Rated 3.87 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review I would buy this again
I really loved it. Was really creamy and gave me the look I was going for. I like that I was able to use it in my waterline without it burning.
Most Helpful Critical Review Pretty good but not the best...Smudges
I've been using this eyeliner for about 4 months now and I have to say its pretty good but when I bought it I was excited thinking I finally got an eyeliner that wouldnt smudge...WRONG! It does smudge near the lower eye and it runs if you use it on your waterline (which in my case is very frustrating) I constantly have to worry about it running or smudging...I dont have the peace of mind that at the end of the day its gonna look the same way as when I 1st put it on. It doesnt smudge horribly bad but I'm definitely searching for a better one.
OH and another thing...IT DOESNT LAST LONG AT ALL WHEN USED ON A DAILY BASIS!
Reviewed by 436 customers Better than any luxury brand
MissBus from St Louis, MO
I have tried dozens and dozens of pencil and retractable eyeliners and this by far has the best staying power on the market. I keep coming back to it and always have it in my make up bag because it is the most reliable and stays on all day even on oily eyelids. It helps even set the eyeshadow I put over it. The black is my favorite and has the most pigment. Thus isn't for those that only want a fine line, however, but it is very buildable and easy to control.
I will definitely buy again!
Lilliland from Erie, PA
Someone recommended this product and it's great - very black, glides on, no smudging. Narrow point so application is a dream. Great value too.
I would buy this again.
myrn53 from Prairie Grove, Arkansas
Best eyeliner I have ever found.
I wouldn't buy this again
Garcia91 from Dallas Tx
I didn't like that I kept going back and forth trying to color my waterline black. I don't
Think I'd buy this again even if it was my last resort. At the end it didn't give my waterline any color
Love this eye pencil because it glides on smooth!
Tata from Auburn, AL
Glides on smooth and doesn't tug at your eye. Plus you don't have to sharpen it!! Big plus!
Prof from NYC
Product billed as waterproof and long wearing. I didn't get out of the door before it was smeared all around my eyes. Really bad product!
buttercupevr from Visalia, CA
I was hoping the tip would self sharpen with the cap, but it does not.
Happy from Raleigh
Love this eyeliner!! Goes on easily & stays on all day!
Happy from Raleigh
Love this mascara! Goes on easily and stays all day!
Nikki from Denver
I have been using this eyeliner since middle school! In the last year I got really into YouTube and was trying all of the influencer eyeliner suggestions instead of this. Every other liner I tried claimed to be smudge proof, and they weren't. I work 12 hour shifts as a nurse. I need staying power! I just repurchased this today after a year of trying other brands! I love this so much! I'm at work now, 8 hours in and no smudge yet! I will just stick with this from now on : ) my favorite!
This is my new go to eyeliner.
Stephanie from St Helens
This is a great liner. Cleans off with soap and water perfectly.
Not as pigmented as I would have liked.
JEP from Hickory, NC
I bought this product for my waterline. The color didn't show up nearly as black as I wanted.
I would buy this product again , need no sharpening.
sunshine from oceanside,ca
This product is good and I would use it again and again. No need sharpening and waterproof.
IS NOT WATERPROOF
Cindylouwho from Louisville
"Maybelline Unstoppable Eyeliner has a smudge-proof, stay-put, waterproof formula that won't budge until you want it to." This is totally UNTRUE....IT WILL AND DOES BUDGE....I bought TWO because it's supposedly waterproof. Smh....when will I learn not to buy makeup online?! Smh I bought TWO!!!! SMH
It was broken when I opened it. And not good at all.
Kirti from Jersey city
It was broken when I opened it not satisfied at all.
Smudges easily not unstoppable
Sky from Everett, WA
Smudges and its not a great product at all
Janie from Oak Ridge, TN
This is amazing! I have sensitive eyes and I wear this on my waterline. It stays on all day without smudging or smearing and it doesn't irritate my eyes. It goes on easily too and lasts a long time!
I would buy this product again
Bonnie A. from Woodville, Tx
I love this eyeliner.
Sarah from Dallas
Easy to apply, super smooth! Love the color.
I will continue to buy this eyeliner!
Calli from West Virginia
I use it to do a smoky eye look.
Best drugstore liner I've tried
Tessa2me from Raleigh, NC
My favorite drugstore liner. I have hooded eyes and always worried about liner transferring to my upper lids but this stays put all day and is a great pigmented matte black. I kinda compare it to the Marc Jacobs highliner. Love love love it!
Tiffersheart from Seattle, WA
Pros: This product does glide on easy. There's a decent range of color. The pencil is thin enough to go as light or bold as you want.
Cons: After an hour, I noticed smearing and smudging on both my top and bottom lid. I only applied to the top lids, so it must have drifted down. I am pretty diligent about not touching my eyes after makeup. I got the color sapphire which goes on like a navy but after the smudging, it looked like a faded blue.
great for waterline
Dapixbeauty from Chicago
I have hooded eyes so I've been using this eyeliner on my waterline. it works well without burning my eyes or Nam ng them dry. I wish it had deeper color though like a lot of girls mentioned already.
Nj from Ohio
I wish it was a darker black but it stays on all day!!
Barb On The Beach from North Little Rock, AR
After the second day, about an inch of it broke off and it seems like there is not very much of it left. I have only had it a couple of weeks :-(