Rated 3.86 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review End Game
Guys listen... I wore this Better Than Sex eyeliner and I winged it out to the gods... I applied waterproof mascara... I wore it all day and there was no transferring, leaking, this liner was in it for the long haul. I went and saw Avengers End Game and I cried 3 times. Teared up about 2 times... After the movie I went to the bathroom thinking I'm looking like a mess like I'm going through a rough break up or some tough life stuff ya know? Oh my god... my liner was SOLID. It was a real trooper, this liner stayed on and hung on for dear life, it was not budging through all these tears. Even my mascara held up. My friend was amazed I got to walk out of that theater with the liner still so sharp and fresh it could cut through diamond. Worth the money, will be purchasing again. I recommend this to everyone!
Most Helpful Critical Review False Claims
I was so excited to use this eyeliner. The Ulta worker that helped me told me how this is the most amazing eyeliner because it lasts 24 hours, it's smudge-proof, and water-proof. I asked if he's ever tried it (he didn't). If he did, he would know these claims are absolutely false.
I shook the eyeliner a lot before I opened it (the box said to shake and I read many reviews that said shaking is the key to getting good pigmentation). I started applying it by using the tip to make the tail/flick of my cat eye. The color was sheer, it looked almost grey. I shook it some more and applied the same way again. The color coming off the top was still very sheer. I used the body of the brisk to go over my lash line. The color didn't improve much. I went to do my other eye and I noticed the color was a bit darker, but not as dark as I wanted.
When I inspected both eyes, I noticed a ton of color transferred from my lash line to my lid (I hate this). Since I had a mess on my lid, I decided to test out the "smudge-proof" claim. It smudged on both eyes easily and spread the color all over my eyes. I was able to use just water to remove all the color.
I was so disappointed in this product. It didn't deliver on any of it's claims. I couldn't imagine this eyeliner lasting more than a few hours. Stick with Stila. I'm returning this next time in near an Ulta.
Reviewed by 493 customers I will never go back
LizB from Fl
Best eyeliner. Periodt.
Michelle from San Antonio
Loved how easy this was to use and the detailed look, but the product did not last long and was kinda pricey for not much product.
Fern from Dallas te
Sucks it dried out and the bristles on the brush started coming out
I would buy this product again!
KG from Phoenix az
Too faced is my to go to brand always! I love this eyeliner! Easy to put on, lasts all day through it all.
mythstilleto from NY
Great and easy application but it's farrrr from being waterproof.
HW from Russell, PA
I have purchased this product in the past, I think I have gone through 5 of them. It was hands down the best eye liner I have ever owned until the last one. The brush was seperated when I got it, and some of the bristles were going off in another direction from the rest. I used scissors to cut them off, but this particular purchase had trouble the entire time, drying out faster, and it didn't last nearly as long as previous items. I am hoping it was a glitch and the one I am ordering today is back to the wonderful liner I am used to getting from Too Faced!!!
Emma from Los Angels
I love this eyeliner. Easy to use and beautiful!
It's pretty good
Amanda from Phoenix
I love how easily this is applied, its much smoother and more accurate than a traditional liquid eyeliner. It lasts a long time on my lash line, but when I do winged liner the wings wear off within a couple hours. I'm not a particularly oily person and I don't wear oil based makeup so I'm not sure why it doesn't last, it just starts to fade and that's a bummer. Luckily it doesn't flake at all like some other formulas I've tried. So overall the product is great on my lash line and well made, just isn't what I need for winged liner for whatever my skin composition is apparently:(
Easiest Wing Eyeliner
DarthXana from North Carolina
This is my favorite eyeliner. It draws on with a smooth, thin line. This makes it super easy to draw winged eyeliners. It's long wearing, dark, and smooth.
Not worth the money
Anonymous from Mississippi
Bought this because of the good reviews. This product was not waterproof. I have this a fair shot using almost the whole container before throwing it away. This liner constantly smudged or ran. I have hooded eyes and usually don't have issues with liners running into the crease or transferring to the skin of the hood but this one did frequently. I also don't use liner or mascara on my lower eye or lower lashes yet this liner always ran/relocated to my under eye. This eye liner is definitely not better than sex but can make you look like you had a some. Again, a total disappointment when you haven't had any.
Barlie from CA - California
Glides on smoothly. Deep pigment. Stays on all day even at the inner eye. LOVE it!!!
first eyeliner and so easy to apply
jjl from washington state
first of all i have to say i love this product. it lasts all day. through sweat and eye rubbing it stays on strong. highly recommend!
I LOVE THIS EYELINER!
LC725 from Oklahoma
This is by far the best eyeliner I've ever used! The full size pen makes it so easy to handle and the sharp felt tip ends makes it so easy to do precise straight lines! It's a game changer for sure!
Yes I will buy this product again
TMJ from Milwaukee Wi
I use this over my lash line it goes on so smoothly.
Barb from Findlay Ohio
This is perfect!! I dont have much control using a brush for liner anymore and this is PERFECT!!!
Shelly from Indianapolis Indiana
Use everyday easy to use very black which I love
Don't do what it says to do
Tatiana from Tampa florida
I put on my eye liner and is supposed to stay on and it comes off withing an hour. Not happy with the product at all.
Perseis from Texas, Houston
It's great, applies great and doesn't smear or flake!
It looks beautiful but not waterproof
Guera from compton ca
i put it on n i love how it looks but not sweatproof. My side loop faded out with my sweat n not even 2 hours of wearing it.
I love this eyeliner. It's very easy to use.
Lovelydust from Mableton, GA
I use this to draw the cat line. It glides on very easy.
Packaging could be better
Mariealana from Los Angeles
I do like the eyeliner but it never fails. ..If you are not careful when you put the cap back on, the tip will get bent. This has happened with every single one, even when I am careful! It's super annoying because it ruins it and you can no longer use it. I've also received ones that have dried up in a matter of weeks. BUT when you get a good batch... it's oh soooo good!
**Waste of money**
ZL from MA
I don't know if I purchased a dried out pen or something, but this product was terrible. Even if I just received a bad pen, no one should have to spend so much for an eyeliner and still have a chance of receiving a faulty product. It was not pigmented and difficult to apply. There are so many drug store liquid liners that do the job. This product was not worth trying.
I would buy again
Trac from Sequim Washington
The first tube I got dried up fast in less than 2 weeks I was very disappointed but of course ulta gave me a new one. Love this store
B from SGV
I love how dark the color is and goes on flawlessly
I love this eye liner!!!
Southern Suz from Saint George, UT
I love that it stays put all day long.