Rated 3.88 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Best waterline pencil liner EVER!!! Please don't stop making
The best liner for my upper and lower waterline EVER!!! My eyes get watery and oily. Other liners never stay on. They smudge off within minutes.
This liner stays on till I remove it the next day with my eyes makeup remover. This doesn't smudge on me.
Please always keep making this product!!! There's nothing like it out there for me. I won't be able to live without it.
Most Helpful Critical Review Another letdown by UD
I debated on buying this after being let down by their 27/7 eyeliner and lip liners. I ended up purchasing this in the color Street and while this did glide on very smoothly, it did take a couple of layers to really get the pigmentation. Unfortunately, after 3 hours, I can see that the pigmentation has faded quite a bit and the product has already worn off of the outer corners of both the top and bottom waterlines. In addition, it has also leaked/smudged in the outer corners of my eyes.
Overall, just another basic, overpriced eyeliner, that I would not recommend.
Reviewed by 1129 customers I would purchase this product again
Diva from Chicago
Creamy. Long lasting rich in color. Good value.
Well worth the money!!
Michelle the hairdresser from Council Bluffs, Is
I absolutely love Urban Decay's eyeliner!! It actually stays on all day!! More importantly, it does not run down my face!! This product also lasts longer than any others I have tried!! Well worth the money!!
KittyVetTech from IL
This is the best waterline pencil ever. It doesn't transfer to lower waterline. Stays put and doesn't smudge. Would recommend to friends.
Seems like a regular liner.
Jess from North Hollywood
Nothing too special about it. Seems like a any other drug store eyeliner. Does not stay on all day
Sarah from OH
I bought this bc it was half off with decent reviews and I was running low on my regular eyeliner that I've been using for years. Unfortunatly this liner wears off in the waterline and starts rubbing off and smudging in the corner of my eye after less than 5 hours. It is very smooth and easy to apply but I won't purchase again.
I would not buy this product again.
Rhonda from Kansas
I was expecting the eyeliner to at least last 6-7 hours. Within an hour of putting it on it had faded away. Could not even tell I had eyeliner on. Very disappointed in product, will not buy again.
Didn't stay for more than an hour
Sar from New Jersey
I was excited to use this eyeliner since it specifically states it's for the waterline however it didn't stay on my waterline at all! I put it on and an hour later I looked in the mirror and was SHOCKED when I saw it was almost completely gone! It either flaked under my eyes or got caught on the edge of my lashes. I looked like I hadn't taken my makeup off from the night before, not like I had just put it on! I'm so upset with this product
Like it but not in love with it :(
MomZ from Chicago, IL
I like how it's easy to apply. it glides smoothly on the waterline. However, it doesn't stay for more than an hour for me. I have tried a few times and had the same experience :(
I really like this pencil
Kelly from Ohio
I decided to try this pencil since it was on sale and I'm happy I did! It goes on smoothly and doesn't run under my eyes during the day. I will purchase it again.
ASHESS2ASHESS87 from Albany OR
I was hesitant at first, most liners dont actually show up on my water line! This one absolutely works and looks great! It doesnt irritate my eyes either!
Makeup Look Changing
ACC from Concord, CA
I am 53 and have been wearing makeup for almost 40 years. I have never worn waterline liners because when I tried them back in the day they were not easy to apply and didn't seem safe since we used to melt it and such. I saw this and decided to try this and I'm so glad I did. I used to use bold lipstick colors and light eye makeup. Now with masks being the new norm it's all about the eyes so I've had to put away all my fun lipstick and experiment with eye makeup.
This liner was makeup routing altering. It's creamy and easy to apply and it lasts all day. It is a different look for me and I love it. It stays on so well that you can't really remove it all so you'll have some residue which also looks cool. I never even knew to apply this to the upper lid! I am a fan forever. I will try to apply colored liner to my upper lash line now too for added bold looks.
DeeDee from Orange County, CA
This was the first time I tried them. They go on so smooth and last all day!!!
Taylor from Georgia
I bought this because it claims to be a Waterline pencil that is water proof. It definitely is not water proof and I had to reapply after only a couple of hours. I bought two because it was on sale and I will be returning.
Bjmacx from Detroit, MI
I really love these pencils. I brought seven of them and will buy again and again!
FL curls from Panama City, FL
I normally only use Clinique as I have sensitive everything! I love this! It's great and doesn't come off until I take it off.
Would not buy again
Sherri from Florida
Was so hoping this would stay in my waterline and not under my eye. Disappointed
Does not work!!
Beachgirl from Tampa Florida
I went over and over 20 times just to barely see the color!! I bought two because I was excited to use this product. I am so disappointed with it will never buy another product from this line!!!
I will not be without!!!
Sheri from AR
On top waterline is where I use this
Not what I expected.
Helen L. from South Carolina
I bought this product for the first time and was very excited to use it. It applies very easily and smoothly and is also very easy to blend. After a few hours of were I was disappointed though. The liner migrated to the inner corners of my eyes an seemed to disappear from the rest of my lower lash line. The product is advertised as 24 hour water proof wear. That is not my experience.
Az from Phoenix, AZ
It's stay in place all day and I have very oily skin. What I like the most it's how easy it's to remove because it won't make you rub your eyes to get it off.
Rosa from Tampa
I'm really disappointed with this eyeliner for the price i was expecting something really good but unfortunately this eyeliner waste of money!!! The color is not even black. Don't recommend it and never buy it again.
Jackie from Cypress CA
I've been looking for eyeliner for my waterline forever all the ones I've tried smudge with in minutes and make me look like I have raccoon eyes but this one stays on I have an oily face so I put powder by my waterline to keep it from smudging and it works great would definitely recommend and this is now my new favorite waterline eyeliner
Not dark and does not stay
LS from Glendora
It was not as black as I like, came off in 4 hours and ran under eyes. I will stick to MAC eyeliner.
This doesn't stay on either. Not buying it again.
April from SC - South Carolina
it doesn't stay on. Its false advertisement......
I would buy this item again!
Cindy from Livonia, MI
I used it daily and it lasted all day and did not smear.