Product Reviews Rated 3.91 out of 5 stars
33 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review I LOVE THIS EYELINER I saw Tati's youtube video she did on this eyeliner, when I first saw it I though it was going to be very glittery but surprisingly is not. It has an amazing pigmentation and shimmer is just right not over done, Tati wore the purple one and OMG lookd amazing on her....I tried the brown one, and the rose gold one, super awesome, I just purchased 2 new shades.......btw brush is very flexible I can do from a thin to a very bold line.....
Most Helpful Critical Review Avoid this eyeliner I wanted to use this as an eyeliner but found the product to be overly liquidy. In fact, when I opened the cap, my countertop was splashed by eyeliner liquid. I was initially excited about the rose color but after I cleaned up the excess liquid on the eyeliner, and applied what I thought was going to be a perfect wing, the eyeliner dripped down from my wing and INTO my eye. Painful. I bled out some of the eyeliner on a paper towel and prayed that I had eliminated enough of the liquid to try to apply it again. I was successful this time but I had to layer on about five layers (with dry time in between) in order for the excessively light pink color to even show up on my skin! Afterwards, I looked like I had a terrible cold because my eyes were crusty and pink. Not the look I was going for, especially during the COVID-19 pandemic. This eyeliner IMHO would not look good on anyone with any skin tone.
Reviewed by 33 customers Its okay 3
Pam from Ny
It worked very well but then almost a month later and the end of it became very dull and didnt apply very well
Shimmer blue works great 4
TEG from MD
The blue is super pigmented, just what I wanted. The glitter tends to fall out, which is weird, but the liner itself stays put and comes off easy with makeup remover. The formula is a bit more on the liquid side of texture, but I didn't have trouble applying it. Wish it came in more color options, would love more super vibrant colors!
No 1
Ann from Maryland
The eyeliner is really streaky and almost none comes out when you try to use it.
Avoid this eyeliner 1
Cheryl S. from Downers Grove, IL
I wanted to use this as an eyeliner but found the product to be overly liquidy. In fact, when I opened the cap, my countertop was splashed by eyeliner liquid. I was initially excited about the rose color but after I cleaned up the excess liquid on the eyeliner, and applied what I thought was going to be a perfect wing, the eyeliner dripped down from my wing and INTO my eye. Painful. I bled out some of the eyeliner on a paper towel and prayed that I had eliminated enough of the liquid to try to apply it again. I was successful this time but I had to layer on about five layers (with dry time in between) in order for the excessively light pink color to even show up on my skin! Afterwards, I looked like I had a terrible cold because my eyes were crusty and pink. Not the look I was going for, especially during the COVID-19 pandemic. This eyeliner IMHO would not look good on anyone with any skin tone.
Disappointed 3
sam from Chicago
Not really pink, more of a rose gold. wanted pink
Pleasantly surprised 5
Carter from Seattle, WA
So, I really like these eyeliners, but they are a bit different than your typical liquid liners. They are not super pigmented, which for me is a plus, 1. because I don't have a steady hand when it comes to applying liquid liner, and 2. dramatic liner doesn't usually flatter me. The color is really easily buildable on itself to whatever level you desire. I agree with other reviews that it isn't a glitter liner per se, as the pictures would have you believe, but it does have subtle shimmer which is very pretty but not overdone. The applicator is a brush, which does make it difficult to apply any sort of a thin line, but I otherwise don't find it difficult to use, and it seems to flow just fine while applying.. So for me, who prefers more of a subtle look, these are great, but if you're looking for a more dramatic glitter liner, these aren't really going to achieve that.
Surprisingly good! 5
Trin from Evansville, IN
I was loyal to the NYX Epic Ink Liner, but wanted to try something else, because I have noticed as I age and get more wrinkles around my eyes, the NYX has a tendency to bleed. this eyeliner is extremely opaque, long lasting, and transfer proof! mine doesn't really have shimmer, which is okay, because I prefer matte black eyeliner anyway! It's lasted me a while and hasn't dried out yet, after several months of having it. the applicator is super easy to use too! I will be repurchasing!
Purple is good, silver don't bother 3
WS from Texas
The purple is good. A very rich royal purple. It goes on smooth and stays put.
The silver barely shows. I have to make a few passes for even the lightest color.
I Love these eyeliners, 5
Char from Seatac. WA.
Great eyeliners and affordable too. I have both the blacks, brown, purple and blue. They are amazing and I will keep repurchasing.
HATE the brush applicator 1
Steph17 from California
The colors are cool, but the brush is terrible, and SO much harder to apply the liner than a marker type would have been. Probably would have kept these if they would have had a felt-tip liner marker applicator - this brush is WAY too thick, awkward, and hard to use to get the thin, subtle line I was looking for.
dry 3
ali from la
my eyeliner came dry
It:s okay 3
kandee from GA
It is ok for an eyeliner. I found it hard to get product to come out. It doesn't flow very easily.
love it 5
Erin from ohio
I wasn't expecting this to be as good as it was! I bought four of them. the purple, the brown and the two blacks. the one black that is supposed to have shimmer doesn't really show up that's ok. I use black a lot anyways. all the colors though are deep and beautiful. I love the purple one so much. the tip btw is a brush not a felt tip in case you have a preference. I prefer brush so I was pleasantly surprised ☺️
love this eyeliner so much but.. 4
kate from ohio
i love this eyeliner so much the pink one is too close to my skin tone but the purple one is amazing. its my go to liner because its so easy to easy to use if you make a mistake you can wipe it off really quick and try again but once it dries it stays all day. ive fallen asleep in and woken up and it still looks as good as when i put it on. though if you itch your eyes alot or like cry laying down they dont last that long lol but i love it i plan on buying all the colors i love it so much the only down side is if you arent super careful when putting the lid on a the brush pushes apart and then the pushed apart bits just stick out and you cant smooth them back together which sucks but its still perfectly useable
Not a glitter eyeliner!! 5
Jamie from Joplin, MO
It always amazes me how many people have a warped perception of what a product is and what its supposed to do. This product is not a glitter liner, nor does it claim to be a glitter liner. Also if your product is defective then return it and get a replacement. Believe it or not those things do happen occasionally and sometimes the damage happens due to shipping. So instead of leaving a 1 star review for a one off accident do your due diligence and actually give the product a proper try. Also manage your expectations. Read the description. This eyeliner has a shimmery effect. All that being said the eyeliner is fantastic. The pigmentation is deep and this eyeliner does not budge (that's a good thing!). It's extremely cheap for such great quality and I would recommend it to any reasonable person.
Love This Eyeliner 5
MBKS from Upstate, SC
This eyeliner is a super buy! Works well, lasts all day. Less than half of major brands.
I would buy again and am planning to. 5
Penelope from Cortez, CO
Easy to line your eyes. Glides smoothly
Intense and easy to apply, with exceptions... 5
Yazzle Dazzle from Albany
Love this product in blue, goes on thick and heavy on top of a ton of eyeshadow, and I use it all over my face for other designs. HOWEVER, the pink color was not pigmented or bright enough. Super impactful in the darker colors.
Just buy it. 5
Ashlydolly from California
I'm a winged liner type of girl and I've tried out so many trying to find a new one after my favorite one mark painted black liquid eyeliner is no longer available. I would say this is one of the best felt tip liners I've tried, highly comparable to Kat von Ds tattoo liner pen. I always shake mine before applying, I fell asleep in the liner and I woke up with my wings still intact. There's no feathering either so you will definitely get a precise line.
SO mad 1
Liz from CT
I had high hopes for this product. I ordered the rose gold color thinking it would be a cute alternative to black eyeliner. Unfortunately mine must have had defective packaging or something because when I opened it, there was rose gold eyeliner leaking out EVERYWHERE. I still wanted to try the product so I applied it with an eyeliner brush. The formula/pigmentation was okay. Not worth the mess it made.
Not bad 3
Becky from Eau claire wi
I bought the purple one and it definitely delivers on color. My problem is the applicator, the tip was already splitting apart so made it hard but not impossible to do s thin line.
Compares to tattoo liner by katvond! 5
Lgies66 from Houston
I said compares but I honestly might like it better, plus it is more than half the cost!! It's mat black and truly amazing!
Some colors perform better than others 5
valentinalex from Cleveland, OH
I purchased this liner in every single color during the sale. I first purchased the dazzling brown, purple, and blue. They each perform beautifully, have a lot of pigment and glitter. I then purchased the other colors. The 3 weak colors are golden boy, platinum pop, and rose gold (though of those 3, rose gold performs slightly better than the silver or gold). The silver and gold colors don't perform AT ALL like the other colors. They are more like glittery washes of color, rather than the BAM bright glitter colorful effect of the other liners. My suggestion is to purchase black, brown, purple or blue--and leave silver, rose gold and gold for the birds.
Would buy again 5
Betty Best from Florida
Use every day love wearing eyeliner
Not worth it 1
Mind makeup from San Antonio
I bought two colors, the gold one and the silver/platinum one. I am not mad because they weee I expensive but I wish I had saved my money for something with more pigment. The silver one actually was very liquify and came off very clear with some shimmer. The gold one looks very sheer but almost bronze? I kept the gold one but it's not what I wanted. Save your money for something with more pigment if that's what you're looking for. Otherwise, it did last a work day for me. I was actually surprised it survived.
