Rated 4.03 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Safe for contact lens wearers!
Finally an eyeliner that doesn't transfer on contact lens!! I have used tons of eyeliner pencils, waterproof, budget liners to high end liners and this is the ONLY one that has specified that it is safe for contact lens-and it lives up to that claim! I don't know why more cosmetics companies don't make their eyeliners safe for contacts like Lorac has done with this amazing liner. I use this on my upper lid and to line my waterline and it doesn't transfer to my contact lens. It stays on all day, doesn't irritate eyes, goes on smoothly, has great pigment. I use the color dark brown and it gives the intensity of beautifully defined eyes without looking to harsh. Many grateful thanks to Lorac for this eyeliner!! Finally eyeliner with maximum definition and complete eye comfort for all of us contact lens wearers! Please never stop making this amazing formula!!! Customer for life! Contact lens wearers, this eyeliner is the answer to your eyeliner dreams!
Most Helpful Critical Review Better than using a sharpener
This color takes a couple of times over to get dark enough to see it well. Because of the diameter of the pencil and the fact that it's self-sharpening it doesn't really allow for a fine line. But it is easy to remove and does not smudge or run unless you rub it accidentally. Not a huge fan of the longer pencil, most other brands are shorter and easier to handle.
Reviewed by 406 customers Love, love, love...
anonymous from undisclosed
Originally received as a sample. Quickly found that it's the best out there. Easy on, stays on, no tug to remove when you want it off. Great deep pigments that smudge easily for a smoky look (if you want) but stays put once it has set. I use it for day looks, as well as night. Saves me so much time applying my makeup as it's a perfect formula. Don't use the white much, but that's just a preference. I really love, love, love it!!
JojoR from Dallas Texas
Lorac makes the best eyeliner. It's easy to apply and it doesn't fade
Katie from Texas
This eye liner stands out to me because it transfers less than Marc Jacobs' eye pencils when I use it to tightline (upper eyelid lash line). I love the brown shade for a softer eye look. This eye liner wears well throughout the day.
Doesn't irritate eyes!
GAPEACH20 from Atlanta, GA
I have used many different brands for my waterline, and most of them burn or irritate my eyes. This one does not! It also goes on easily and lasts all day. Highly recommend.
Amazing!! And I'm one of the pickiest reviewers.
LarameeBlair from Canon City, CO
I've been laughing at some of the comments about not being able to apply it because or primer and highlighter or that they can't do a straight line... Ummm I've been using this for over a year. My boss and friends now use it too. My eyes naturally water A LOT, so I have tried so many eyeliners. This is the only one that stays in tact. It is amazing. I wear charcoal. I have blonde hair and blue eyes and it complements them perfectly. This eyeliner is amazing.
msh from san Diego
the liner is way to soft. I can't get a straight line and end up with smudged liner everywhere.
Best eyeliner out there!!
Missy from Tennessee
Goes on smooth!!!
Hard to draw on and no pigment
spruce120 from ARIZONA
I couldn't get the eyeliner to glide on. It wouldn't go on easily, and really couldn't see it when I got done. I am returning. I bought the charcoal color.
Will buy again
Ann from Rochester, NY
I bought based on other review saying this liner stays on all day. I agree! Last last much longer than other brands. Will buy again.
Noor from California
Best eyeliner ever. Best color , great for eyes allergy . I love it and I'll buy it again for sure.
Point Too Wide, Smudges and Doesn't Last
heartfulmom from Marietta, GA
This eyeliner was my first LORAC purchase. I bought it during the 21 Days of Beauty. The dark brown color is perfect, and the quality of the materials is quite good. Unfortunately, the tip of the pencil is too wide and can't be sharpened further, so it's impossible to make a thin line. It also stops and starts, so it's tough to create a continuous line. Plus, this eyeliner barely lasts a few hours. It also smudges too much. Raccoon eyes! I've spent $5 on far better liners (LA Girl!) I will be returning this when our local stores reopen.
My ride or die eyeliner
Fireheart from Batesville, AR
I'm probably on my fifth one. It's my favorite. I have brown eyes and I always purchase the brown one for everyday wear.
Best eyeliner I have found!! Goes on great & stays in place!
Sherri from TN
The first time I tried this eyeliner, I immediately loved it. But being cheap, like usual, when I ran out, I tried another brand that was on sale (Urban Decay). On top of having to use a pencil sharper, which I hate, it ran down under the corner of my eyes. I caught myself having to constantly look in the mirror and wiping under my eyes. Then I tried another one that went on sale ,Bare Minerals (which I use their concealer & foundation daily). I loved that it was self-sharpening and I loved the color, but I could hardly even get it to go on my skin... I ended up with very light coloring... Now I am back to the one I know will go on nicely and stay in place!! It still looks great after a whole day at work!! No more wasting money on other brands for me!!!
Kaitlyn from Iowa
Love this for my waterline. It doesn't go anywhere and I have seasonal allergies so my eyes water A LOT. I've used it on my eyelids as well and it's staying power is awesome!
I love this eyeliner
Ayana from Niagara Falls New York
I use this on my waterline and it's the only eyeliner I've found that actually stays on and doesn't come off super easily
Millie from Port Saint Lucie, Fl
Used on bottom eyelid it was a perfect glide on eye
This thing won't draw on my eyes!
Bev from Alaska
Maybe it's because I have eyeshadow/primer on, but I can not get this pencil to draw on my eyelid. I can get it to work on my hand, but it's useless on my eyelid!!!
I would proceed with caution on this one. I've tried three different days and it hasn't works and I threw it away. Also you can't sharpen it which isn't helpful if you like a thinner line.
Cmayr from U.S
I love the way it easily glides on. No smudging after a long day and perfect for the waterline. It's retractable with a small sharpener at the end to refine the point. Best liner by far.
LMK from OR
Love the color, it goes on easily and does not smudge.
Kate from California
After trying many runny eye liners, I came across this! The precision and tone of the liner is amazing. If you like a more natural look, the dark brown shade is great.
Ellie from MT
This was my first time buying lorac and I love it! It's worth every penny. I don't wear eyeliner much, but this stays on all day and for going out where my last one didn't. Highly recommend
Kel from Ohio
I use this for the bottom part of my eye and the liquid for the top. Both are amazing and no smudges. They both last all day. Highly recommended. I haven't found an eyeliner I like in yeeeeaaaarrrssss and basically would just go solo on mascara but since finding this lovely, I wear my eyeliner daily again.
Reeses1 from Reno
Soft on eyes and waterproof. Stays on all day.
pls di not discontinue. Best eyeliner ever
karen from Twinsburg Ohio
Use daily. Love it
I have bought this item again and again love it
Barb from Montana
Loved the smoky color with just rummage right amount of glitter