Product Reviews Rated 3.91 out of 5 stars
385 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Big bang for the buck' This product is super easy to apply. It doesn't tug your eyelids so you don't have to try to Smooth them Out which can actually cause wrinkles an crowsfeet to occur prematurely For [$] it's been great! Does smudge a tiny bit but fades throughout the day I'd reapply if I were going to go out for the evening after wearing it all day. You can get semi thin lines but it's not an automatic pencil don't expect the same results. I love it an only when I can get ulta's automatic liners on sale for two dollars each, will I even use any other type of eyeliner. *hint* putting on primer makes the eyeliner last longer an stick better, honestly I'll even put my anti wrinkle cream dab it on my lids an use that after it dries to help my liner stick sometimes if I'm going out for the evening.Ohhh I also bought a white one, it's super white!! Which is great if You love that bold look but I like to use it as a primer for an eyeshadow. I line my upper lid then put a color eyeshadow like gold to basically great a strong hold eyeliner! It works an it's very cost efficient that way. You can basically choose any eyeliner color with the white eyeliner and an eyeshadow color of your choice
Most Helpful Critical Review average I was looking online and noticed these eye pencils. I planned to buy all colors, and i headed out to ulta. I was not disappointed,but not astounded either. For the price, it is good but i wouldnt be willing to re-purchase this.
The cool breeze and neon sweetie are nicely pigmented.Overall,this product is average. Essence makes cheap products, and the quality is so-so. If you can afford it, save up and buy some stila smudge pots or kajals. They work great.
Reviewed by 385 customers Go with the essence long-lasting eye pencil instead 3
sa from Erie, PA
It does not go on easy or very dark. Go with the essence long-lasting eye pencil instead
Disappointed 2
The eyes have it from Meridian Mississippi
I bought the white to use on my waterline and as a change for a regular liner. There is almost no pigment and it doesn't last very long. I've had dollar store white liners that have done better.
Great EyeLiner 4
Jade from Auburn, WA
I bought this liner with the intention of smudging for a smokey eye look & it was perfect. The formula allowed enough time to move it around to where & how I wanted it before setting down. Once set, it did not smudge or smear, which was great.
Disappointed 1
s from mi
Terrible formula :/ bought the white shade and it shows up grey on me. If you have watery eyes this isn't the eyeliner for you. Their long lasting eyeliner has a better formula and pigment.
Recommend! 5
Eee bee from Ohio
Came on time, super cheap and great quality
Good initial color, but fades quick 3
jackie from Chicago
I use this in teddy on my upper lash line. It's ok for blending out (it's a little creamier, so my finger worked better than a brush) but as a rigid liner, it faded quickly. I also had a little difficulty applying it to my waterline. Other than that, the color was very nice (it had a subtle shimmer to it) and the pencil was soft and applied smoothly.
Eh 2
Grace from America
I tried this to go on my water line but it doesn't really show up
Not what I thought 3
G from Usa
It's not as pigmented as I hoped, but it's under $2 so I'm not too upset. It goes on nice on the skin, but when it comes to my water line it doesn't really show up
Not the best but not the worst 3
Tiffany B from IN
While it goes on smoothly, it's almost to the point it's melting if that makes sense? As I was placing on my water line it was catching and clumping in my eyelashes. For the price it's not bad, but I would probably just spend the extra money and get something a little better
It does the trick at a great price point. 5
Jas from New York
I needed a little something to offset the shipping fee and this was at a great price. I used it once I got it and it's a great product. The product stays all day, definitely brightens my inner eye area and is easy to apply.
This product broke on the first use 1
Deeni from State college PA
This product was a disappointment, it broke on the first use and smudged
Love this product 5
Cami from Versailles, KY
Love the way it went on. Lasted all day
I love it! 5
Alexis from none of your buissness
This product is great I love the packaging and the price is what makes it even more worth it! It is relly pigmented and doesn't smudge unless if you purposely try to. It also doesn't fade away. Keep in mind that if you are ordering this in hot weather conditions it will start to melt just a tiny bit making it softer but that is not the company's or formula's fault.
Stayed In Place All Day 5
mew2youtoo from Arizona
Pretty standard eyeliner, but outstanding for the price. It stayed on all day and didn't smudge under my eye so that was a great plus!
Great love it 5
Kari from Indiana
Love this product love Ulta
:( 3
better luck next time from earth
did not like this. I was so exited to try it out and the price was great but the crayon just cracks breaks and clumps. not worth a buy
Yes I will buy this product again 5
Bet from Washington State
I have very thin Eyebrows , this Pencil has the perfect point , it's soft , so when drawing the brow line there's no pushing back and forth to get the perfect shape!! Love it
it's alright for the price 4
emilee from phoenix
it doesn't show up that well but if you go over it enough, it'll show up.
Good especially for the price 4
Ittybiteybatty from Buffalo
This is a good eyeliner, especially considering the price. It's super smooth and goes on really well, applies nice and dark and evenly, it glides on. I don't get the opinion that the pencil itself will last very long however, the tip wears down fast but with the price that's not a big issue. Lastability itself however is mixed. Sometimes it lasted a really long time and didn't need much freshening up and other times I was like where did it go? Definitely not waterproof or good if you're active or sweaty. My only real complaint is it had a tendency to get messy, bits of it would end up on my face or other parts and make a mess. I would find black flakes and they'd smear unfortunately. Still a good pencil, especially for the value.
too hard... I will stick with my nyx eyeliner 1
j j from frankfort ky
I like to line my waterline but i wont use this its too hard :(
No pigmentation 1
Michelle from California
I tried to use this for my water line and literally nothing applied. I went over it several times and barely got any color pay off.
So sad bc i really wanted to like this product/brand
My Favorite Eyeliner! 5
Kenna from Ohio
I saw this at Ulta for a cheap price and thought I would try it. I'd never tried a pencil eyeliner, only the liquid and stick. I am sooooo glad I bought it because it's amazing! I have a makeup sharpener already for lip liner pencils, so it wasn't a problem for me. I also have had trouble in the past cleaning off eyeliner, but it's very easy to wipe off with makeup remover. It stays throughout the day too! Great product!
Great deal for price 5
Hayden from North Carolina
Great eyeliner and also a great eyeliner choice for if you decide to color your brows an unnatural color which is what I use the white for in addition to just using as a regular eyeliner
I would buy it again 5
Dolphin102 from San Antonio
I would buy it again, I love the way it looks on my eyes and I want to buy other colors and it's easy to remove.
! 4
jo from tx
great for the prize
