Rated 4.35 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review The BEST mascara in the world
I love this mascara! Ever since I discovered it, it's the only one I use! It makes my eyelashes so long and every time I use it I get compliments and get asked what mascara do I use. Thanks to this product I don't even need to wear false lashes.
Most Helpful Critical Review Too wet/heavy for short, weak lashes
I have short, wimpy East Asian lashes that stick straight down and have trouble holding a curl so I always have to curl them before applying mascara. After hearing how beloved this mascara is by almost everyone I hoped it would work miracles, but unfortunately it doesn't. As soon as I apply it, my lashes get weighed down and start to sink and lose their curl. Although the mascara does add volume and length, I find that it tends to clump up and make my lashes stick together. It also stays wet for quite a while and has a tendency to smudge and flake on me. In the end it basically netted out to just an average mascara for me. Granted my lashes are difficult to work with but I figured this review would be helpful for those with similar issues.
Reviewed by 3617 customers Perfection
Ashleigh C from Aurora, Co6
When I tell y'all this mascara is EVERYTHING! I mean it! I've used several prestige brand mascaras, and while they were good they just didn't wow me. I was skeptical of this because of the price. But wow is this mascara amazing. Seriously with 3 coats I reach what im looking for. Its amazing! Buy it!
Mascara Lover from East Lansing, MI
Greatest mascara ever! I've tried so many name brand and non compare to this one. Makes my lashes look amazing. No clumping, doesn't irritate my eyes and my lashes look like I have false lashes on. Would absolutely recommend!!
Mel from USA
Out of the dozens of mascaras I've tried, this one will always have me coming back. Full lashes, buildable, affordable, beautiful packaging.
Juiia from Arkansas
I have been purchasing Super Hero Mascara for over three years now and bout this as a last minute purchase to get to the free shipping amount. I figured I'd just give it to my daughter. Jeepers!! It works as well as Super Hero if not better for me! At a 1/'4 of the cost. Definitely gives the length look. Not goopy. Doesn't flake. My new favorite staple in my makeup. :)
Tired Mommy from Charleston
This has become my go to mascara. It really gives volume to my lashes and the price is great!
Ashleighc from Aurora, CO
When I tell y'all that this mascara is EVERYTHING! I mean just that! From the price to the product it is everything! Im so in love I buy 3 at a time so I dont run out lol
Wings from Chattanooga, TN
This is a great Mascara. It glides on easy and makes big full lasesh.
I will never buy it again. The packaging I feel is unsafe.
Kim from Arlington TX
Won't use it because of packaging. Couldn't tell if it had been opened before. During this time of COVID the packaging should be tampered proof. I would return this but was told I couldn't do that curbside.
New favorite mascara!!
Beautyluvr from Missouri
I was skeptical of this mascara because I'm a LONG time lover of Loreal mascaras and I've tried so many others over the years and they never stacked up. I was even more skeptical when I saw the brush but let me tell you 😍 If length and separation is what you're after BUY IT NOW!!! It's amazing stuff!! This is my new go to!
Marisa from Shakopee, MN
My lashes really look long!
I will buy this again
Pam in Naples from Naples
Natalie from California
I like this but I notice it flakes off a lot during the day. Makes my lashes look full and beautiful but only for a limited time.
The absolute BEST
Erin F from Monrovia
I've heard lots of good things about this mascara so I finally tried it. It's all true! I have short and straight lashes and this gave me so much length and volume! I've tried tons of other mascaras and even L'Oréal lash paradise wasn't this good (but it was close). One coat can be for everyday casual minimal look but two coats is like BA BAM! And it's so cheap!!! It also lasted well throughout the day, no drooping or smudging. I even work out while wearing this mascara and it's completely fine! I'm definitely going to be constantly restocking on this.
Creamenstein from WA
I bought this because of the reviews but it's honestly one of the worst mascaras I've ever used. For something comparable in price, Maybelline Great Lash is a millions time better. I have very long lashes and with only one "layer" of mascara my eyelashes were clumpy and heavy. They looked and felt so disgusting, and it's impossible to remove excess.
It Was Alright
Leigh from Virginia
It did the job, I just don't understand the hype. It was just fine and did what it was supposed to do. I will say that most drug store mascaras tend to irritate my eyes, this one doesn't at all.
AMAZING AND SO CHEAP
jae from Hanover MD
don't need any other mascara i will only buy this for now on
Would not buy it again
Dolphin102 from San Antonio
It did not work at all and may seem like my lashes were natural and it did not give me linked at all
Does its job
Vil from Central Jersey
I was introduced to this mascara from a friend. I have tried top name brand ones and found this inexpensive one to live up to its name. There are several types for the different looks u want to achieve. Tried all and my review is on the fake lashes effect. It's like have falsies on without the hassle. Yes it does take a while to dry and may flake but my lashes looked pretty good and did not irritate my sensitive eyes.
You can easily remove with an oil based removed from Clinique or Lancome.
Hannah from Boston, Massachusetts
I purchased this mascara as I saw people raving about it online. I personally thought it was just okay. Definitely overhyped.
Favorite mascara I recently found! It is the best!
Chris from Itasca, IL
This mascara does everything you want it to do. It extends your lash length, does not flake or clump. The price is great and I tell my friends about it because it is the best mascara I have ever used.
Love this mascara
Haley from PA
I'be tried mascaras definitely more expensive than this one, but this has the least fallout compared to others. I love the price too!
LaMah from Portland, OR
When I first put it on I loved it. Did a nice job adding length while not clumping. But a few hours later I noticed it was leaving black eyelash marks under my eyebrow and then a few hours after that it was so smudged under my eyes. It looked like I had a late night at the bar when I was really just home making dinner. I say try it because if it doesn't smudge it was great. But sadly I tossed mine.
I would definitely buy again
Me from TucsonAz
Top five mascaras
HORRIBLE CLUMPING. DO NOT BUY
HuggableHooligan from Pewaukee, WI
I have had the absolute worst experience with this mascara. I could never get it to apply smoothly, always clumped and made me long lashes look scraggly. I wish I had literally just gone down to the drugstore instead.
Save your money and buy this!
Tera from Wisconsin
This is one of the best mascaras I've ever used and it has a cult following for a reason! For the price, it outperforms the rest.