Product Reviews Rated 3.52 out of 5 stars
25 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Love it! I was a bit hesitant about getting this product because I usually like doing my brows with a brush and eyebrow pomade. I bought it just to try it out and I actually love it! It was easy to use and the brush at the end is soft.
Most Helpful Critical Review do not buy I have been searching for a good eye pencil every since Jordana went out of business. I asked the rep at Ulta for help and told her that I have been searching for a while - over 10 different pencils at home. This pencil is very faint and color doesn't match. Looked greyish brown. I wanted to return it after I eagerly opened it in my car outside the store - but because of COVID, I did not even try... more wasted money :(
Reviewed by 25 customers My Go To for Brows 5
Lyn V. from Chicago
This and the Wet N Wild ultimate brow are my go tos! I prefer this over the Anastasia brow definer.
KIND OF DRY 3
KATRINARAEE from LaLaLand
The eyeliners and lipliners are great in terms of application and longevity, but the brie bestie isn't smooth. It kind of drags and us dry, and if it is rolled up with an excess point it breaks off. It did break off I rolled it up a bit too much
Maybe I don't know how to use 1
T from Arkansas
I may not put a lot of makeup on but this pencil was so dry it didn't seem like it was working. If I could have returned I would have.
I would buy this product again 4
Erica from Chicago,IL
I used the brow pencil to share in my eyebrows where they are sparse
do not buy 1
tiff from Houston, TX
I have been searching for a good eye pencil every since Jordana went out of business. I asked the rep at Ulta for help and told her that I have been searching for a while - over 10 different pencils at home. This pencil is very faint and color doesn't match. Looked greyish brown. I wanted to return it after I eagerly opened it in my car outside the store - but because of COVID, I did not even try... more wasted money :(
Can't believe how much I like this product. 5
Becky from Florida
I've already said it all.
Don't buy it 1
Dash from New York
It broke as soon as I got home. Literally slid right out of its tube. Kind of chunky and doesn't allow for precision. Barely shows up. I got it in black and it looked a little ashy.
a bit dry but the look and color is perfect! 5
LC from Menifee, ca
I got it in the color bestie brunette and it matches my brows perfectly and they look natural. It is a bit on the dry side but it's still easy to apply. I outline with the slim brow pencil first then I shade in the rest with this one.
Does not go on smooth 1
T from Orlando, FL
Returned this as it doesn't go on smooth at all.
I wouldl not buy this again. 1
T from Orlando, FL
I am returning it. It's hard to apply; doesn't go on smooth; is quite a bit darker than the auburn eyebrow pencil I usually buy. I find Maybelline to be much better.
U get what u paid for 2
Amystar from Dallas, TX
I got mine deliver today and when I opened it a big piece came off so it was broken. I used to buy Anastasia but wanna give this a try. Like the color but definitely the quality wasn't the best
Inexpensive alternative to Benefit's Goof Proof pencil 4
PJ from Massachusetts
This is a great inexpensive alternative to Benefit's Goof Proof pencil. Same twist up mechanism and brush on the other end. Not as long lasting as Benefit's but great for weekdays and errands. When I need a more polished and long lasting look, I go back to my Benefit pencil.
Favorite drugstore eye pencil 5
Heather from Tampa
I've been stuck paying for high end brow pencils for years because it's hard to find drugstore alternatives that have the triangular shaped tip (rather than the really fine tip). My brows are kind of unruly and I'm able to make them look more polished and well groomed with the triangular tip (whereas a fine tip takes forever and doesn't work as well). This is just as good as Benefit or ABH for a FRACTION of the price and it lasts well too!
I like it but don't love it. I wish it add a gel side to hol 3
Dee from Southern Pines,NC
Like but don't love
Great brow pencil 5
Diva from Vacaville CA
Use to color in eye brows. Also as a liner.
I love, I would but it again 5
Alla from Calabasas, CA
It makes my brows look natural
ABH dupe!! 5
a from nc
I'm a longtime abh brow pencil user and i was looking for a cheaper alternative. I ordered a bunch of pencils online and this one was the closest dupe i found. I like it a lot and the price can't be beat
i really liked it, very crisp lines 4
bad wolfie from denver
nice vibrant color for an affordable price
One of the best eyebrow products 5
Tor from NJ
I've used this product just for casual wear and with full makeup and I have loved every second of wearing it. You can use it for a natural eyebrow look or for some snatched eyebrows. I love it so much!
You have to press hard to get pigment. It's great as a liner 3
Nola from Baton Rouge,LA
I would not purchase this again
Disappointed 1
Lyssa from Bryan
I had heard this pencil was great, but when I received mine, the product would not come up when you twisted it. Unfortunately, I was unable to actually try the product and received a faulty.
Buy it 5
EJ from Atlanta
Love this get it. You wont be disappointed
Love it! 5
Nita from Minnesota
I was a bit hesitant about getting this product because I usually like doing my brows with a brush and eyebrow pomade. I bought it just to try it out and I actually love it! It was easy to use and the brush at the end is soft.
Brow 4
Roberta from USA
Good product but getting the top off was way too much work
Very good 5
Johana from USA
The best product !!!
