ok, gave me full lashes but turns very flakey and by the end of the day it just crumbles away?! I was actually excited for this when it first came out - bought a full big bottle of it thinking I'd have no issue but after numerous uses I had to stop bc I have some sort of reaction to the product in which it makes my eyes water & run, makes them puffy red & irritated..
I have used BM products for over 13+ years now but something is very different with this mascara.. I do not recommend.
Not what I expected! 1
Deb61 from Brandon,MS
I thought it would make my lashes look longer and thicker but it doesn't.
really adds to lashes 3
Pickypatty from Winchester, KY
It really does a good job adding to lashes....but it needs to come in waterproof. It makes my eyes water, so must be allergic to it, and then my mascara runs and gets black all over my under eyes and cheeks. PLEASE bring back the waterproof mascara that you had! I was not allergic to it.
Great product. 4
Cynthia47 from Rabun county ga
I love it .it goes on real easy you dont have to fight with it.
Something is wrong! 1
RR from Kansas
Though the container was sealed, upon the first use, the mascara seemed dried out. I plan to contact Ulta to see what happened.
Obsessed 5
Jacqueline1 from Seattle,WA
Since the day I asked one of my customers what mascara she's wearing I was obsessed!This mascara transforms your eyes. The formula itself is amazing. It's not waterproof but it sure does not smudge under the eyes. The color is a perfect black it does not turn grey after applying coats. I love that the formula is a bit thick and not runny because you have an instant fuller lash after application! You're able to go as light and as bold as you want with this mascara! I've hit the bottom of this mascara two times now! The applicator is a bit wide/ big I do wish it was a bit thinner, but overall I love it!
Natural formula, long-lasting, moisturizing: LOVE 5
bitsyc from Lehigh Valley, PA
I'm so surprised to see the rather low reviews of this mascara. I have tried so many natural mascaras and this one is by far the best. It makes my lashes look full, long, feel moisturized...and it lasts, even through sweaty workouts. I love everything about this mascara.
Bring back brown 1
Disappointed 523 from undisclosed
I've been using this make up for more than 20 years and they discontinued the brown color mascara I've always used. I do not like the black for myself and it's quit messy. I really don't want to use any other brand...bring back brown!
Great mascara 5
MoJo from FL
First mascara that actually makes my lashes look thick and long! I've worn mascara for many years, but never had this great coverage
I would buy this product again 4
Alice from Spokane Wa
Great mascara
Bare Minerals fall short of their usual quality 1
Spurling from Greenwood, IN
I am usually 100% brand-loyal to Bare Minerals. For any cosmetic needs I have, I always look for it from Bare Minerals first. I bought this mascara with high hopes and I was supremely disappointed. From the very first use, the formula was thick and clumpy. Each application was a mess and even after a few weeks of hoping it would get better, I finally gave up and threw it in the trash. I am so disappointed!
Favorite 5
MadelineD from Evansville, IN
I have used this mascara for the past two years and have had zero issues! No clumping, it doesn't bunch my eyelashes together, it doesn't smudge (unless you rub it for ten minutes straight, lol), and it shapes my lashes nicely. Lasts a long time too. My favorite mascara by far.
