L.A. Girl

 Hyper Cake Eye Liner

I had high hopes for this eyeliner which I purchased it in the black shade. It was a type of formula that I had never used, and as someone who spends a lot of time exploring makeup products in their free time, that was really saying something. That said, I was incredibly disappointed with how difficult this was to apply and how little control I had over the liner. I also was hoping that I could use this with ease to make wings, but it proved nearly impossible. For someone who seeks precision from an eyeliner, this is not worth your money.

easy to use and stays up in place. well pigmented. I hope they make more colors!

Gets cakey if layered, so have to be precise with first stroke. Good pigmentation though.

Color is thick but not heavy and doesnt move

Submitted 3 years ago

By Julianna

From San Diego

Verified Reviewer

Reviewed at

Picked this up on a whim because I've always wanted to try a "cake" eyeliner. I did NOT expect this to be my hands down IMMEDIATE FAVORITE eyeliner. I'm 50 years old and have been lining my eyes like the Goth that I am since age 15. This stuff is AMAZING. Wet, dip, whoosh… done. Wings in an instant, zero pull, zero tugging, smoooooth sailing over my wrinkles/sarcasm lines. Turn the brush sideways for thinner or thicker lines. Make sure the brush isn't *too wet* before applying— there's a happy medium— or it will run into your eyes. Use a little less water. Wet it, tap some water off, dip it. One swipe for super dense coverage. Set it with some powder and you're good for the night. I can't say enough good things about the pigmentation of these, either. I have both black (perfect pitch black!) and red (doesn't go pink!), and am back to buy the purple. And a couple extra black ones to have, just in case.