Rated 4.21 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review OMG HG Status!
This eye pencil is the best eye liner I've ever used!!! I'm 55 years old -- believe me, I've tried a lot of eyeliners in my life time. This eyeliner glides on smooth without tugging and delievers bold pigmented color. The best part? on my really oily lids it stayed on ALL DAY. No transfer to my hooded eye and no smearing or smudging. I absolutely adore this and I'm back to buy more colors!
Most Helpful Critical Review Hard to sharpen
The actual product lasts a long time without running or fading, but the pencil tip quickly goes dull after two applications. Sharpening this thing is a nightmare. You burn through a huge amount of pencil just to get the tip sharp and intact. My pencil lasted one week of everyday use because so much had to be sharpened out. It's really a bummer because the gel liner itself is one of the best ones I've used.
Reviewed by 433 customers Unable to sharpen
Living from Brandon Florida
This pencil will not sharpens. Love the product but waste of money if you can't use it.
Worst Eyeliner I've ever used
T from OR
It's so difficult to put on. Lots of gaps. No playtime. I have no idea who this works for.
MELISSA from Louisiana
This eyeliner is my favorite. It doesn't smudge and goes on easily. But, like many other reviews have stated, it's impossible to sharpen! It breaks and doesn't sharpen to a point. It also get soft. Ugh come on smashbox, do something about this! I'm literally thinking of going back to my last brand because of this.
Face value from Jackson Bh
Perfect dark black eye liner a pleasure to put on does t get all smudgy all over the place
Favorite gel liner
Emily from PA
This is my current favorite gel liner that I've tried. Goes on smooth and dark.
I love this eye liner
Lori from Florida
I love this eyeliner because it goes on smooth and stays on. The only downfall is that I had to try a couple different locations to find in stock.
lizzy from ny
great the best easy
Smashbox gel eyeliner pencil
Soni from San Antonio
it is horrible eye pencil
Not what I wanted
Ashley from AL
I was looking for a liner that would not smudge on my eyelids when wearing but was not able to perform to my expectations; smudged on eyelids.
I love this!!!!
Lauri from TX
I love the gel eyeliner. I actually last long, doesn't smudge, and doesn't infect my tear ducts. The only issue is that it really doesn't last long meaning you run through the product quickly because you will always be sharpening it. Also, it took me forever to figure out that it's a pen you sharpen with a pencil sharpener and not a twist pen.
Would not recommend.
Brandy_tx from Texas
Barely used and then can not turn to get more eyeliner and can not sharpen.
Smashbox is Amazing!!
Anna99x from TX
Many eyeliners say they stay put all day but this one really does. I have severe allergies and this one stays put. I've tried them all. Hands down better than Lancome.
Best on the water line eyeliner that I have found!
Chas from Tampa, FL
Goes on very black and stays on for hours. No smudging.
I don't bother with other liners
Debbie from Portland OR
He depth of the black is consistent all day.
My go to pencil eyeliner
Irais from Fort Wayne, IN
My go to eyeliner! Does not smudge and it is very black! Just what I like!!
VK from Chicago
Love this eyeliner. Goes on smoothly, doesn't smudge, and lasts all day.
Love this stuff!
Neels from Kansas City
Great for tight lining your eyes!
Best eyeliner if you don't want to have creases!!
Ikl987 from Evans Ga
I absolutely cannot live without this one. I used to use 24/7 urban decay, Bobby brown, too faced, bare minerals just to name a few. This beats all of em. This lasts all day, doesn't crease on your folds. Best eyeliner ever
Kay Bee from Raleigh, NC
I generally LOVE this liner.... but the past few purchases, the wood gets all broken with sharpening. It used to glide on, set, and stay all day... now it smudges, barely applies, when sharpened, breaks all sort of ways... I was in love with it, but now I'll have to search for a new one again.
I think I got a bad one 😩
Ash from Maryland
I got a sample of this eye liner in my ipsy bag and loved it. So I bought a full size liner. When I went to use it, I had to sharpen it first. The pencil kept breaking off. When I was able to apply it, barely went on! So shocked and disappointed 😞
Difficult to Sharpen? Buy the Ulta Cosmetic Pencil Sharpener
Elissa from Midwest USA
So after having extreme difficulty sharpening this, I went straight to my local Ulta and asked for help. I was previously trying to sharpen with a Clinique sharpener, but the staff directed me to the Ulta Cosmetic Pencil Sharpener (https://www.ulta.com/cosmetic-pencil-sharpener?productId=prod1951196). I was skeptical at first but she was so helpful. She even tried it herself with the Ulta sharpener to make sure it worked and it looked perfect after. It did not break off or have jagged edges like it did before. For all of $2.50 my problem was solved. This eye liner is amazing. It lasts all day and doesn't build up in the corner of my eyes. Glad staff was so willing to help!
Rebeck from Pleasant Hill
Smooth, easy to put on, and last a long time.
Smooth and no transfer
Erin from Baltimore
Love this for a more natural look and stays put even in my waterline!
Maymom from California
This has been my ultimate favorite eyeliner
I like the way to glides a little pricey but so worth it
May buy it again
Tams from Arlington WA
I have hooded eyes and typically find that by the end of the day my liner has transferred to my eyelids. This stays put. It would have gotten 5 stars except it is difficult to keep sharp.