Rated 3.33 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review 24 hours 100%
I got this in place of urban decay's nude waterline eyeliner & i have to say the nude makes your eyes pop when used on the lower waterline... i havent used it on my upper waterline because i usually do a cat eye but I am looking into getting the same product in black to test the top waterline for waterproof capabilities. This product goes on better than NYX white liner & does NOT budge. I have been wearing it constantly and it brightens my eyes so much. Super happy with this product. Will buy more colors.
Most Helpful Critical Review This product needs more R&D: won't sharpen
I bought this product a month ago and was very excited to see it last all day, didn't smudge, but I could use it with other products. Until the tip wore down. I know how to sharpen a pencil, which this essentially is. The plastic casing around the color is too brittle, I spent 20 minutes this morning cleaning up the casing that shattered all over my dressing room and on to my blouse. In the bathroom to clean up the mess I had to SCRUB my hands to get the liner color off my fingers, which then left my bathroom sink stained. Will anything be done about this? I get it, first world problems...but an element of this product is terrible. I believe that those that haven't complained may have not have tried to sharpen the product yet.
Reviewed by 896 customers Lasts all day with no smudges; Impossible to sharpen.
Sue from NYC
Lasts all day with no smudges; Impossible to sharpen.
May Eliz from Texas
This is an outstanding eyeliner. It is very pigmented and excellent for the top lid and cat-eye look. It also lasts all day without smearing. Many reviewers have complained that it is hard to sharpen. I have had no issues with sharpening this pencil. However, I do use a good quality sharpener for all my eye and lip pencils.
Good Color, Doesn't Stay Put
Amelia from NC
I have this in both aubergine and bronze. I love both shades. They are beautiful and compliment my eyes really well. The liner is soft and creamy, so it goes on with very little pressure. The issue I ran into is that it's too soft—the tip breaks off with even the lightest touch, which sometimes means I get a chunk of eyeliner in my eyes, which then gets smooshed if I blink before I can remove it, smearing all over my contact lenses. So it doesn't work well for tight-lining my eyes like I was hoping. Also, it's plenty waterproof if I swatch it on my hand, but it never seems to set fully on my face. It remains smudgeable for way too long and sometimes smears outside of my eye area if I touch my eyes or sweat. I do have oily skin, which no primer or powder has ever been able to fully tame, so maybe this is just a me problem. And maybe if I smudged it out intentionally instead of wanting a defined line, it would dry down better. But I don't want smudgy stuff all over my eyes, so I don't do that.
For all the people saying you can only use it for a few days and that it doesn't twist up...it isn't supposed to. You're supposed to sharpen it with a pencil sharpener. Now, because the product is so much softer than the casing, you'll have a heck of a time trying to get a good point without breaking it off in the sharpener (and if you succeed, that point will break off as soon as it touches your face), so it's still a pain, but to say it isn't sharpenable is just incorrect.
So in summary: I love the color, and I appreciate how creamy it is, but it's almost too creamy to the point of being unstable. But for the price, it's not bad.
Bwong from Marysville, OH
I got MAYBE 5 uses out of this product. The bottom seems like it should twist up with more product but no more would come out. Not sure if I got one that was defective or what but it was very disappointing because I liked what little product was there.
Brights the eyes
DinDin from DC
All the liners go inside my eyes and irritate them. This one is gentle to my eyes. I'm using the cosmetic sharpener from Nyx.
Hannah2021 from Genesee, MI
Says it's for the waterline. I'll give it a 2 star instead of one because it lasts about 5 minutes before rubbing off into my eye. Product after product I keep searching for the eyeliner that will stay on my waterline. Unfortunately, this is not it.
waste of money
Ateph from undisclosed
Like everyone else, you get 14 days of wear and then you cant sharpen it. Its done. Waste
no way to advance pencil tip
sassy gram from Chicago, Illinois
I would love this product except once the tip was down I couldn't advance the pencil at all. It is now just a stub.
Great color, but this pencil is hard to sharpen
Ecar from Texas
Love the color, but this pencil doe not sharpen easily. Wasted alot of color trying to sharpen. Will not buy this product again
Cannot be sharpened! This is a hoax product.
Jude2 from Massachusetts
This company is deliberately selling a product that can only last a week. They know you can't sharpen it. Read all the reviews. Loreal, you have a good name. Be honest and make a product that isn't deceptive.
RockiesFan from Florida
I loved what this product offers, but trying to sharpen is a fail. No instructions on how to sharpen. Also, the product does smudge. This is the second attempt I have made to use this product and I am done. Tired of wasting my money.
LOVE IT BUT......
marthajean from Chico, CA
LOVE THE COLOR. LOVE HOW IT GOES ON. LOVES HOW IT WEARS. BUT - PENCIL LASTS MAYBE 2 WEEKS. CANNOT SHARPEN IT - AND IT DOES NOT PUSH UP LIKE A MECHANICAL PENCIL. ONCE THE NUB IS WORN DOWN - YOU ARE DONE - PRODUCT IS GONE. SO SAD.
Stef from Wilmington, NC
I broke off the very first time i used it and i was careful with it-terrible product
WORST liner I have ever used! Deserves NEGATIVE stars!
Dancinqueen from Mpls, MN
I've used soft pencil eyeliners for 40+ years & this is the WORST I've ever used. There are NO positives about this inferior liner. I have used it about 4 times & because it's so soft, loses it's point immediately & has to be resharpened twice while using it! Due to this I ha used almost half the pencil already. I am throwing it out now & am so disgusted I will likely never buy ANY L'Oreal product of ANY type again!!
Don't Waste Your Money
Babs52 from undisclosed
At first I really liked this eyeliner. It was easy to apply, and the color is beautiful. However, when I tried to sharpen the pencil, my disappointment set in. The pencil is nearly impossible to sharpen. Don't waste your money.
I would buy this product again
Rosebud from El Paso, texas
The ease of application and quality is the reason I've purchased before and did so again on this occasion.
jendr from WV
The waterproof feature was why I made this purchase. By the end of an 8 hour work day I would have residue under my eyes from either the eyeliner and/or mascara I was wearing. Made the switch to waterproof eyeliner and mascara and this appears to have fixed that problem. Still working on applying this in one motion so it leaves a smooth, single line.
megggggg from Cedar Falls, IA
So beautiful!! This eyeliner is super pigmented and smudge-proof, which is exactly what I need as a competitive dancer.
Not my favorite eyeliner.
Starbright from Williamsburg, VA
This pencil said it was waterproof and pro last, which it doesn't live up to that advertisement. My eyes water up and the eyeliner comes off.
racheltaite from undisclosed
I don't typically use pencil eyeliners because I don't want to go through the sharpening hassle, but this is more of a creamy texture that is amazing! It goes on so pigmented (sometimes a little too pigmented, but you can just apply with a lighter hand!), and very opaque. I loved this for my upper eyelid, but would probably use a less pigmented eyeliner for my lower lid.
Lasts all day
tienforeverandalways from undisclosed
I wear black eyeliner in my waterline with almost every look so I was very excited to try this pro last eyeliner. And it lived up to it's name! I don't typically go to sleep in my makeup but last week I was exhausted and only had mascara and eyeliner. I was shocked to wake up and see that my waterline eyeliner was still there and holding strong. Definitely recommend and will definitely be an item I keep in stock!
Great until it needs to be sharpenned.
rachaelg5 from undisclosed
I bought this product a month ago and was very excited to see it last all day, didn't smudge, but I could use it with other products. Until the tip wore down. I know how to sharpen a pencil, which this essentially is. The plastic casing around the color is too brittle, I spent 20 minutes this morning cleaning up the casing that shattered all over my dressing room and on to my blouse. In the bathroom to clean up the mess I had to SCRUB my hands to get the liner color off my fingers, which then left my bathroom sink stained. Product was great until needing to be sharpened where it went down hill fast.
love this eyeliner!
nicolemdeluca from undisclosed
Very pigmented and easy to use. I love the consistency of it. Not rough on the eye like some other brands are. Very long lasting
I really enjoyed this
nicolac28 from undisclosed
I really enjoyed this eyeliner. It was extremely easy to use and was very smooth. It did not tug on my eye at all and was very pigmented
allieh28 from undisclosed
I was super excited for this product. The fact that it is waterproof is amazing. This product did not smudge, but when I was applying one day, the whole top of the product got smushed and ruined the product. I no long use this and don't think I will be buying again.