Product Reviews Rated 3.69 out of 5 stars
565 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Good Budget Water-resistant Mascara I needed a very waterproof mascara that came in a brown or brown/black color because my eyes water a LOT. This was a pretty good fit. It was waterproof...for a while. After a few hours, I would begin to get some smudging and flaking. Perfect for a quick shopping trip or lunch with the girls, but I wouldn't use it for a nice, extended night out. The product seemed very hard to remove with waterproof eye makeup remover pads- even after I had worn the product all day and then showered. The wand took a few tries to learn how to use effectively, but this is the best BUDGET waterproof mascara I have used yet- and I have tried about 10.
Most Helpful Critical Review RIDICULOUS! This mascara did not do what it promised at all. It touts a "unique, flexible" brush, which I found very annoying. It was like applying mascara with a broken wand. It wasn't rigid, so the application of product on my lashes was uneven and very clumpy. The product itself also looked old and dried out. I purchased the waterproof version, so I'm unsure if the regular version would be any better. I am very disappointed and I will not be buying this mascara again.
Reviewed by 565 customers Good mascara 4
Unknown from Jehdjdjdjdjd
This mascara is very good at making you eyelashes look very long. But you have to end up scrubbing your face with makeup remover to get it off which is not good for your eyelashes. But I will say it is VERY WATERPROOF and does not not smudge easily. If you don't want to have to use makeup remover on your eyes every night I recommend the non waterproof one it looks identical just easier to get off.
Favorite 5
Jynx from USA
Perfect in every way. I've gotten 3 tubes so far. Need a new one. Just makes my lashes so long and amazing!!!
It's just mascara 3
FFHGRAMMY from Miami
It is a good Maybelline mascara, but does not live up to its "hype."
One of my all time favorites 5
Christy from Illinois
Love how dark and long it makes my lashes
Good mascara 5
Madison from San Diego California
This mascara is really good if you're on a budget.
it works great for me 5
elle from texas
i have lashes that weight down so i have to use waterproof mascara as my base. it lengthens my lashes about half a centimeter( which is actually a lot), and keeps them unclumped. just make sure you wait for each coat to dry before adding another. i noticed that it flakes but so do most waterproof mascaras so i just put a normal one on top of this. definitely a great base!
VOLUME VOLUME VOLUME 5
Joce from Buffalo, New York
I love this mascara, it does a great job of making my lashes full, long and dark. It lasts all day and is comparable if not better (IMO) than the more expensive brands.
More like falsie...advertisie... 3
ninakretina from New Orleans
As I was deciding to buy a new untested mascara, this one popped up. Many youtubers swear on it and I can't understand why. After applying 2-3 coats of this, my lashes only look clumpy and weighted down. And even the waterproof one smudge all over. I love Lash Sensational but this one is a dud and a hard pass.
I won't buy this again 2
K.Candid from California
I'm really torn, I loved the way this mascara made my eyes look, but it isn't even waterproof. A bit of sweat will make this mascara run down my cheeks. NOT cute. I would originally put up with it, but I'm really over having to check up on my eyes every hour, especially on hot days!!
Nice wand 4
BB from Chambersburg, PA
The shape of the wand makes for the easiest application for top and bottom lashes. It's also seriously waterproof. If you are looking for dramatic lashes, you'll have to build this one up.
too hard to remove 3
osita from Las Vegas
I been using this product for several years, but there are too many variations of it, therefore; I bought the waterproof by mistake thinking it eas the same I used before. I will never buy this product again.
I love this mascara, I have short and thin lashes. 5
angie from roseville,ca
Love this mascara and I'm a mature woman with short and thin lashes.
I like it better pairs with a primer and eye lash curler too.
love love love 5
2spirit from idaho
Ok so I bought this and didn't like it bcuz I used it wrong. I realized I had to use the flat side of the brush and it gives u instant volume and length. I have the oilest skin type known to man and it stays on all day. This has quickly become my new favorite mascara.
Good waterproof, but hard to remove with soap and water 3
Jen from Beaumont
This mascara is awesome, but it clumps and pulls out lashes of you try to remove it with just basic soap and water. Plus it's not as pretty on my lashes as the other falsies (volume)
Hold the Curl! 5
Emily from DC
I always keep one as backup. It holds the curl after using the curler. Lashes look very full and lengthy! Some downsides: When it's new, it's a bit wet~ After a while, it becomes having very good effects. A little bit smudges on the bottom eyelid when it's kind of drying out (you can actually feel the clumps when you put it on)and about time to throw away. Overall, this is so far my favorite drugstore mascara!
Not a fan 1
Chelsy from Ohio
Hard to remove. Doesn't work the way it's described. Don't recommend
Garbo 2
B from couch
not great on its own but okay for layering. still won't buy again because it transfers as if it weren't waterproof at all. save your coins.
Smudges 2
Kellyers from Tulsa, Ok
It looks great, but it stays kinda tacky so it smudges on my bottom lashes
My current Fav! 5
Marie from Douglasville, Ga
I love how this makes my lashes long and pop out! I especially love how the waterproof version doesn't flake or get ugly when I cry or even when I have to take a quick shower.
Highly recommend if you want a mascara that doesn't get off if you cry easily, like me, or anything related to water.
my favorite mascara 4
Steph from California
My lashes are very straight. I don't even have to curl them with this mascara. It gives you a winged out look. I love it.
Great 5
Jay from Nc
Great
Great waterproof mascara! 5
Beachgirl from Topsail Island, NC
Love this mascara and it will be my new go to.
Good 5
Iman from Amherst
Very good
Unexpected Perfection! 5
Kiki from Macon, GA
I picked this mascara up prior to going on a cruise because I just wanted something inexpensive and waterproof. After using it for the first time, I was honestly bitter about the fact that I'd wasted so much money on Better Than Sex for years. My lashes aren't exactly the longest and like to stick straight out, but this mascara makes them look absolutely bangin'. No clumps, full volume, the works. Highly recommended!
My to go mascara! 5
Dumham from Cape Coral, FL
Make my lashes look so long and thick.
