Rated 4.55 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review All the things I look for in a liner.
The Infallible Flash Cat Eye Waterproof Brush Tip Liquid Eyeliner is a really good quality, drug store eyeliner that makes applying liquid liner much easier. I have used many drug store eyeliners in the past and this has got to be one of my top favorite liners to date. Not so much for the gimmicky stencil, but because the formula of this liner is just really good.
This eyeliner comes equipped with a removable stencil that is supposed to make applying liner much easier for the makeup challenged user. The stencil is made from a really thin plastic, which bends very easily, so be extremely gentle with it. You simply place the stencil to the eye, at your preferred angle and fill in with the eyeliner pen. Then you lift and remove the stencil, et viola! a perfect cat eye! I found that it took me a few tries to get down the mechanics of the stencil, so the first few tries were a hot mess. I eventually got it down and it really was easy to use. I, personally, have no issues with doing cat eye liner free handed so I found the stencil to be useless. I can see the appeal in it for users who don't have a steady hand or just have issues with doing their eyeliner.... it definitely would make it easier for these types of users. It just wasn't for me.
The formula of this liner is amazing! The brush tip makes applying a breeze. The liquid is very pigmented, which I LOVE a BLACK black liner. One swipe is all you need! The formula is waterproof, but not overly so that I find myself having to scrub my eyes to get it off. In fact, quite the opposite. It's the easiest eyeliner to clean up. If i've made a mistake, I simply let it sit for a few seconds then wipe and it comes right off without any hassle. Once set, there's no smudging, running, smearing, or bleeding of any kind.
Overall this product has all the great qualities I look for in a liner without any of the drawbacks I find in many. This is one of, if not THE best, drugstore eyeliners I've found to date.
Most Helpful Critical Review I despise this eyeliner.
I have used loreals "infallible super slim" black eyeliner pen for years but when Ulta was out of it I figured I'd try this just to give it a shot.
Let me tell you how awful this liner is. It's got a pneumonic shaker in it (so it is pressurized to push out the liner, sounds great in theory) and it absolutely sucks. It delivers liner unevenly.
On top of that, this is tattoo grade. It is EXREMELY DIFFICULT to remove. At the end of the day a makeup removing wipe, Clinique makeup cream, and Vaseline still left residue of this worlds worst eyeliner. I am saying that using all of those methods still left me with chunks of makeup. On the plus side, if I was out on Friday and didn't take my makeup off, the next day my eyeliner was still there.
But here's where I'm extremely irritated. After using this permanent marker of a pen for about a month, the shaker device suddenly failed while I was applying my eyeliner. Ink flooded from the pen into my eye, and because it takes so long to remove from skin, I was an hour late to work. Luckily I was wearing contacts, so my contact took the brunt of the ink flow but this is absolutely unacceptable.
Do not buy this!!
Reviewed by 1325 customers Not impressed
chriskeene from AZ
Eyeliner did not last very long. Broke apart after awhile. Really disappointed.
Cher from New York
I ordered 2. One was really dry and drew a faint line which rubbed off quickly. The other was slightly less dry but did not stay on more than a few hours . This was an attempt to try less expensive liquid eyeliners.
lav from San Antonio
I always have a hard time finding a gel eyeline that I like and is effortless to put ontop of eyeshadow. Bold black color!
Good product for price
Bri from Maricopa Arizona
Stays all day with no smudging. Easy to apply.
Not good for hooded eyes
Cris from Fort Worth texas
Not good for hooded eyes, came off in 5 minutes. The product tip is easy to work with and comes with a tool for precision but not good formula
Leaks so BAD after 3 months
Lala from Wisconsin
I've been loving to use this liquid liner since the color payoff is nice and not a lot of shine on it. But after 3 months it leaks so bad that every time i open it all of the ink go into my hands! So annoying! Take note, i only use this when i do my makeup NOT everyday. So you'll be the judge!
Never stays on long
Honey aromdee from Raeford road
Don't like this products doesn't last long it is not worth the money.i bought the brown.exactly 3 months ago bought j cat liquid eyeliner 4 of them that didn't last long either.waste of money I will be trying Milani liquid eyeliner hopefully that will last better
Liquid cat eye
KelseyyyMariiie from Southeastern, Kentucky
I am not a fan of liquid eyeliner by no means but I assume where the lid has the 'cheater guide' as I call it, I am now a fan!
Changed my mind on the brown one
Veronica from Illinois
So I got the brown one bc I prefer brown liner. At first the payoff was little to none but once I put the product to sit the pen side down so the ink can pour down, the pay off has been amazing. Very easy to make a wing for hooded eyes.
Samantha from CA
I have tried a ton of eyeliners and this is the best formula out there. It stays on but comes off easily with makeup recover. The pen itself is easy to use and the lines are smooth, black, and matte. The only issue I've had is the packaging can sometimes get occassional bubbles towards the end of the lifespan of the pen. Otherwise, it hasn't leaked into my purse, and it's perfect !
Cas from Arkansas
Great for someone just starting out like me. Also, i have a disability that makes my hands shake badly so i couldnt really use other liners i have tried. This liner is soft and just glides on so effortlessly.
Michelle from MS
Quickest and easiest wings I've ever done!
Works great at start, and then leaks A LOT
Katie from Gales Ferry, Connecticut
I wanted to love this eyeliner so bad, and at first I did for the first few weeks. I've gotten these more than once, and every time I've used it, it leaks and makes winged eyeliner, your face, and your hands all messy. Gross, and wont rebuy ever again.
Chels from Glendale
I could not do winged eyeliner before I tried this liner. the stencil is perfect, and the brush is soft and easy to use.
Just the best
Sam from CA
I've tried a ton of eyeliners and this one is perfect. Matte black, doesn't bleed or flake or smudge. It isn't waterproof but otherwise it's perfect!
Best thing EVER!
Babygirlcas from San Diego
I've always wanted to do a cat eye but failed every time! I came across this product and figured why not... now I'm hook! This is the best and easiest way to achieve a perfect cat eye in 30 seconds!
Best eyeliner I have ever used
Sarah from Evansville, IN
I have been wearing eyeliner for the last decade and have tried SO many different eyeliner products (drugstore and prestige). I LOVE this. It is easy to put on. I love the fine tip pen and the actual formula. It also doesn't flake off throughout the day. Its not perfect 12 hours after application. But it is pretty darn good. 10/10 recommend!
I haven't tried to do a cat eye with this. I just use it for my every day over eyeliner.
Great For The Money
TMD2 from Hawaii
Eyeliner is easy to apply and stays on throughout the day. It's not perfect but for the price it's great!
Cpax1990 from Hanover pa
I wish I would have known that this was going to leak huge drops of eyeliner everywhere ruin my eye look and get all over my vanity seat it worked fine the first few times and then it became a huge mess I would never buy this product again I would rather pay the prestige price for a product that won't leak all over!
Great liquid pen liner at a great price.
Dayna from Monterey, DA
Lines precisely, dark liner, doesn't skip, thin line linrer.
Where have you been all my life 😂
Marissela from Texas
Great eye liner !!
Andrea from Phoenix, az
Great eye liner goes on so easily.
Overall good - just dries out after using it for a lil while
Korina from Arizona
This eyeliner is really good, definitely don't feel like anything is on your eyelid like most matte eyeliners do. But i have noticed that after you use it for a couple minutes (like really quick), it dries out and isn't that smooth or dark anymore, there's hardly any product. And it takes like 10-20 minutes to be useable again. Only downside
Dries out after the first use...... horeible
Lorijw53 from Chicago, Illinois
So disappointed with this. I wanted to love it but it became dry and difficult to work with after the first use.
T from Chicago, IL
I bought this after my Nyx epic liner kept leaking everywhere. I love it! It lasts all day! I like the tip and feel like it give a nice crisp line. For the price 10/10 would recommend! The little liner piece is cool, but idk how much it helps me. I find it easier to just do it on my own. I'm sure it would be helpful to someone new to makeup.