Product Reviews Rated 4.58 out of 5 stars
241 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Beautiful shades!! I received the L.A. Girl Keep It Playful palette in "Playmate" along with this fluffy, blending brush in number 203. The first thing I noticed was that this palette looks slightly different in person than on the website which is something I had seen someone else discuss about the palette. Online it seems to be much more red than it is in real life which is much more blush toned. However on the website is does state that this palette is made of blush tones. I would just keep that in mind when purchasing! The case is very nicely made and seems to be pretty sturdy. The smooth, magnetic closure is something I really love and the packaging does not seem cheap. These shades are GORGEOUS! Definitely not as red toned as I had imagined, but they are going to be so pretty as we transition into fall time. The foils and metallics are my favorite. They are super pigmented and went on smoothly. The matte shades are bendable and the formula is really creamy and soft in the pan. They blend into other colors beautifully. This palette is a must have as cooler weather begins to set in and for under $10 I think I'll go back and get the other palettes in the collection.
Most Helpful Critical Review Mediocre. Wouldn't buy on my own I received this eyeshadow palette complimentary from bzzagent in exchange for my honest review. I am an eyeshadow fanatic with over 100 palettes ranging from drug store to high end and this one was not impressive at all. I use profusion which is an extremely cheap drugstore brand and they have a pretty good formula. This eyeshadow had an EMENSE amount of kickback in the pan as well as fall out ALL over my face. The colors didn't apply well at all. I had to try out several bases before I found one that it would stick to. Once I was able to get it to stay on with the base I was able to create a decent look but nothing to write home about. I wasn't very impressed at all. I've owned several LA girl products that I've loved, this isn't one of them
Reviewed by 241 customers Amazing shimmers 5
Kiraboo from Mineola, NY
I started with Downplay because I missed out on the Huda Smokey palette. The mattes are fine, but the shimmers are special. There are some great textures, and the black shimmer is unlike anything else I have. Recently added the Rosy one. Shimmers and mattes are all strong, but not as "special" as the first one. Really great palette for a good price.
My Comfort Palette 5
Lori Jo from Georgia
This my go-to palette. Nice neutrals for my blue eyes and light olive skintone, I have good quality mature skin. Good, blendable pigment that lasts all day when used with eyelid primer. Recommended!
Great palette 5
Kristen95 from West Islip, NY
For the shimmer/ metallic shades I normally go in with a setting spray or use my fingers
Great!!!! 5
Deja from Texas
I was looking for a new palette because I always use my Eternals palette so I decided to buy this one and it's EXTREMELY GOOD!!!! Beautiful shades and they are pigmented.
pretty good! 4
kait from omaha
these are pretty nice palettes for the price! the mattes are okay but i really bought it for the shimmers. the shimmers are beautiful if you use your finger or a damp brush. i only bought the one palette but i might add the other 2 to my collection as well!
Just buy it! (Keep It Playful) 5
Nivi from PA
Affordable and pigmented. This was a good buy.
Not good 2
Vic_Fulk from Indiana
Looks like there is a ton of really good reviews for these palettes but I didn't have good luck. The shimmers got hard panned immediately(and I always touch my eyeshadows with clean hands). The mattes are fine but not mind blowing. The only shade I liked was the pinky white topper shade. When I got the shimmers to work they looked chunky on my eyes. I'll stick to high end palettes.
My new favs! 5
MUA Wannabe! from STL, MO
I ordered two of the palettes: Playmate and Foreplay because Andrea Matillano recommended them on her channel; she was absolutely right. I love the color story, the size is perfect to go in your purse or trip; and above all the quality of the shadows are amazing, almost no fall out; pigmentation is there, and in just minutes you have the perfect look! Although I own some ND, UD and ABH, etc.; L.A. Girl have surprised me and now are my latest obsession.
Absolutely Amazing 5
Kan from Charlotte
This eyeshadow palette is A1!!!
Blendable and pigmented! This one eyeshadow palette will give you various eye looks that leave people swooning. Don't hesitate, buy it!!
New holy grail 5
dv from Arizona
I bought this in the shade playmate. The formula is great as it blends easily. The colors are pigmented. I'll buy more from this brand.
Great Vibrant colors 5
40 and Fabulous from Fremont
Product is very affordable with great colors that blend beautiful together. Palette has a glittery shine colors to stand out! I always get compliments definitely recommend
I would buy this again 5
Lyle from Florida
I love how smooth the eyeshadow is nothing wrong with it it's perfect
I will buy again! 4
Kammy from Grove City, Ohio
The colors are brilliant and rich like no other.
Misleading colors 1
Esty from Texas
The colors for playmate look nothing like the colors in the photo.
horrible! 3
Arabella from Florida
these palettes are so bad! glitter shades are so awful, they fall everywhere on the face and in the eyes. don't buy!
A good value 5
MJ from Florida
Very festive.
Loooove love! 5
Christyyy from Taylorsville
For the price, the pigment was REALLY good for me. I'm A neutral girl that was venturing out to try some shimmers and this palette was a HUGE hit! Will definitely purchase again!
misleading colors 3
yeet from CA
okay, first off the formula is amazing and I totally am so excited to use this HOWEVER the colors for playmate are so ridiculously misleading :/ the colors look redish in the photos and when I got the pallete it was so muted...kinda disappointed
picture is deceiving 3
Ang from Chesterfield
ordered the "playmate" one specifically for the 2 red colors in the center and they are no where near red. The middle one ended up being a light glitter pink and the other one ended up being a pink/brown nude color very disappointed as it was supposed to be a gift.
Amazing! 5
Buttercup from Texas
Absolutely blown away by these shadows. I bought all 3 palettes, and am very impressed.
Beautifully pigmented but... 3
Ros from CA
Although this is a beautiful palette for its size and price the glitters are a bit to large and fall on face. Its extemely pigmented when wet, however, it flakes off. Had to take off and use another palette.
Different eyeshadow 3
Kay from Tennessee
I received a different color pallet.
AWESOME PALLET 5
mamaof2 from Thousand Oaks, CA
I absolutely LOVE this eyeshadow pallet! The neutral colors are perfect for any occasion..from a night out with girlfriends or my husband, to a more natural daytime look for work. My husband was a rockstar for Halloween, and I even used the black eyeshadow in this pallet to do his eyeliner..it worked perfect! The eyeshadow is long-lasting, super pigmented and goes on so easily. I would highly recommend this eyeshadow pallet for anyone in the market for a neutral pallet.
Wonderfully Surprised 5
Tiffany from Carthage, MO
I was tickeled when first recieving this eyeshadow pallet. The color story is not only beautiful but also versatile.
The mix of mattes, shimmers, and foils was perfect. All the colors switched beautifully but also applied well with the eyeshadow brush that I had recieved.
These colors were so easy to make a lot of soft day looks. But to turn around and have the ability to make smoldering and bold evening looks really says something about this pallet.
The small and light size of this pallet made it perfect for to travel with. The colors a are great variety so there was no need to tote around other pallets.
The price point for this palette easy on your wallet and worth it for its quality.
Definitely a thumbs up!
Nice for a drugstore eyeshadow 4
SueBee from Alabama
This is a good rich eyeshadow pallet. The coverage is very good. The only thing I don't like is the glitter that lands on the cheeks.