Rated 3.17 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Best eyeliner ever!
I have been searching for the perfect eyeliner for years and have finally found it! I just got this yesterday and wore out for a birthday gathering and then again today at work. I have never been able to apply my eyeliner so perfectly and as fast as I can with this. I'm talking SHOCKED at how amazing it is. I will *never* buy another eyeliner again. The tip is small enough to go with a modest, thin look(like today for work) but dark enough to get a bold, dramatic look(like last night). I have always spent at least five minutes on my liner trying to get the look I want with both eyes while have them being the same effect. With this eyeliner I was done with both eyes in under a minute. Love, love, love this eyeliner! On my next order, I will be stocking up because the price is amazing and the quality is second-to-none. Like I said, I have spent a lot of money on different eye liners and I have finally found "the one".
Most Helpful Critical Review Almost a great product but...
This eyeliner is super easy to apply precisely, but it's not pigmented very well and came out more gray than black.
Reviewed by 775 customers Amazing & more Amazing the price!!
Lloydielui from USA
I use Urban Decay eyeshadow primer potion all the time so after doing my eye-shadows this pencil is amazing it is so smooth and you can go over any previous lines to straighten your wing. It stays put all day long and washes off easily. Will definitely buy again!
sammy from tn
it literally won't draw on my eyelid lol
N/A from South carolina
It's affordable and it stays on all day
Dry tip, useless, has to lick to work.
Jim the Runner from San Diego CA
I honestly only buy vegan and cruelty free cosmetics, I was in a rush and purchased this item. Completely dry in the tip and it's useless unless you lick it, I highly doubt it's safe to consume. Would not buy again. I've tried better dollar store eyeliners than this one, it's nice if you're trying to clean your keyboard tho! Completely regret not buying the one I saw, my tongue is turning black from this. Can't go back out to buy a different eyeliner cus I live in a sketchy neighborhood. Don't take the risk, I did enjoy taking apart my keyboard and using this to pick up dust.
I would not buy this again.
Sanye from Altadena Ca
This product is terrible. I got it and it worked for two days, then dried out. From all of the good reviews I was expecting something good. I'm really upset and would not recommend this product.
For the price you cannot beat the quality..LOVE
Smile from North Las Vegas
I use this everyday and work in many weather conditions
Doesn't hold up
Miz Cook from West Palm Beach, FL
I wanted to love this! It is super easy to apply and comes out in a nice jet black color, however the color only lasts about 3-4 hours into the day.
dahnyela from El Paso, TX
I bought this item about 3 weeks ago, and I usually love elf products. I even like one of their other liquid eyelines, so I did not think anything bad about this eyeliner. However, after the first couple of uses I started realizing that the eyeliner would smear on my eyelids after a few hours. Then, I thought maybe I need to prime my eyelid. After doing so, it would still smear. I then started making my lines smaller and it seemed to fix the problem but I would not recommend if you like I dramatic eyeliner like myself.
Fair in the winter, poor in the summer
Niks from DC
This formula smudges, smears, and fades quick. It does better in the winter when your face isn't as oily and hot, but still not amazing. There are better options for this price point.
lez1 from undisclosed
When it arrived, it had no pigment at all! It was so dry and I shook the eyeliner to see if any ink was going to come out and nothing. Really disappointed
Bethyboop from Vancouver BC
I usually love everything from elf; but I was so sad with this product. When it arrived it was just not pigmented. I even tried it on my hand and it just came out like a watered down grey, and I bought "blackest black" so sad. Cause I feel I could have great looks with that tip
Rae from Lubbock, Texas
Great product, great price and I will add to my favorite list of products!
If I could give a 0 star, I would
pandapandapanda from Ontario
Bought this last year, writing a review now. This is the absolute worst eyeliner I have ever used and I've been doing makeup for well over 9 years. This product is the definition of you get what you pay for. The entire tube dried out after 2 days of use. Not good at all for hooded eye shapes, in fact, you're dreaming if you think this is easy to apply and use. Looks like you could stamp it almost but no. Do not be fooled by how it looks. Dry and waste of money.
deanna treacy from pennsylvania
this eyeliner is horrible. the tip is way too bendable and when i go over the line to fill it in, it disappears and becomes flakey. it also dried up way too fast. i got this eyeliner 4 days ago and it is just about gone. don't waste ur money.
andygab from San Salvador
Yesterday I tried this product, well I was not so sure because it's price but IT'S AMAZING, before I applied a coat of concealer, sealed it with setting powders and lasted ALL DAY LONG. I love it so so much.
jasmine14 from new jersey
This is literally the best liner ever. It was so easy to use and very pigmented and now my go to liner
Star from Tokyo
I love this eyeliner because it doesn't come off when you put it on. What I hate is when I'm done with my eye look the ink doesn't come out. So three stars because I cant draw over my eyeshadow 😞
The precision of the ink eyeliner
Vickizeiyang from Saint Paul, MN
Omg! I was skeptical to try this out but when I first did, I fell in love with this eyeliner. The precision of it, the fact that it dries fast too also helps me to not have to worry about smudges or any mistake. Plus very easy to remove and define my eye. I will definitely buy more. Added to one of my favorite eye liner.
Janz from Saint Louis, Mo
I have tried several eyeliners and this is the best I've found. I lay the tip flat on top of my lid all the way a crossed and then touch up with the tip.
Eye liner from Cleveland
When I got it was very dry
Charo9876 from Louisiana
goes on on one application and looks beautiful! Also a true dark black without gray! I can not believe how great this is, especially at the low price.
don't buy for hooded eyes
bryk from undisclosed
pretty difficult to control the pen, and if you have hooded eyes then it just comes straight off and looks super patchy. dries quick tho
not beginner friendly
angelina88 from New York, NY
Bought this because I wanted something cheap and easy to use. It did not apply smoothly, didn't have that much pigment, was dry, and smudged at times. Maybe someone better at eyeliner could make it work but I definitely cannot.
Tcool from Cincinnati ohio
I love this product especially for the price. It stays on all day and when I rub my eyes it doesnt rub off unless with water. I have also bought eyeliner in the past where through out the day it will run off of my eyes and that can be embarrassing if you do not notice it until you see a mirror. I do not have that problem with this eyeliner
suitcasey from undisclosed
the tip of the eyeliner dries out fairly quickly and the product easily rubs off.