Rated 4.16 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Purse Worthy!
I love Benefit brow products! I use 3-4 of them each time I do my brows.. If I'm feeling REALLY extra I will sketch out the brows w/Goof Proof #4 & fill w/PMB #3 then finish w/Browtones & 24hr Setter.. When I saw Ulta offered Goof Proof & PMB in mini form I was stoked! Both come in #3 only but its ok because you can use either a very light hand for light coverage, or heavier strokes/more strokes for deeper color. I will say that the mini PMB is more cool-toned than the mini Goof Proof. I keep both in my purse- along with a small spoolie in case I need a touch up- or need to do my brows in the car. Worth the $ & highly recommend!
Most Helpful Critical Review Made my eyebrows BREAKOUT
Yikes! I tried this without checking the ingredient list and that was a HUGE MISTAKE--within the first few days of using it I started getting painful zits IN MY EYEBROWS. I thought maybe I was reacting to something else in my skincare, but it was JUST my eyebrows, so I finally checked the ingredients list for this since I had just decided to give this a try since it had been on sale and found COCONUT OIL in it! Coconut oil is very comedogenic if it's not fractionated and thus not safe for use on the face for most people (it has a comedogenic rating of 4-5 out of 5, making it one of the most comedogenic oils out there, and not suitable for most people to use on their face). I stopped using it immediately and after a week my eyebrows started calming down again and the painful pimples started to go away. Be careful if you use this and keep an eye out for pimples that form around the area you use it and stop using it immediately if you find you start breaking out! I was SO disappointed to find this ingredient in the product when they easily could have used a different oil that has a lower comedogenic rating.
I also chose the darkest color for my black eyebrows and it oxidized a bit, making it a bit unflattering for me since my hair is cool toned!
Reviewed by 201 customers I love this brow pencil!
Alissa from Columbia, MO
I recently visited Ulta's Benefit brow bar and got my eyebrows tinted. I use this brow pencil to fill in the area of my eyebrow that happens to be missing some hair. I love this pencil because it is so easy to apply the color and it is long lasting! I also love that it matches my eyebows perfectly!
Do not recommend
Maria from New Jersey
It's too sharp and there is very little color, so you have to press really hard. It hurts to apply and pulls out your eye brows.
I would buy this product again. Easy to use, stays on.
None from Newark, Ohio
I use as eyebrow pencil. Great packaging.
Just what I needed for my thin brows!
GG from Waldorf, MD
Just what I needed for my thin brows! I fills them in perfectly!
Just what I was looking for!
Sherrie from Holland Michigan
When my hair turned silver gray (after chemo), I've tried to find a gray eyebrow pencil. This is the perfect pencil for drawing hairlike strokes to fill in where the brow came back sparse. It was just what I was looking for.
Ana from Nashville
Everything is perfect
Good pigment but BREAKS REALLY EASY!
Katie from Chico ca
Has good variety of shades, yet is no better then a drug store brow pencil.
Excellent staying power!
BluBrit from Ohio
I really liked this product. I tried the mini version to test it out. The staying power of this product is the best of any brow product I have tried. I applied it in the morning and it lasted all day. I chose shade 3.5 (neutral medium brown) and I found it to be a little warmer than I expected. The product was easy to use and blend.
Nic from Medina, Ohio
The definition is amazing. It wears all day without reapplying and it looks amazing!
Vix from Cape May NJ
This makes it much easier to do my eyebrows
SCCB from Lexington, SC
LOVE the new 2.5 shade. Matches perfectly! Easy to use, fills nicely. Doesn't leave brows looking overly filled or caked on. Lasts all day and through 12 hour shifts. Stays put and doesn't rub off in southern summer humidity
Emma from Los Angeles
I am a first time buyer of this product and I see what all the hype is about! Really really beautiful easy to use brow product that has now become my every day go to brow product. I still love my Anastasia Beverly Hills but this is a new front runner and often times I use it with other Bro products it's great to just grab and go!
Yasssss brows on fleek!
Bri from Philadelphia PA
Love this eyebrow pencil it makes your eyebrows look VERY nice. I would certainly recommend and it last all day.
Shouldn't be that hard to apply. Not for me
Birdie from San Diego, CA.
The pencil was very hard and did not glide on very well. It took a few trys just to get color on my hand with very hard strokes. When I tried to get it to apply to my brow with a little more force it snapped.
Not my favorite
Italian Blue from Youngstown, Ohio
The color was suggested by someone working at my local Ulta, however I found the color uncomplimentary for my coloring.
Yes I would
Joy from St. Louis
I like it, just not enough of it
I would buy again
Joy from St. Louis, Missouri
I use it to fill in my eyebrows, it's small enough to get all of the empty spaces. The brush helps to smooth it out
This is my go to pencil for brows.
Vix from Cape May
I can actually do my brows well with this pencil.
I had to return this product. There was no color.
Roz from AZ
As I said before, this product did not work for me.
I would not buy this product again
Gl from Fort Worth Tx
I took into the store the Little that was left of the previous gray IT eyebrow pencil I had which you no longer carry and was assured the one I bought was the same color...well it's much darker. I made the mistake of buying two because I don't get to the store very often. Now I'm stuck with two very dark gray eyebrow pencils.. Disappointing.
Will buy again
josie from CA
like the pencil is easy to use.
I would buy, but not often
Cynthia from Newark, NJ
Use this product sparingly. It goes fast; does not last
I love how this goes on. It looks like real brows.
Sooz from Rochester NY
I used it in small strokes the give the appearance of real hair. I always start at the end and work my way in to the middle.
LOVE IT! Makes my eyebrows so nicee.
Malina from Yelm, wa
Makes my eyebrows so much more smoother looking, very light and is super easy to blend.
Smooth brow strokes
Sunny Girl from Mobile
Being a novice at makeup, this product made it easier.