Product Reviews Rated 3.75 out of 5 stars
48 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Amazing This eyeliner is amazing! I've used so many eyeliners including a $20 pencil one from MAC and none of them are as amazing as this one.It lasts at least 6 hours without budging. The formula is very creamy and easy to apply. I would recommend putting a setting powder underneath your eye and then wiping it off before applying to the bottom lid. After applying I usually have to blink a few times since it makes my eyes water a little.My only complaint is that I accidentally broke the tip of it once and it was hard to sharpen after that.I highly recommend especially if your one to wear makeup all day.
Most Helpful Critical Review Seriously...? I went to go put this on and the whole tip broke off. I was super gentle (so gentle there was barely any color on my lid - see picture, totally not kidding) but my hand got a ton of pigment when I went to fish the broken tip out of my eyelashes BECAUSE it's so silky (yay?)
I'm glad I wasn't trying to lashine or do my waterline. Overall, not off to a great start and I can't image this thing is going to sharpen well.
If you're going to make a pencil THIS soft, make it a twist so it has some support. 😐 probably not even going to attempt to sharpen it at this point. Not stoked about the idea of trying this again. Plus it's chonky. No level of precision is possible between the size and sheer smooshiness of this thing. If it smudged nicely so you could blend it out, I'd get it, but it doesn't blend so much as... flake? Particle? Idk. Not a fan and not what I was hoping for.
But I'll give it one star for the color range and one for the overall feel. It does glide nicely and has a solid pigmentation to it... on my hand, anyway. It just also crumbles, apparantly.
Reviewed by 48 customers Broke 1
Disappointed from Morehead, KY
I used it a couple of times and when I went to roll more out, it didn't work. It's useless to me.
Bad eye reaction..eyes turned red and itchy 1
Megha from Texas
I have used lot of eye liners but this one was the worst .I got red eye and bad reaction to ky eyes.My eyes turned red and itchy.DO NOT BUY!!
Great Eyeliner! 5
Noel from Los Angeles
I've been using the Endless Silky Eye Pen in Black Noir for years. Its creamy gel formula makes it easy for me to line my waterline and upper lash line without irritation. Super pigmented, the color really pops. It also never dries out on me, so I get full use of the pencil. Great eyeliner with a great price!
this gave me an allergic reaction 1
aureli from renton, washington
title says it all. i don't have sensitive eyes idk what happened
NO NO NO 1
Melanie from Paso Robles, CA
do not buy this product. It is impossible to sharpen I will never use nor recommend this eyeliner.
Yes, it is soft, if the shards on it don't tare up your eye lid. Waste of money.
The best pencil liner! 5
Ms.K from San Antonio, TX
I literally tried all the major brands liners! some I paid high price for that I had high expectations disappointed me even more after multiple trial and error I stumble upon Pixi liners and they're the best!! I use it on my waterline and for tightlining and I don't buy expensive liners anymore!!
I literally own every color and can't live without this liner!!!
Love it 5
MissOpheliaRose from NC
I purchased Bronze Beam, and I love the color. It has a light shimmer. I have used only expensive brands, and this matches those and even beats them out! It goes on silky smooth and then sets for ALL DAY WEAR! I cannot say this for many high end brands I have used. This pencil sharpens very easily with my NARS sharpener, and you do not have to twist much before it is sharpened perfectly. This cuts down on pencil waste, and that is wonderful. I wear a lot of eyeliner, and have been doing so for many years. I know eyeliner, and this one is great! Well, at least this color is. Try it! The price is sooooooooo inexpensive.
another dud 3
ali from chico
I've been through endless amounts of eyeliners...almost none work without fading away. This dissapears in the first 30 minutes and is 1 of the worst I've tried. Save your money and invest in urban decay instead.
Burns and smears 1
Hol from FL
If you wear contacts this may not work for you. I wore it on the top lash line and lower waterline and it smeared all over my contacts which doesn't happen with other liners and causes my eyes to burn. I returned it. Sad because I picked up the bronze pearly color. I wish they would reformulated and make it more budgeproof.
Silky for sure! 4
Rizzles from Anywhere, USA
Applied smoothly on my crepey eyelids and didn't look as bad as liquid liner does on me. I had given up on pencils before bc of the crepiness of my lids, (too much skipping) and liquid liner pens were easier but still couldn't get an even line. I think this might do the trick. Smudge-able too but if you smudge too soon, the color wipes almost away. I got the Black Cocoa. Perfect deep dark brown, almost black but not quite. Love the color, appreciate the smoothness. I will probably be purchasing some other colors soon.
Didn't work for me 1
SueBee from Alexander AR
Used it to tight line top lash line, 2 hours later total dark circles under my eyes.
My favorite eyeliner by far! 5
Lindsey Trogdon from Billings, MT
I use this liner nearly every day. I get tons of compliments on my eyes when I do wear it! I had to order online as none of the stores near me carry this specific color.
Good for smudging 3
Morgan from PA
Three stars because the Brown is Good for smudging, long lasting even without a primer. But The black color runs blue so I don't like it for smudging. Transfers from tight lining. And the Nude color is actually too dark/orangey for my waterline but has good staying power. Hard to sharpen and they break easily when sharpened so knocking off 2 stars.
Seriously...? 2
Unhappy from NH
I went to go put this on and the whole tip broke off. I was super gentle (so gentle there was barely any color on my lid - see picture, totally not kidding) but my hand got a ton of pigment when I went to fish the broken tip out of my eyelashes BECAUSE it's so silky (yay?)
I'm glad I wasn't trying to lashine or do my waterline. Overall, not off to a great start and I can't image this thing is going to sharpen well.
If you're going to make a pencil THIS soft, make it a twist so it has some support. 😐 probably not even going to attempt to sharpen it at this point. Not stoked about the idea of trying this again. Plus it's chonky. No level of precision is possible between the size and sheer smooshiness of this thing. If it smudged nicely so you could blend it out, I'd get it, but it doesn't blend so much as... flake? Particle? Idk. Not a fan and not what I was hoping for.
But I'll give it one star for the color range and one for the overall feel. It does glide nicely and has a solid pigmentation to it... on my hand, anyway. It just also crumbles, apparantly.
Perfect Eye Pencil - Which You CAN Sharpen 5
Nlj from Springfield, MO
These Pixi pencils are the best eyeliners I have ever tried. High end pencils which cost twice as much are not any better (some are worse), but these are substantially better than your average $6-10 eyeliner pencils. You get enough time to smudge before the formula sets, and once it sets, it stays. Mostly I just wrote this review to correct the misconception that this pencil can't be sharpened. It's a plastic barrel, but this pencil and others like it can absolutely be sharpened with a standard makeup pencil sharpener. Best to freeze for a few minutes first, ad the product itself is so soft, but I don't always. I've thrown away similar pencils because I didn't realize they could be sharpened, and I hate to see a good product get 1-star reviews over this.
Love 5
Just me from Indiana
Glides over my wrinkled eyes beautifully! My favorite brand eyeliner!!
Definitely silky 3
KLA88 from Portland, OR
I rim the upper and lower waterlines of my eyes and add a line over the lashes on the lid. This product is definitely silky and smooth but almost too "melty" and soft. It lasted mostly through the say but definitely slid off the corners like most other eyeliners.
Absolute Favorite Eyeliner 5
Rachel from San Diego, CA
Definitely my absolute favorite eyeliner. I buy it over and over again because it is so great. It glides on smoothly and has such a wonderful pigment to it. I also like that if you don't buy the matte color it has beautiful little sparkles in it 😍
Cannot advance product 1
Alleyoop from TX
Waste of money. An expensive eye pencil you cannot advance.
Easy to Use 5
MariC from Bordentown, NJ
Pencil glides on easily and smoothly. Lovely intense color.
Good 5
Nina from Troy
Stays long
YOU CAN SHARPEN IT 5
Nelly from Wi
It's great and guess what? ITS NOT A WIND UP YOU SHARPEN IT!! yes!! With any eyeliner sharpener!! Wow what a concept imagine...
Best eyeliner 5
Robin from Virginia
The has got to be one of the best eyeliner i have ever used.
Smooth and easy pencil 4
Jax from San antonio, TX
I bought. It GLIDES on...and its super bendable. I liked so much, I went back for another color.
Dull sharping 3
Older user from Washington
My biggest review fault hard to sharpen, wastes the pencil and color