Rated 4.13 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Amazing I love this Product
I am not a big fan of Mascara but this one I fell in love with it doesn't take a lot but it has big pay off. I got this in a gift set that I got for my birthday. It makes me look like I have on fake lashes when I don't so that's a plus! What's not to love it's Too Faced! I am doing this review as part of and Influenster contest.
Most Helpful Critical Review I used to love it
I used to love this mascara, it was lengthening and waterproof but the last one I bought smudged all over and it was super clumply, I do t know if they changed the formula but is totally messy now, will be looking for another one
Reviewed by 23153 customers Not the best for me.
Ang from Pa
It was good to it wasn't. After I kept using i got a allergic reaction and got an eye infection:(
i loved this but...
aubry from mn
i loved this mascara but after a couple uses it did start to clump up on my lashes
I love this mascara
CG from Caldwell, NJ
The product looks clumpy on the brush, but when applied it isn't clumpy at all. Lashes are long and bold! I haven't had issues with smudging either. Great product.
Just a marketing gimmick
Sunny G from Colorado
I have tried drugstore mascaras that were better than this one. Heed the warnings of the other bad reviews and save your money. The "revolutionary brush shape" makes the end a globby mess when you pull the brush out of the tube and you have to scrape most of the product off the brush. You can't put the 'waterproof' product on lower lashes without it smudging after 2 hours of use. The consistency of the mascara is thick and gluey and just sticks your lashes together. I cant build any product at my lash base without lots of clumping. The product goes on so thick that it rips my lashes out when I try to remove the product at the end of the day. I am getting tired of bad products coming out just for the campy marketing.
Jessieca from Bronson, Tx.
It is a great waterproof mascara wish they would run it on sale
MACgirl4Life from Texas
I wanted to love this mascara based on what I've heard about it, and I do love the wand, the way it goes on and the way my lashes don't look clumpy when applied, but... It starts flaking off and smudging after only a few minutes of wear. I've tried two different tubes with the same results. Also, I feel like it's not as black as it could be. I can definitely tell a difference between the shade of this black mascara which has a gray-brown-charcoal tone to it vs. MAC mascara which is a very dark, true black. I have to put so much of this product on my lashes to even notice a difference (ugh so much for non-clumpy). I probably won't use this product again unless the color and formulation are improved. I'll just stick with my "better than mediocre" MAC products.
Yes it is better than sex,
Dude1121 from Santa Rosa CA
This product also contains a lot of actual mascara in the container, actually a great value at the price.
Amazing!! Love love love it!!
Tatiana from Los Angeles
I have straight small lashes and usually mascara won't hold a curl from my eye curler but, this mascara hold up!! I was surprised but with one coat I had full coverage and my lashes stay up not just applying but the entire day! I absolutely love it that I purchased a few more.
I LOVE THIS MASCARA
Sofia from NY
This is such a nice mascara! It made my lashes soo long and I have small straight lashes! This made them so beautiful! Definitely recommend!
Leaves me looking like a raccoon
Caro from Boston
I bought this by accident. I normally buy the Lancôme one. But, when I saw that it had good reviews online, I kept it. The mascara looks great when first applied, but then starts running after a few hours. Not cute !! One day after work, I got home noticed how much mascara was under my eye and wondered why no one told me anything ! lol not impressed, especially for the price.
not too bad but
AngeRConk from New York
definitely can see the hype for this mascara in a way but i still love my l'oréal paris lash paradise mascara way more, plus it's $20 cheaper. the better than sex mascara gets kinda clumpy on the brush and it kinda weighs down my lashes and doesn't hold the curl. it's not a bad mascara, but i have seen better. i had really high hopes so i'm kinda bummed. besides the downsides, it does give some good volume and length.
I love it but pits a bit pricey
Amelia from OH
It works great with 3 coats like it says the only thing I don't like is the price
The Best BUT..
Redd from New York
This is my favorite mascara, I absolutely love how my lashes look she. I use this! The only issue I have when wearing this is that it runs 😩 I even use a mascara primer before using this sometimes and it still runs. Doesn't really stop me from purchasing again lol but in the hunt for something similar to try!
I would most definitely buy this product again!
Becca from West Virginia
This is my everyday go to mascara I love that it don't run and it it last all day/night! 😍
Worst Waterproof mascara
Nadia from New York
Don't even bother Wasting your money. I love the non-water proof better than sex so I thought, y not try waterproof. Well, the formulation is def different as my lashes didn't look full. Instead they looked clumpy. In addition, this waterproof mascara is the WORST to remove
Not worth the hype
Olivia from PA
The wand shape is nice but Way too much clumping. It should not be that hard to remove. It's so hard to remove with makeup remover that I lose multiple lashes.
Thought I would give this brand another try, wished I hadn't
Barbie from Royston, GA
I thought I would give this product one more try, now I wish I had not. It makes the lashes clump no matter how much mascara is on wand. Doesn't go on as well as the non waterproof mascara.
I would purchase again
Better than sex from Riverhead, New York
I wanted to try this mascara because someone told me about it.
Runs really bad after a day of work
Ari D. from Michigan
This stuff looks really good when you first apply it. I went a whole day wearing it at work, running around like usual, and not looking into a mirror- until I did when I was horrified to see all the smudge underneath my eyes. The formula also gets dry and starts clumping only after a few weeks of using it. Really disappointing
My go to mascara for day to day usage
Cam from Oregon
I can make one application last 2+ days with working out a showering every day so it is extremely strong. Very volumizing and perfect for outdoors during the rainy season.
Clumpy from Clumpy
It's very clumpy
This makes my lashes more stunning!!
Danisha from Oklahoma
I love this mascara!! It truly enhances my already natural thick lashes!! Best I've used thus far, it doesn't weight my lashes down and makes it look like I have on lash extensions
H from PA
i heard all good things about this mascara but for me it just wasn't it. it made my lashes clump together very bad. it was very messy and smudged a lot. the tube dried out very quickly
K from Iowa
not as good as expected. drug store works just as well for half the price.
Misj from Ohio
For the price I expected better. The wand is weird and causes lots of product to build up on it. I keep giving it a chance but it is so disappointing. Ulta brand is better IMO and costs less.