Product Reviews Rated 4.04 out of 5 stars
285 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Perfect Blend Cobalt Blue It's hard to understand why this color was discontinued. There are hundreds, if not thousands of blacks, browns, charcoals and combinations thereof available. Blue eyeliner is tricky at best, and can easily mess up an otherwise nicely made up face. The other blues on the market, whether pencil (you sharpen), retractable pencil, liquid etc., most of which I've tried, simply miss the mark! Either by the color being very harsh, shiny and/or totally unnatural. The claims of lasting all day and staying put are false. This pencil, which allows for a very fine point if wanted, is invaluable. It does not run or smudge, even if one tends to have oily eyelids. This all speaks to why CG perfect blend pencil is exceptional, even compared to much more expensive eyeliners. However, above all else, Cobalt Blue and the color it lays down sets it above all else on the market for anyone wanting a blue eyeliner that looks appropriate. A lot of women who use other colors of eyeliners would be well served to try cobalt, to accentuate their eyes without looking harsh and unnatural. Please bring this color back.
Most Helpful Critical Review not so good this eyeliner worked great until i had to sharpen it. when i tried to, it cracked right down the middle!!!
Reviewed by 285 customers Not The Same Eyeliner 1
Gina56 from Tn
I have used this same Eyeliner for years. I've noticed after my last 3 purchases, it does go on the same. It pulls my eyelids, and you can forget keeping coverage on the bottom. What have you all done? I thought it would soften up after a few try's but that is not happening. Go back to your original formula please. You cannot fool a consumer.
Smoky Taupe Very Dry 1
samiam2020 from Dallas, TX
I bought this pencil because I wanted a more natural look for some days and not a heavy kohl look. Unfortunately, I can't get any color to line my lashes. I tried to moisten it with a little water, didn't help. I tried sharpening it, didn't help either. Can't recommend.
reliable! Pulls your eyes! 1
Woog from Sedalia, Mo.
Way to dry, hard to put on. You have to keep going over it about 20 times for it to finally see the line. I've bought 2 of these, never again. Totally waste of money! It pulls your eyes to hard trying to get it on. I don't recomend.
This eyeliner is so easy to apply. 5
Patty57 from Wisconsin
I'm just so sad they no longer carry Cobalt Blue!!! WHY???
Smoky Taupe = Necessity! 5
Carla_N from Dallas TX
Taupe is a difficult shade to find in an eyeliner, and I'm not sure I could live without Smoky Taupe!
I'm brunette, NW15, green eyes, and Smoky Taupe is my go-to soft neutral liner for lower lids.Smoky Taupe is, true to its name, a soft light-medium greyish brown with the slightest hints of a yellow undertone in strong light - just enough to render it "neutral."
It works for my brows, too.
This liner is nicely pigmented, with only the tiniest suggestion of dryness, which isn't a problem on my very oily skin. Smoky Taupe goes on smoothly and wears well. It defines without looking harsh, which is ideal for those of us who are pale-skinned and over 50. I hope this is NEVER discontinued!
I really love this pencil 5
butterfly from Germantown, MD
I being use this pencil for more than 3 years and I love it
Smoky Taupe = Love 5
CarlaN from Dallas TX
I really like "Smoky Taupe." I think the color is best described as a light cool brown, but it's perfect for a subtle look. It could be creamier, but it applies smoothly and wears well on my oily skin. It's ideal for the bottom lash line.
Have a question 5
Lstarr86 from Pennsylvania
is this liner hypoallergenic? If not are any of your liners hypoallergenic?
PLEASE bring back MINK! 1
Kate726 from North Carolina
I have used mink for forever and nothing else compares. I have tried other brands and nothing resembles mink. Please bring it back. Even when it wasn't discontinued, it was hard to find on store shelves. It was obviously a color a lot of people wanted.
Eyeliner 4
Loranek9 from Sandwich, MA
I wish Covergirl would bring back the Perfect Blend Eyeliner color Mink....it was my favorite. There is nothing that compares.
👍🏽 5
😬 from La
👍🏽👏🏽
Where is the cobalt blue I love so much???? 4
nannnnnnnnn from Pennsylvania
Where is the cobalt blue I love so much???? I love this product. But not the color choices. I want my blue! I would give it a five if they had blue. But if the color palette suits you the product is very nice! It holds up well and yet washes off easily it's just the perfect combo.
Where's my favorite??? 5
CoachesX2 from Tennessee
I love the color "Mink" but I can not find it anywhere??? Why have you all quit making it???
Won't buy again. 1
Lee from Nashville, TN
Trying different eye liners hoping to find the right one and this is not it. Within a couple of hours is was smeared under my eyes and the color faded quick.
Where is my favorite Mink color 4
Micki777 from Akron, Ohio
I only gave 4 stars. I do love the product. However I have use the Mink eyeliner and it was my favorite till it was ripped off the shelves. I still haven't found another color or brand with a color close to it. So sad without my favorite Mink eyeliner from Cover Girl.
Stays On For A Long Time! 5
Ladybug25 from Orlando, FL
I've had thinning brows for years now. I'v been using Covergirl Perfect Blend Eye Pencil (in black/brown) and this product fills in my brows perfectly. It goes on very smoothly and stays in place for a long time! I would not use anything else on my brows and I'm very happy I found this wonderful Covergirl eyeliner.
Don't recommend 1
Momluvsmakeup from New Jersey
I don't apply my eyeliner on the bottom of my eye and at the end of the day with this eyeliner I look like a raccoon. The eyeliner completely disappeared from where it was applied but somehow ended up entirely all over under my eye. It was so embarrassing
They need to bring cobalt blue back to marker 5
cobalt blue lover from DC
I still use this product, cobalt blue but it is no longer available. I am not big fan of other colors. They need to bring cobalt blue back!!
Only one i buy 5
Xoxo chris from Fontana
I use if for eyeliner good quality
Cobalt Blue!!!! Please bring it back!! 5
SueD from Long Island, NY
Love this pencil but missing the cobalt blue color.
what happened to the blue shade????!!!! 5
oliviaaaa from MD
The blue shade was my whole family's favorite! Will it be back soon?
Mink 2
Jessica66 from undisclosed
WHERE IS MINK?! I have literally used it for 20 years.
Mink 1
auburnfire from Fort Wayne, IN
Why can't I find Mink any longer? I have used it for years! What compares if you discontinued?
What happened? 5
KimsEyes from Moncks Corner SC
I have used Basic black for 35 years, now... all of a sudden it will not go on my eyes. I wear it on inside of my eyes as well as outside. What happened!?!. i have bought 4 in the past 2 weeks, they just won't apply! PLEASE HELP! THIS IS THE ONLY EYELINER I USE, I NEED HELP!
You Dropped The Best Color 1
veryblue62 from New York, NY
I have tried all the colors that are still in the Perfect Blend group & the wrong shade was dropped.The smoky taupe barely shows up on my lid.
Mink was the best color - period:
That was the only CG product that I used & faithfully for years. So long!
