Product Reviews Rated 4.14 out of 5 stars
1580 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review This product is very... This product is very good, it really stretches out your lashes and gives you a nice soft or frantic effect depending what your trying to go for, the only con is that it's very easy to get Caked so less is more with this product
Most Helpful Critical Review Looking for the right one for me I bought this Tuesday I was looking for a waterproof mascara and I wish that I had went with a different one cause this did clump my lashes together and it looked horrible! It's not going to stop me from trying another waterproof one, but any suggestions? Ive used Maybelline products since I was a teenager, just need to find the right waterproof mascara for me!
Reviewed by 1580 customers I will be buying again 4
Daira from beaverton, oregon
I love this mascara I cried a bunch and it didn't smudge at all so definitely waterproof. Even though it's hard to remove just use coconut oil to remove it. Makes my eyelashes look really long. would recommend
amazing 5
cate from colorado
i already naturally have long lashes but this makes them touch the middle of my eyebrow! i also had a friend with short lashes try this and it looked amazing! zero smudging and long lasting. i have had this open since february of 2020 and it still hasn't dried out! get this.
OBSESSED with this mascara!! 4
Hannah from Utica, NY
My lashes are super straight and this keeps them pushed up all day. Typically, the product and the brush should not give you clumps but sometimes they can, just run a spooli over them and you'll be fine. The only flaw I have found for me is that after a month and a half of using the mascara, my eyes will be super irritated when I apply it and they become very bloodshot. This is probably because I use this mascara almost every day and it's just dry and worn out. This also layers amazingly!!
torn 3
okitty from ok
makes my lashes look great, black dramatic lashes..makes my under eyes look horrible, smudgey raccoon eyes by night time
Great for oily eyelids 5
CeCe from Springfield
I have such a problem with mascara running all over my eyes because of my oily eyelids and I've tried EVERYTHING high end and drug store and this and the cover girl mascara in the orange tube (waterproof) are the only things that stay on all day and night
Great mascara 5
Lady iris from New York
Love this product because it's waterproof and that important plus it makes my lashes look long.
My favorite mascara 5
Megan from Atlanta, GA
I was looking for a mascara that would help separate my lashes and stay up all day since I work in a restaurant and it gets humid and all other mascaras I have tried wouldn't last all day. This one has yet to fail me. This is my go to mascara
Thick and goody 1
Sunshine 401 from Fort Myers FL
Don't waste your money.
My go to mascara 5
Kristi from CA
My favorite mascara ever. Creates long and full lashes with little effort.
Trash 1
MeadowTate from New York, NY
Absolute trash. Clumps your lashes and makes them look sparse. Would not recommend. Don't waste your money.
Favorite Mascara 5
Kline from VA
I have straight eyelashes that do not remain curled (even when I use an eyelash curler) unless it's waterproof. Not all waterproof mascaras have worked so me that also gave length. This mascara has my eyelashes curled the entire time and gives me length and thickness. I have tried many brands and this is definitely my favorite and works!!
Disappointing 2
Redhairedsweetie from undisclosed
I first bought the non waterproof because my store was out of waterproof. Loved that product so I figured I'd love the waterproof. WRONG!! It is very wet, clumpy and doesn't separate my lashes. I have short, thin, blonde lashes and this waterproof was not good for them. The only thing is that is good for me is that it does pass the waterproof test but if I get any on my skin, it's very hard to wipe off.
Love this!!!!!! 5
Kassandra from Orlando
I love this product!! It really lasts!
Great product for oily skin 4
Irene914 from Peachtree Corners, Georgia
I like this mascara because the price is acceptable and works great. My major problem is the mascara won't stay long with my oily skin, this works great, but need brash more times to looks volume.
worst mascara ever 1
lexie from nj
the regular version of this is completely fine easy to take off but i got the waterproof by mistake and NEVER AGAIN!! SO crumbly not smooth at all broke off my eyelashes while trying to take it off with an oil cleanser just terrible 0/10
Returned 2
marie from Bluffton, SC
I found the teeth on this product to be very difficult to use. It deposited clumps on my eyelashes not a nice smooth color.
Waterproof!! 3
Alyssa :) from California
I bought this for the pool because who doesn't like looking cute in the pool!! The only thing I disliked about this product was that it is VERYYY hard to remove, I used makeup remover to take it off and wipes.It also dries a bit fast but hey at least it's waterproof!!
Very Clumpy 2
Courtney from Nebraska
I am usually a fan of Maybelline mascara. However, this mascara ended up being very clumpy and thick. I have sensitive eyes and it did not go very well. I tried going through it a few times to get it to smooth out and it just did not work. I would not recommend you buy this if you have sensitive eyes.
:/ 2
taylor from detroit
i find that the brush picks up so much product that you have to wipe a lot off. when it dries it gets really hard and then its almost impossible to remove.
good but not amazing 4
bijou99 from california
it has a nice curl to it whenever i wear it but its a bit clumpy and the brush is weird to get at an angle. but the color is dark and nice!
got hit by a car and it still didn't budge :) 5
Ava rose from New York
Got hit by a car on my bike , flew 10 feet, balled my eyes out and still my lashes look poppin ;)
came without plug, had to throw away 1
paola786 from undisclosed
the bottle cane without a plug, so when I used it it would just be a glob if mascara. did absolutely nothing for my lashes. had to throw out
My go-to mascara! 5
Ella from New York, NY
My favorite drugstore mascara. Application is super smooth with the curved brush and it lengthens lashes without getting clumpy. If your lashes are like mine and are straight/don't hold curl, the waterproof is the way to go. It keeps my lashes curled all day. My only con is that it sometimes transfers onto my eyelid, but it doesn't happen often and is easy to wipe off. Would def recommend if you're thinking of trying it out!
brown black 4
Sintia from Los Angeles
Ive tried both the blackest black and black brown and the latter is nice for soft lash definition but I think I'm ready to try other brown mascaras. The black version looks so harsh/unflattering on my lashes.
Whenever I tried to layer this mascara (both versions) I felt like it would just get clumpy no matter how hard I tried to be gentle which is probably attributed to it being waterproof so it dries fast on your lashes (and in the tube). In terms of being waterproof it's pretty solid at holding a curl on my straight lashes and not budging throughout the day but I've never really had any trouble with mascara flaking or running. I think there was also a little bit of a learning curve with the brush because it holds too much product. A pretty solid product overall
Doesn't flake, lasts forever! 🤩 5
Aubrey from usa
I've been using this a few months now and it's AMAZING! I work somewhere where we wash dishes in a small humid kitchen (and occasionally get sprayed in the face) and it never smears or flakes on me! I sweat and even get sprayed in the eye with water and it stays! Love this stuff!
