Product Reviews Rated 3.92 out of 5 stars
213 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review I'm in Love !! This product GREAT!!
I'm terrible with eye makeup and with EVERY other eye pencil I've never been able to get a perfect application on my waterline and I was almost in tears when I got it finally with this pencil
I think this pencil is great for beginners and others like me who struggle with waterline application
It's not getting a 5 star from me because with my 2nd pencil my tip broke on the first try..ugh
But that being said I'm returning a pencil I bought before to exchange it for another one of these
Formula is amazing and I love it!!
I always fall in love with super dark eye pencil and this pencil in black onyx is one of the darkest I've found
Most Helpful Critical Review Absolutely not worth it. This eyeliner pencil was okay in my opinion. The texture is pretty soft and creamy. I personally don't think eyeliners like this are easy to apply, but when I did apply it, it looked pretty good. It worked really well when I applied it onto my waterline. However, it but was hard to apply to the top of my eyelids and make a wing. I also found it smudged easily and expected that it won't because the description said it supposed to be "long wearing and 36-hour coverage" I probably wouldn't repurchase it. I received this product free for testing. I received this product complimentary for review purposes. Do not waste your money.
Reviewed by 213 customers a great formulation that works 5
Shrewsburyan from MA
You must get a specialized eye pencil sharpener for skinny pencils. There are several. This pencil is difficult to sharpen without wasting a lot of the pencil.
Poor manufacturing 1
Tipper from Pennsylvania
Poor production control..BUT Ulta replaced it no questioned
Wish it Glided On More Smoothly 3
Wendy1 from McKinney,TX
I found I had to press hard on my lashline to use this. I was used to eye pencils that glided on more easily. The color is good and looks like the color in the picture. It lasted pretty well, but it's uncomfortable to apply.
I wouldn't buy again 1
McTwirly from Peterborough NH
It stays on, if you can get it on - but it is impossible to sharpen, breaks off and gums up the sharpener.
Hated the plastic outer shell 1
Jen from Keene,NH
Tried to line my upper lid but color stick kept breaking and I wasn't even pushing hard
Best eyeliner 5
Ambypop from New Mexico
I love this eyeliner, the shade stands out very well. It lasts all day and is easy to apply.
No 1
Aly from WV
It was very easy to use, and its color is rich, but I could not afford it on my eyes, during an hour causing the swelling of my eyelids.
I would not buy this product again 1
Kiran from Yuba city
It says smudge proof but it's not.
Best eyeliner 5
Meme from Chesapeake Virginia
Tried all kind of eyeliners and this one is the best
Definite favorite 5
DebNP from Georgia
Great for us mature ladies to line the waterline to increase the natural look
Irritated my eyes 2
GWjedi from Cincinnati, Ohio
I got this to try on my waterline and tightline bc it said it was waterproof. I tested it on my tightline before washing my face and going to bed. It was nice and creamy and super easy to apply. Unfortunately, my eyes started watering as I got ready for bed. When I woke up the next morning, my eyes looked like I had been crying for hours; red, puffy, and watering. It took hours for the effects to go away. I'm sure this product is great for some people, but do NOT use on a waterline if you have sensitive eyes.
Yes I would. But I can't sharpen the eyeliner. 3
Princess Gail from Clarkston, WA
I really like this product long lasting. But every time I go to Sharpen it it breaks off. Again and again
I wouldn't buy the product again 2
Ann from Corpus Christi Texas
Rhe product would be good it I didn't water so much trying to sharpen it
Yes 5
Crazy Carol from Tinley Park, Il
It stays on all day !
Best Lasting Eyeliner 5
Chris from Alabama
This is one of the best eyeliner compared to high end and low end liners. I love Fenty liners and Benefit Roller liner but this just stays on perfect and is deep. I love the black eye liner. I see a lot of people had trouble sharpening but I bought the Ulta pencil sharpener and had no trouble with the liner. It definitely helps with the hard to sharpen pencils and jumbo pencils.
Loved it. Went on smoothly and lasted all day. 5
Mumma from Appleton, WI
Used it to line my upper lash line. Was easy to remove.
I milght buy this product again 4
mo girl from Milssouri
I loved this product when I first got it but as a little time wore on it was very hard to get it to go on easily. The tip wears down way to fast and its hard to apply.
Really wanted to like it 2
AS from Syracuse, NY
I really wanted to like this product, and I did at first. Now I am terribly disappointed. I have tried numerous brands and types of eyeliners and even now, have to agree that Makeup Forever Aqua Eyeliner Pencils are still only the true waterproof ones out there, and limited to some colors (like the gray No. 14). Marc Jacob gel liner is pretty good too. But, after reading reviews I was hopeful that Maybelline Tattoo Eyeliner pencils would beat them all. I ordered charcoal, navy and violet. The violet was lighter and pinker than I would have liked. The charcoal and used with a little navy over it was perfect UNTIL I took a walk on a hot sunny day with my husband and he asked me what was wrong with my eyes. Definitely not waterproof! Smudged and mirrored the line over my eye lids.
I'm now back searching for the perfect waterproof eyeliner, specially in shades of charcoal, navy and deep purple.
Yes, I would purchase again 5
Betty Bbop from Clovis CA
Really like how it slides on smooth but not too dramatic
I'd prefer a liquid eyeliner 3
Lisa from New Jersey
The product glided On very nicely although the pencil picked up some of my makeup that it went over. It's a nice pencil but it breaks fairly easily
This product irritates my eyes and makes them red 1
Tare from Ceader Hill Texaa
I would not use this product again
What you see is all there is!! 1
Andrea from Pittsburgh
The small tip of product that you see upon purchase is all there is! There is no way to advance more eyeliner. Disposable eyeliner at non-disposal price. Don't waste your money.
Deep rich color 5
Prissy from San Antonio tx
Very pretty color
Not waterproof 1
Allyh214 from Austin, Tx
It's not waterproof or long wearing.
No smudging 5
Cfletcher from Houston
this stays on ALL day without smudging or smears! Absolutely love it!!!
