Rated 3.86 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review End Game
Guys listen... I wore this Better Than Sex eyeliner and I winged it out to the gods... I applied waterproof mascara... I wore it all day and there was no transferring, leaking, this liner was in it for the long haul. I went and saw Avengers End Game and I cried 3 times. Teared up about 2 times... After the movie I went to the bathroom thinking I'm looking like a mess like I'm going through a rough break up or some tough life stuff ya know? Oh my god... my liner was SOLID. It was a real trooper, this liner stayed on and hung on for dear life, it was not budging through all these tears. Even my mascara held up. My friend was amazed I got to walk out of that theater with the liner still so sharp and fresh it could cut through diamond. Worth the money, will be purchasing again. I recommend this to everyone!
Most Helpful Critical Review False Claims
I was so excited to use this eyeliner. The Ulta worker that helped me told me how this is the most amazing eyeliner because it lasts 24 hours, it's smudge-proof, and water-proof. I asked if he's ever tried it (he didn't). If he did, he would know these claims are absolutely false.
I shook the eyeliner a lot before I opened it (the box said to shake and I read many reviews that said shaking is the key to getting good pigmentation). I started applying it by using the tip to make the tail/flick of my cat eye. The color was sheer, it looked almost grey. I shook it some more and applied the same way again. The color coming off the top was still very sheer. I used the body of the brisk to go over my lash line. The color didn't improve much. I went to do my other eye and I noticed the color was a bit darker, but not as dark as I wanted.
When I inspected both eyes, I noticed a ton of color transferred from my lash line to my lid (I hate this). Since I had a mess on my lid, I decided to test out the "smudge-proof" claim. It smudged on both eyes easily and spread the color all over my eyes. I was able to use just water to remove all the color.
I was so disappointed in this product. It didn't deliver on any of it's claims. I couldn't imagine this eyeliner lasting more than a few hours. Stick with Stila. I'm returning this next time in near an Ulta.
Reviewed by 522 customers Garbage
Roxo from San Francisco
I've only got it because a YouTube blogger recommended it. And it's pure garbage. The black color is actually gray on the skin.
BrownSugaa from Sylmar, Ca
This eyeliner is so amazing and beautiful. So easy to do winged liner ( thick or thin). Great for people wanting to learn to do liner because its so easy to glide and precision is spot on.
Sarabella from Orange County
It's not the best to draw with and washes off easily.
Starburst from Weirton wv
Use this every day for my winged eyeliner
Sharpay from Connecticut
I am a die hard liquid eyeliner fan. I have tried everything under the sun over the last few years. This is far superior to all of the other options. The tip is a perfect medium between soft and flexible and stiff. You have perfect control over each mark you make. My biggest issue with the Kat Von D tattoo liner is that it dries too fast. For me, it is difficult to work with because you cant go back and fix your mistakes and the longer the pen is out of the cap the stiffer it gets. With the better than sex liner, I have literally sat on my bathroom counter for and hour drawing on my face. it doesn't dry out. I go to sleep in this eyeliner. I havent applied it since yesterday morning and it is still perfect. Trust me, this product is a godsend.
Dana from New York
My favorite liner! So easy to apply and great for a winged look!
Amber from Ohio
Pros: I got my money's worth bc it doesn't dry out quickly. It does help to shake it before you use it. Love that it's a pointed brush rather than felt tip or non pointed brush. It really does glide and the brush makes it easier for me to use. The color is nice and intense enough. Beautiful packaging.
Con: Be careful bc it is very liquidy and can get messy (especially when it's new). I stored it upside down to avoid this. I have oily eyelids and it's not the most waterproof/smudge proof on its own, but it's not terrible. Doesn't smudge when I wear it over eyeshadow.
Seriously.... it amazing
Newbie88 from Kansas City, MO
I am not good at makeup lol. Like... its a real challenge for me. But this stuff makes me look like I might actually know what I'm doing! Its glides on sooooo smooth and even. I have not had a single issue with smudging and it stays on all day. I just finished my fist container of it, and just logged on to buy a second. Worth every penny!
The longest lasting eyeliner
Labiba from VA
My first time using this was for work and girrllll it lasted all day and looked flawless!! It didn't smudge or anything at all. It's so easy to apply as well. It lasted all day even after working for 8 hours, I was so amazed. I love this eyeliner and I actually have 2 of them currently because I bought one a few weeks ago and then used the promotion for a free liner. I would definitely recommend for everyone!!
I love this eyeliner. Recommended by Ulta staff.
Syephany from Topeka,KS
Love this eyeliner!
So Cal Gal from So Cal
I love this eyeliner. It is smooth and so easy to use. It lasts a long time, unlike some other liquid eyeliner that dry out within a few weeks. Worth every penny!
Ree from Charleston, WV
I'm always looking for a good eyeliner. Had a little free time so I stopped in ulta to look for a new eyeliner and just was not it. While in the parking lot I shook it and then tried to apply it to my eyes. I looked my eyeball was solid black. it came out too fast. I will be returning it.
I will buy over and over
Autumn from Wy
This is by far the best liquid liner I've owned. I truly don't understand the 1 star reviews, its long lasting, goes on incredibly smooth, doesn't budge, and the product lasts so so much longer than the other super expensive types I've bought. Usually I can't get more than a month out of others before they dry up and I easily got 3 or more out of this product.
Don't waste your time buying!!
Lovetay from Buckeye
This eyeliner smudges quickly. Doesn't last a long time. I would recommend another eyeliner before I would recommend this one.
It's not bad....just not what I'm used to
Babydoll from East la
this has a fine point ... glides on effortlessly... but did flake a bit which wasn't really a big deal to reapply a tiny bit. Other than that i actually like it.... it's not bad I've just had better. As long as you store this upright or even just leave it in an upright position for some time and shake it before use you won't have problems
Love brush tip, hate the formula
princesspeach from Shorewood
Brush tip liquid eyeliners are my go-to. I like them better than felt tips because felt tips can get pilly and typically don't deliver as good a performance than a brush tip. I definitely like how smooth this liquid liner goes on, but it's not as black as I would like, and it is most certainly NOT WATERPROOF. As someone with year-round outdoor allergies/occasional watery eyes, I always look for a waterproof liner to help combat runny eye looks. This liquid liner bleeds very easily and runs the second my eyes get a little watery. Very disappointing.
glam from Portland, Me
This is not waterproof at all. One drop of water causes this liner to run like bad mascara
HAYFAB from Orlando
Literally one of the best eyeliners I've ever owned lol. I splurged a bit and got this eyeliner. Stayed on while crying and a nap. Haha. Nice application. It's so worth it.
This product is a joke
Laila from TX
I kid you not, this is the worst eyeliner I've ever used. I wore it to school and my entire right wing was completely smudged off within 3 hrs! I knew this product was sketchy as soon as I shook it up and barely anything would come out. The packaging is pretty and it's easy to apply, it just needs a better formula. Literally everything the box says this product is, it's all a lie.
I will definitely buy this product again! Fabulous!
Julie B from OR
It goes on so smoothly and lasts until you take it off!
merb from South dakota
My 16 yr old daughter and I love this eyeliner. I have oily eyelids but It stays on all day, washes off easily enough and the pen lasts quite a while.
Stina from Denver
Now this eyeliner is fantastic! I love it! It stays on and it doesn't smudge one bit! Long lasting!
So easy to apply
Peach purple from Villanova PA
This eyeliner is so easy to apply as it glides on my lids effortlessly and with the right amount of line. It also seems to last a long time. If I add more shadow after application of this liner, then it does dull the darkness of the black shade but I can easily go in and build on the liner.
Lynn from Ohio
Best ever! A must have!
Best eyeliner ever!
Casey from Michigan
This eyeliner is literally the best eyeliner I have ever used and I do big wings every single day. It's easy to use, very black and has a nice sharp pint every time! I will never buy another eyeliner because nothing compares!