Rated 4.12 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review I wish I could give this a 4.5
I love how well this eyeliner works as far as not smudging. I struggle finding eye liners that don't turn me into a raccoon. My one complaint is that I can go through one of these pencils crazy fast! I will continue to buy until I find one that works as well and last longer, but I really wish this one was a better value.
Most Helpful Critical Review Not thrilled
I like the color, I don't like how it applies. It does not go on smoothly or evenly. It is not easy to apply I have to keep going over and over the same area to get the color to show up. I like to apply waterproof eyeliners on my water line, I can't get this to apply on the waterline, I have to apply it right under the lashes. That even would be okay, but it is not okay since it doesn't apply easily and smoothly.
Reviewed by 68 customers Great gel liner
Spr from Tulsa OK
This is my go to eyeliner, creamy and lovely but doesn't budge... I've tried them all but nothing tops this one.
I would definitely buy this again
Kimmy from Sapulpa OK
Last all day w/o smearing
I would not buy this again.
bhouck from Virginia
Very expensive for a product of poor quality.
Very good eyeliner .
L'alice from Philadelphia pa
One of my favorite eyeliners. Wish it wasn't so expensive.
i love this product
cece from dothan. al
it is the perfect eye liner
Beth from IA
I love this eye liner but I agree with all the reviews you have to keep going over and over and over again. I wish the black was a tad darker.
It actually stays put on the waterline
Mrsbrown1412 from Philadelphia
I have very watery eyes and I've tried everything from Makeup Forever, Urban Decay, Nyx, Revlon, Kat Von D nothing can stay in my water line until I tried this pencil you do have to rub it back and forth quite a few times to get the color intensity you want but it Glides on so smoothly that it doesn't really matter that you have to go back and forth a few times my eyes always water while applying so that makes it even harder to apply but this one doesn't even run while I'm applying it. I love everything about this eyeliner it's pretty pricey but it's worth the money I hope they come out with more colors
I would buy this product again.
Jules from Madison
Love that it is waterproof. Lasts all day without smearing.
First time I have used this one. I definitely will buy it s
Susan from St. Petersburg, FL
All expressed above.
Great for eyes that water all the time
Birdie from Lafayette, IN
I found this product to be long lasting even on someone with watery eyes. I have allergies and am constantly wiping or dabbing my eyes. No other product I've used has had the staying power of this one.
Dawnmarie from St louis
Stays on really well, even under eye. Looks natural.
Love this liner!
Joan P from Thousand Oaks
I get my eyelashes tinted so I don't wear any mascara except on special occasions . This eyeliner helps boost the look of my lash line for everyday wear and the deep plum color is a subtle purple. I like that it is a twist rather than a pencil that needs to be sharpened.
Drey from Wheeling, IL
This is the best waterproof eye liner I have found! It does not come off even when the rest of you is melting in the hot sun!
Lynette from The Villages
Liner is not worth the price.
Kitty from Pittsburgh, PA
It cakes upon application, comes off within an hour, and breaks off easily.
JW from Vero Beach
This eyeliner actually stays on all day. Espresso is a very nice, soft but bold brown color.
NAna from Florida
Easy to apply and long lasting to wear but Not a lot of product for the price
Love!! Stays on all day!!
RM from Minnesota
Love! Stays on all day!
LS from NJ
This is an eyeliner that will last the day, even with my super oily eyelids. The black isn't a very saturated color, but it makes it appropriate for work. I docked a star because the smudger tip is useless. This eyeliner dries immediately after application so there is no time to smudge it. And I've tried. The smudger becomes an eraser at that point and just takes it all off. I prob won't repurchase. It good but not great, especially for the price.
mamalynn from Iowa
This is the best eyeliner I've used. I'm 48 so have some fine lines and I have oily skin. My recommendations...it goes on better when the skin around the eye is dry. I put it on after applying foundation and powder, then I set it with a touch of powder after I apply it. If I try to put it on my slightly oily bare skin it does not go on as thick and does tend to run. Every morning I use it I just "sharpen" it by drawing on a piece of paper to expose fresh eyeliner. I do NOT use the sharpener as too much would go to waste. It lasts a long time. I like how I can build it up for more dramatic effect for going out or just keep it light for everyday use. I highly recommend this.
will never buy again
Tmimi from Jackson, MS
clumps and does not glide on easily.
a rip off
Best eye liner available!
Sherri from BRistol, Va
Yes if can find on sale
Kat from Newport tn
Caty from New york
This eyeliner is good and stays put but difficult to apply.
Baby girl from Madison, WI
I absolutely love this eyeliner!!! Goes on so natural! Doesn't run or smudge. Great price too!!