Product Reviews Rated 4.32 out of 5 stars
464 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Amazing. I have been wearing this eyeliner for the past 6 years. I have traveled to Suriname, Guyana, India and Nepal and everywhere I have gone, women have asked me what do I do to my eyes to make them look as they do. Fluidline has to be the best eyeliner I have ever used. I have recommended this to so many people, MAC should give me commission!
I have worn this eyeliner swimming and in the humid hot summers of India and it has managed to stay on nearly perfect. It does not run, it tends to melt a little around your tear duct but with immense sweating in India's environment, this eyeliner definitely outlasted the others. I have never been afraid to wear this eyeliner- I know it will last no matter what type of environment I am in.
The colors are also the type that you can wear without fear of looking overly intense or underdone. You cannot go wrong with fluidline. It may be pricey for a tiny jar, but I wear this eyeliner EVERYDAY and I wear a healthy amount and it manages to last me up to 5months. MAC is also wonderful and has their recycling program so I never feel bad going through it the way I do.
It is worth the investment. The brush, 266, has lasted the 6 years that I have had it and ultimately everything pays for it self with all the compliments I get!
Most Helpful Critical Review Great product... Until it dried! :( When I first used it... AMAZING. Perfect precision line for brows with my MAC 266 brush. HOWEVER, after some time the product dried and was incredibly flaky. I visited the MAC counter and was told to try mixing with an oil (olive oil, coconut oil, etc.) This method worked OK, but was too much of a hassle for me. It's really unfortunate because the product is PERFECT when the consistency is normal. When/IF you buy, make sure to keep a closed (tight!) lid. :)
Reviewed by 464 customers LOVE LOVE LOVE! 5
Ana from Los Angeles
Best true brown eyeliner I've ever used! Creamy, pigmented, and smudge proof. Perfect for everyday use!
Please keep Dip Down!!! 5
Staysee k from Tx
Please keep dip down! It's the prettiest, creamiest, waterproof,real brown on the market! Even better than the Stila liquid pencil. I have oily eyes and this is only product that stays all day.
My favorite for my brows 5
K_ashanti from New Jersey
I have used this product for years on my brows. I have very thin brows i use spiked brow pencil to give them shape fill the in with this and an angle brush then set in place with brow gel perfect every time I'm sad its sold out at the moment 😢
Love black track. So easy to apply and waterproof! 5
Babs from Hampton Bays, NY
I'll never switch eyeliners! I can apply a thin or thick line easy. Lasts until you wash it off. Waterproof for swimming. Love it and highly recommend!!
Solid cream liner 5
EAA from USA
This is a good cream liner. It goes on really smooth and is easy to use. I like the consistency a lot. The color blacktrack is a solid medium black shade. I would not consider it water or smear proof, but it may be because of the moisturizer that I wear. It is long lasting and generally stays put well if I don't touch it. I've used it with MAC eyeshadows and it works well. A little goes a long way so I expect it to last a long time.
Definitely would but this again 5
Kat from Michigan
This waterproof eyeliner works great. Doesn't smudge and is easy to apply. Great quality .
Good first impression 5
mintz from IL
Never used gel liners before and this was a good first product to try it out.
they reformulated and it's not the same 1
Sad Bride from Baltimore
shame that they turned this product into a versatile brow/eyeliner gel. it used to be darker than my soul and was disappointed using when I put it on on my WEDDING DAY because this used to me by go to liner, my truest and trusted friend. But no, they reformulated
Use this for my brows 5
Pascale _ B from Grand Terrace, CA
I have jet black hair and needed a cool toned brow product in a pot was recommended to try "low lights" I've been using it ever since. Dries down to a nice matte finish very easy to apply and you don't need a lot of product it also lasts all day long until I wash my face.
The best 5
Liz from USA
The best gel eyeliner I've ever used!
First MAC product I've purchased 2
Em from Oregon
I've always heard good things about MAC but I was not impressed with this at all. Will not be a repurchase. Kinda wish I could return it … if not it'll probably end up in the trash after a few months of me not using it… 🤷🏻♀️
The best 5
Tring from Stroudsburg Pa
I love this eyeliner yes you do have to work it in a little to get the darkness u want but I love it because I like doing a light coverage first so if I don't like how the wing comes out I can always change it and it didn't smudge all day !!!!!! Omg that is saying something because I have very teary eyes and my eyeliner always smudges and I hate that and I hate using liquid eye liner because it always gets in my eye and turns my whole eye black and the I sit there blind washing my eye out. This is just perfect will purchase again !!!!
Best of all gel liners out there 5
Mc from Ca
I've tried so many drugstore and high-end gel liners because I love the control around my sparse lashes. Mac and Bobbi Brown gel liners are on par with each other and no others can compare. The difference that I've found is that MAC pots stay fresh and soft much longer than Bobbi Brown pots. I noticed some people complain about poor coverage/spotty application but it always comes down to what brush you're using. You can use the best gel liner in the world with a trash brush and you'll always get bad results. So get yourself a quality brush and watch this product glide effortlessly.
Does not layer well 1
cc luxuri from San Francisco
I put it on my eye(clean base) and tried to fix a small spot maybe a minute after applying but it just crumbled off and made a mess.
Must have gotten a lemon 1
Ferg from Sonoma County
All gritty and won't go on smooth. Returning. I've used this product for years but purchased directly from MAC counter.
Doesn't last like it claims to 1
Jacqueline W from Chico, TX
Not worth the money when I can buy a product for a fraction of the price that is just as good. Wish I could get my money back
Could not get a clean line 1
E from Tempe, AZ
The product streaked and left holes in the line during application with an angled liner brush. Attempting to go over the line to fill it in actually removed more liner. I tried with and without eye primer to get a clean line, with zero success. After a full 30 minutes of trying, I gave up and took it back to the store. Would not recommend.
It's okay not the Best 3
Edith from Colorado
It has a long lasting wear but you have to apply it several of times in order to get it dark enough ! I probably won't buy it again just for that reason, other than that it's alright I guess ....
Black track eyeliner 5
TC from Boise Idaho
I have never tried eyeliner like this before. I really like this product, it's so easy to apply and smudge. Long wearing, highly pigmented, waterproof and very easy to apply. It will be my go to eyeliner for sure. Love you MAC!!!!❤️
I absolutely love this product it's flawless and easy to app 5
Tms from COMPTON, CA
I absolutely love this product it's flawless and easy to apply.
Flattering and Reliable 5
Jules from Iowa
I am a loyal MAC Lover! I fell in love with Blacktrack Eye Liner many moons ago. The pigment is true and the formula is easy to use, thick or thin. Ruby Woo lip and Blacktrack eyeliner are a match made in Old Hollywood heaven. #macgifted
Very Good Product! 5
Lilly M. from Falls Church, Virginia
I was gifted this product from MAC for being a Mac Lover in the Obessed Tier. I never tried this liner before. It applied pretty smoothly, stayed on and didn't run. I will definitely purchase this product in the future. If your thinking about purchasing it just do it, the end result is worth it!!!!
Silky Smooth 5
DeeDoll from Houston, Texas
This was my first time using this amazing eyeliner. It's really soft, satiny, long lasting & no clumps! My new favorite!!!
Finally a black geek that neither fades or runs 5
Ramah from Arlington, TX
This bold black gel liner/ brow gel was #MACGifted as a MAC Lover. I was excited TY try it out, and was pleasantly surprised at the bold pigment, longevity and precision of this product alongwitha117 brush. I tend to sweat in the face and get oily, so running eyeliner can be an issue... but not with this liner! No raccoon eyes for me!
Who doesn't want a solid black in their bag? 5
Jm from Fl
Brows? Check. Eyeliner? Check. Wing? Check. Another classic MAC product I can't say no to? Check.