Product Reviews Rated 4.26 out of 5 stars
115 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Portable and Easy to use I have been using a dept brand gel pot eyeliner but I hate having to clean out the brush after each use and pencil eyeliners need to be sharpened or the lids always seem to break off me.
One of the things that brought my attention to EL was that it had dual tips.Which I like. For best application I have to relax my eye so I get a straighter line but the color is great.Stays on all day and removes easily.The only thing I noticed is if I leave it standing up in my brush vase the color seems to run to the other end so I have to shake it to get it to flow again. Now I just lay it flat to avoid this but I love that I can just throw it in my purse when I'm in a hurry.
Most Helpful Critical Review Ok Eyeliner I have a problem with this eyeliner - the thin end doesn't work whenever I want to draw a precise line. And I have +10 years of experience using eyeliners. It looks like the fluid/ink doesn't come to the very end of the tip.
If I want to have a thicker line it works perfect. I'm disappointed with this eyeliner.
On the good side it doesn't smudge and it's easy to wash. I also like that it is mat.
Reviewed by 115 customers Little Black Liner 5
Dawn Marie from Memphis, TN
My first time using this particular Estee Lauder product; loved it. smudge proof. Defining. Stayed fresh all day. I will be continue to use this product.
liked the application and that's all 2
Chi from Las Vegas, NV
I started using a pen style liquid eyeliner 3 months ago. With the Black Friday sale I decided to get this a try for after my NARS run out. Well today I finally got to use it. First, this is very different than NARS. There are two tips vs one and these don't bend. They are stiff which made it super easy to apply, just dot on the line. I loved how easy it was to use and how the color just came out, no pulling or tugging. This afternoon (not even 5 hours after application) I looked in the mirror and discovered it had smudged all over my under-eye. I was not pleased. Blotted it with tissue as much as I could and went about my way. Two hours later I got home and noticed more on my under eye and finally took the make-up off. I am very disappointed how it smudged and didn't stay put. Guess I'll be buying NARS again as that never smudged on me.
Awesome 5
Gwiser from Venice fl
Love this eyeliner! Can use bold or slim for different looks and occasions. Stays on all day! Love love love!
Best Eyeliner I've Ever Used 5
CP125 from Buffalo Grove IL
I absolutely love this eyeliner. It goes on easily and doesn't bleed as the "crayon-types" tend to do. The fact that it has 2 ends, thicker and very thin, is really great. This allows me to get the look I want easily. The only areas that I have to refresh sometimes are the outer corners of my eyes. This usually occurs when my eyes may have watered a little.
In Love 5
Moll Doll from Fairlee, VT
I am absolutely in love with the eyeliner. Every eyeliner I've tried until now smudges under my eyebrows, especially when I sweat; This eyeliner from Estee Lauder is so waterproof, it stayed in tact in a rainstorm & it stayed in tact after crying and patting my eyes with a tissue.
This eyeliner goes on so easily and so fine, it makes me feel that much more beautiful when I wear it. I also bought Estee Lauder eyeshadow.
I will never use another eyeliner again!
Love this!! 5
Honey95 from Morganton
Love this. Works well for me and lasts a long time.
Wouldn't buy it again 2
BQ from Chico
Eyeliner comes off
Disappointed 3
JoA from Gloversville, NY
I have been using Estee Lauder exclusively for over 40 years. This is the first negative review I have written. I find that this eyeliner smudges and does not stay on for long. Very disappointing.
Disappointed-thin liner hardly works 2
Heather from Vero Beach
I am a fan of Clinique's Pretty Easy Fine Line Eye Pen so I was excited to try this pencil after loving the glittery black Estee Infinite Wear kohl eyeliner. Unfortunately, this Estee pen was disappointing! The thin side hardly works. The thick side works well, though, but I need the thin for the finishing touches. This seems like a quality product and wears well (all day) when I apply it to my upper lids. Unsure if I would recommend this product or purchase it again.
Not what I expected 1
Nikki from New Haven CT
It says waterproof but definitely not. I find it hard to put on and also it is smudgy. I will probably return.
favorite product 5
Alti from Brooklyn, NY
love this eyeliner its long lasting and so easy to apply
LITTLE BLACK LINER 5
Jessie from Miami, FL
I like this eyeliner a lot. It's very smooth and doesn't smudge throughout the day
Fabulous eyeliner 5
Llachef from Mill Valley Ca
Even though it's more than what I normally spend on an eyeliner, I love it. I just bought another one. Great line and waterproof.
Nice liner 5
KimD from Macomb, MI
This is the first time buying this product. I like it a lot! Stays in place, and the 2 different tips is a nice plus. I will purchase again.
Love this liner 5
Jupiterkaren from Jupiter FL
I needed a great liner this is it, thick or thin. Both sides work great! I'm not a steady hand and found this liner helps me to make a great line! The tips are firm not flimsy. Absolutely love.
New terrible formula and applicator 1
ARocky from Gilbert, AZ
Why the change?!! I had used Estee Lauder Double Wear Zero- Smudge Liquid Eyeliner for YEARS. It was a quality eyeliner that didn't smudge (even despite my oily skin) and lasted ALL day. This new pen-style applicator and apparent formula change are awful. It smudged all over and is not the same. I returned this and switched to Lancome Artliner which reminds me of the quality product Estee Lauder used to produce.
Disappointed 1
J,E from Springfield, MO
Initially looks good when I first put it on but it smudges bad right away and gets flakey later. This is the first Estee Lauder product I am not happy with.
never again 1
ejc from IL
to messy
Little Blk Liner 3
Candy from Houston Texas
It smears after a few hours not what I expected.
I am in love! 5
Enda from Maple Grove, MN
I tried so many eyeliners from cheaper to high end brands. I have hooded and sensitive eyes, when I found this eyeliner and put it on, I am impressed and love love this! It's so easy to apply, stay on and last longer. No more drama with my eyes. Beautiful packaging too.
Best Eyeliner on the Market! 5
Indigo from Tacoma, Washington
I have used countless eyeliner brands trying to find the best eyeliner. I will look no further! I like the choice of the thin or thicker line. Looks great & stays on the entire day! I love this product!!
Perfectly precise! 5
Christy from Spanish Fort, AL
This liner is a game changer. I struggle with wrinkly eyelids and this liner makes application a breeze and stays put! The dual ended tip gives you options depending on what look you want to achieve.
versitile eyeliner 5
skincare guru from muscatine, iowa
I was disappointed when the automatic duo eyeliner pencil was discontinued. the estee lauder consulant told me to try the little black liner, and I love it. It works in 3 ways.
I Love this Product! 5
Kim from Clay, WV
I love this eyeliner. It is so easy to apply, and it doesn't flake or come off until you remove it! I will definitely buy this product again!
Disappointed 1
KF from Los Angeles, CA
Was really hoping this product would compare to the discontinued Double Wear Zero Smudge liquid eyeliner, but the formula is sorely lacking in quality, especially for this price. This eyeliner smudges very easily and does not have a very smooth application. The black isn't as bold as the Double Wear, and requires a few applications to achieve a clean, matte look. Disappointed to say that I've tried drug store liquid eyeliners that have proven better quality.