Product Reviews Rated 3.16 out of 5 stars
822 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Best eyeliner ever! I have been searching for the perfect eyeliner for years and have finally found it! I just got this yesterday and wore out for a birthday gathering and then again today at work. I have never been able to apply my eyeliner so perfectly and as fast as I can with this. I'm talking SHOCKED at how amazing it is. I will *never* buy another eyeliner again. The tip is small enough to go with a modest, thin look(like today for work) but dark enough to get a bold, dramatic look(like last night). I have always spent at least five minutes on my liner trying to get the look I want with both eyes while have them being the same effect. With this eyeliner I was done with both eyes in under a minute. Love, love, love this eyeliner! On my next order, I will be stocking up because the price is amazing and the quality is second-to-none. Like I said, I have spent a lot of money on different eye liners and I have finally found "the one".
Most Helpful Critical Review Almost a great product but... This eyeliner is super easy to apply precisely, but it's not pigmented very well and came out more gray than black.
Reviewed by 822 customers do not buy 1
bry from indiana
terrible, just bought it and it's super dried out
Completely dried out after one use 1
Lauralev from Maryland
I usually love elf products but this did not work at all. Bought it to touch up my eyeliner today. Went to put it on and not only did it dry out after one swipe it took off the eyeliner I already had on when I went over it, which doesn't usually happen to me! Super disappointed in this eyeliner. Especially cause I love all the other elf products I have!
DRY 1
Jackie2021 from Grove City, OH
I just bought this eyeliner pen and it went on great the first eye! However when I went to do my other eye, it was already dried out! I tried everything I could think of. I usually don't have an issue with the products but this one is just a waste of money; seeing the other reviews, I'm not the only person with this problem.
Impressed 5
SHS09 from WI
Received this free as a gift and very impressed with it. I used Tartes maneater liquid liner and ran out. Thought this liner works just as well if not better!
No. Just no. 1
malika36 from Montreal, QC
I'm usually super satisfied with my e.l.f. products, but this one just ain't it. I was expecting a nice eyeliner that would be easy to apply, and I was really happy when I tried my first winged eyeliner with it. However, since the tip is very thin, it dries out incredibly fast, and doesn't work anymore no matter what I do. So unless you want to buy two of these to *maybe* do both eyes once, it's not worth it. At all. I had to use another eyeliner to finish the second eye because this one dried out too fast. Yes, it's cheap, but considering e.l.f.'s usual quality, I'm disappointed. It's the only item in my order I didn't like.
Not that good 2
Sara from Michigan
I'm not sure if it was the one I bought or all of them, but the tip is very dry and hard to put on. Doesn't glide in like the regular liquid eyeliners I have. You have to be forceful with it. And by the time you try to fix a mistake with a q-tip it's already dried and hard to get off
DRY 1
anniejo from NM
My go-to and pretty much the only product I use daily is eyeliner. I was excited when my shipment arrived, only to be thoroughly disappointed. The eyeliner is so dry, I am not able to use it and now I have to go out an purchase another product. Very disappointing.
dry af! 1
shae14 from canada
was so excited to use this product but when i opened it up to use, it was completely dry! i even tried shaking it multiple times to get the eyeliner going but unfortunately nothing changed. :(
great idea, not enough ink 1
windflcwer from troy ohio
i bought this and it was already dried out once i opened it lol bruh
Perfect wing 5
Lolawazhere from Orlando, Florida
It seems bulky at first but honestly when I used it as a stamp for my wing it came out flawless everytime!
Okay 2
giselle000 from nj
I really liked the felt tip & i love the size of it. However, the ink seemed to dry out after my 2nd day of using it. I can still apply it if I use it a certain way, though.
Not great... 2
Kaya21 from Saint Paul, MN
I was so excited to use this when I got it, but when i tried it it didn't work :( The ink didn't go onto my eyelid...
Love 5
Aliciadeane from Iowa
It works great!!!
i would definitely buy this again 5
cameron lol from danbury ct
i think the pigment is good and it stays for a very long time
This one wasn't it... Try the other e.l.f liner 2
tayymahon from Dayton OH
As much as I love e.l.f, this eyeliner didn't do it for me. It's mostly grey, and application is a bit difficult. Some of the dryness I can attribute to age or packaging, but I was disappointed. The other liners are better.
Barely any ink in it 2
emi_ from Philadelphia, PA
I bought this recently and after one use the ink struggled to go onto my skin. I was incredibly disappointed with this. But besides that, using it was so easy.
quite good 4
honnie from undisclosed
I prefer the other ink eyeliner on the website, but this is still quite good.
Works well 5
Hina from Toronto Ontario Canada
This liner, despite it looking really fat and chubby, actually works really well. I haven't had any issues with this
Not bad for my first eyeliner 4
Frizzabella from Texas
Sometimes it doesn't flow well, but it has a great tip and the color is bold :) However, sometimes the ink doesn't flow out well.
Subpar 1
actual demon from Canada
It's alright as an alternative to pencil eyeliner for just the top of your lid above the lashes - less messy than liquid, but so much less pigmented and annoying to put on that it's really not an improvement. The point is okay, but it's impossible to do any type of cateye with this watered down bulky pen, so I won't be using it again. It can't be blended like a pencil, it does not have the dark pigment of liquid, the only potential plus of the sharp point was useless anyway, and worst of all, you have to constantly shake it upside down to even get anything to come out. I didn't have high expectations for this, but was still disappointed. I only tried this because reviews complained about it not working on the waterline, which I did not care about as I only do cateye above and below the two lash lines. So this review is to tell you that it absolutely does not work for that, either.
Awful! 1
KTip from undisclosed
I've given this eyeliner a chance. A few times. It just doesn't come out well at all! It's liquid, it should glide. I'm tossing it.
Dry and spotty 1
MJPa from undisclosed
I just got this in today and I am not happy with it. I first thought it wasn't working because I was applying over eyeshadow, but then I ran it on my hand and got the same result. The tip was super dry and the ink that did come out was spotty and not consistent.
Honestly really bad quality 1
Olive_rom from undisclosed
I bought this earlier today and the tip is already dried out. Seriously don't buy this
My most favorite liquid eyeliner 5
pigeon from undisclosed
I love this stuff!! It doesn't smudge, and I'm someone that runs pretty warm so that's saying something. I also have hooded lids and it doesn't transfer. It also lasts me allll day long without crusting or cracking. And, it's so easy to apply. My favorite thing about it is that it layers super well. I don't have the most steady hand for applying liner so it's great that this stuff is so forgiving and allows me to adjust without destroying the whole line. I love the thick shape of the container too because it's easy to hold, and the applicator tip is so versatile for thin lines or thick.
My only complaint is that it runs out sooo fast. Since it's so cheap, it's not the end of the world, but I do wish there was more product in there. On black friday I bought 4 to stock up!!
This is my holy grail ya'll.... even if others don't agree.
Not worth buying 2
Laibah from New york
Bought this recently and this lives up to having an intense color but the cons outweigh the pros. It drys too quickly and does not apply smoothly.
