Rated 4.11 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Fabulous! Please give us a Black Coffee color!
I loved the B&B twist up liners from a few years back. Couldn't wear the Round The Clock liners because some ingredient made my eyes sting. Plus they were dry and clumpy after the first pencil sharpen. This Lasting Line liner is better than either of the previous pencil liners. Consistency is smooth, no tugging, you have time to smudge it before it sets, and it really does have staying power. My only complaint....I really need a Black Coffee color to replace my favorite B&B color. Not black, not as light as Lasting Brown, but a true dark coffee color. Pretty Please?
Most Helpful Critical Review Non-Lasting Eyeliner - Please Bring Back Round-The-Clock!!
I used the "Round the Clock" liners for several years and loved them. They were the only true "long-lasting" liner pencils I ever found at any price point. Now that they apparently are discontinued I assumed this product would be as good or better.....WRONG!! I have used Bare Minerals brand for at least 10 years - foundations, make up, brushes - and love the quality as well as the look, feel, and positive effects on my skin. But, these pencils were a big disappointment and a total waste of money. Sad to say that I purchased them at Sephora, so I doubt I can return for a refund or exchange. The two I purchased were the orchid and the charcoal shades and they will be thrown out. I tried them on bare skin with the same sorry result - thinking that maybe my moisturizer had caused the problem. I have tried the powder and liquid eyeliners as well, but the shape of my eyes plus the fine, crepey texture of my lids just doesn't work with them compared to the pencils. To the Product Team at Bare Minerals: PLEASE BRING BACK THE ROUND-THE-CLOCK EYELINERS!!!
Reviewed by 846 customers GOOD SUBSTITUTE LINER
JUJU from IN
WOULD. LIKE TO HAVE A CHOICE BETWEEN THICK LINE AND FINER LINER. TOLD PREVIOUS THINNER LINE NOT AVAILABLE.
Tyanna from Tennessee
Eyeliners usually burn my eyes throughout the day. This brand is the only one that doesn't make me tear up and burn. I love Bare Minerals!
Andie from New york
I buy multiples. Use a few colors
California native from California
This is a great liner, I ran out and bought another brand that was dry, didn't apply and crumbled. I will stick with this one.
Long lasting no smudge
Cdig7 from Warwick, RI
Daily use, lasts 7am through 7pm, even through sweaty workouts!!
I would buy this product again.
KK from Surprise, AZ
I only use Bare Mineral produces and have for over 25 years. Love Love Love this product.
Maryd from Hyattsville MD
use it daily to enhance my eyes
This is a great smudge proof liner
Rose from North Strabane Township PA. 15317
It is a good value eyeliner. I like that it is waterproof.
I love this eyeliner because it goes on smoothly.
None from Torrance, CA
Nothing bad about it. All good!
Hiker from Oregon
Lasted about 2 hours. Not long lasting at all.
So smooth eyeliner
JK from Fremont CA
I have fair skin and blonde hair color. The Always Charcoal is a perfect match, not too harsh. It is my everyday eyeliner.
Annette from New york
This is the only eyeliner I use now. No raccoon eyes.
Kathy from San Antonio
Sometimes different colors are varying levels of density. Mine is bronze. Possibly just trouble with that one.
This is not a long-wearing
Betty nick from florida
This expensive eyeliner was one of the worst I have used , lasted less than 30 minutes
TripletMom from MI
The bronze is a great option for me due to fair/warm skin tone and blonde hair. Don't feel overdone, but eyes are accented nicely. Love that they have a smudger and sharpener included.
Jo Jo from Texas
It's a great eyeliner
Lexi from Forney, tx
Love this eyeliner. Super easy to apply and does not smear! Highly recommend!!!
Spinny from Salt Lake City, Ut
I expected product to last at least as long as drugstore brand I currently use, but it wears off almost immediately! Bare Minerals should probably continue to focus on their foundations and skin care.
This is my favorite go to eyeliner
Jules from Indianapolis
See Pro's above
Love this eyeliner
MrsD from Atlanta, GA
I've been using BareMinerals eyeliner for years and will continue to. It is very easy to use and applies smoothly. I wear contacts and some eye products irritate my eyes but this does not. I would recommend it.
Bruna from Texas
Mu eyes are super sensitive and I have allergies so I was concerned to buy online without trying first but worked fine and I do recommend
Easiest eyeliner I've ever put on, even for hooded eyes
Antonia, BSN, RN from WA
For my 33rd birthday, I bought myself all new makeup and decided on bareMinerals because of their clean ingredients and are vegan. I suck at putting on eyeliner and found this really easy to put on, didn't drag on my lid at all. I have hooded eyes so it's really hard for me to put on eyeliner and this was perfect. I am impressed!
Full product list used in my review photo, of which I gave all products 5 stars:
bareMinerals Hydrating Foundation Stick in shade Buttercream 03,
bareMinerals Endless Glow Highlighters in colors Free and Fierce (used as a bronzer),
bareMinerals Gen Nude liquid eyeshadow in Sunstone,
bareMinerals Lasting Line long-wearing eyeliner in absolute black,
bareMinerals lip gloss in shade Spark Plug.
Good eye liner
Lori from NK, RI
I wish it stayed on better
Tonias84 from Sacramento
This stays well and doesn't bug my eyes. It does what I need it to. It can be stiff at time when putting a line down.
I would not buy this product again
Meeky from dallas
The liner did not go on smooth in the eye line area. It was somewhat dry on initial opening/application and did not get better after about 5 uses