Rated 4.24 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Beware: When they say Huge, they mean HUGE
I use this product everyday to make my lashes the first thing that people notice when they see me- whether its at the office or a night out. For someone who recently stopped doing the liquid eyeliner wing (for about 4 years I did this everyday), this really has made a difference in my look- brightening up my eyes, and making my lashes pop! I am not someone who typically spends a lot of money or splurges when it comes to make up products- I am a very reasonable shopper- but I would definitely keep purchasing this product. The price isn't very bad considering it has lasted me over 2 months- when I'm usually buying mascara every 2 weeks. I highly recommend this product to anyone! Depending on how many coats you do (I usually put on 5-10, spending about 5 minutes on my lashes), you can really make people think your lashes are fake because of the exceptional length and volume that comes with this mascara. I have had people ask me if I was wearing fake lashes because of this amazing product. And the brush helps in curling them the same time as application, so throw away your lash curler! I recommend this product to anyone who wants to make a statement with their eyes and lashes!
Most Helpful Critical Review AWFUL!
This is the worst mascara I've ever used! I got it to try as a free sample and I was excited to use it. What a disappointment! There is way too much product on the wand/brush and it is really difficult to avoid clumps. i wore it for 8 hours and there was absolutely none left on my lashes. It had all flaked onto my under eye area and I looked like a flaky raccoon. I used it twice and it's going in the trash.
Reviewed by 989 customers The best!
Ash Christine from Davenport, IA
This is my favorite mascara! I have tried many others, and I always go back to this one. It is a little wet, so I just have to be careful right after I apply it until it dries. It makes my lashes long and thick!
I'm addicted to mascara
Suzie from Boise
I haven't used high-end mascara in a while since I haven't been able to afford it (which may skew my experience of the product), but I saw this was on sale one day and I had to try it out. It's volumizing, it's not clumpy, and it has great pigment, though I don't think it does much in terms of lengthening. The packaging is nice and it smells more clean than chemical-y, like some mascaras do. I'd definitely purchase again.
Mascara from Birmingham, AL
Came out of the tube with clumps on the brush. Very messy
MBa from Prescott Valley AZ
Mascara smudges within hours and no significant lash appearance. I wouldn't recommend it or buy it again.
Clumps, Flakes and Racoon Eyes- Avoid!
Kristen from Connecticut
I was excited to try this mascara and was totally disappointed after use. It makes your eyelashes clump together and leaves racoon eyes almost immediately. There is so much product on the wand when you pull it out of the bottle that it is difficult to even apply a minimum amount. AVOID.
The best mascara I have EVER used!
Nora from Wisconsin
The longest lashes with any mascara I have ever used before.
Clumps for days
denise from NYC
This is probably the worst mascara I have ever used. I received a sample and it was so thick and clumpy you could hardly see the brush, bc so much of the product would stick to the bristles as it came out of the tube. Applies so unevenly I had to take a dried tube of mascara and use that brush to distribute it evenly. Does nothing to lengthen lashes. Clumps and feels like it never dried out. Not at all worth it to me, will not be purchasing a full size
Looked perfect even after getting dumped and crying
Can endure anything from Brentwood California
I recently bought this mascara because I felt the two face better than sex was just not looking the same to me as it usually did and I had been using it for years. The first time I used this mascara I wore it and tested it out I was very impressed at how long and voluminous my lashes were with out even curling them. That same day my boyfriend of two and a half years came over to my house and unexpectedly broke up with me and completely blindsided me. During our almost hour long conversation I cried pretty much the whole time and the whole rest of the day. Later that night as I was taking my makeup off I noticed that my lashes were still intact and that all my crying did not effect the quality of the mascara. If the mascara can endure all that it was put through that day it can really endure anything! This is my new favorite product that I will definitely be buying again!! I love it and it never lets me down
Weighted my eyelashes down
Mommy from IL
I really wanted to like it. I saw great reviews but I did not like it, it did not work for me. Once I place it on my lashes they felt wet and they drop even after a while.
Huge is Right
Nycbeautyqueen from NYC
This is an honest review no free product here. I'm a certified mascara junkie. I've tried at least 50 different brands over the past few years. There are very few that I would buy again as there are always new ones to try. I would buy this again. It's buildable and easy to come off. I have semi long lashes but need volume this gives me both. I look like I have fake lashes on.
Brush wand bent & mascara is half dried out!
Cjohnson082 from North Carolina
I have used this mascara in the past and liked it enough to order it again but this one is all messed up! When I got it I took it out of the box and put the tube in my make-up bag - i didn't open the tube of mascara!
I am working from home so I've not been using make-up much. I received the mascara about 10 days ago. Anyway, I just went to use it this past weekend and when I opened the tube the brush wand was bent (it supposed to be straight) and the mascara on the brush was half dried out and brush was shaped weird. I didn't use it! I don't have the box the mascara came packaged in so I do not know if I can return it. Attaching a picture of how it should look and some of how mine looks! Very disappointed!
Good for everyday
JinALX from Alexandria, VA
I have naturally medium thick lashes & sensitive eyes. I've had this for a week and I'd consider it a good everyday mascara. It's somewhat buildable, doesn't clump much, holds a curl well, and doesn't flake. It's a nice mascara but nothing about it wows me.
BETTER than Better than Sex
Chelsea from Denver, CO
I was a Better Than Sex mascara loyalist for years but I found that it wasn't quite getting my eyes t h e r e. I tried Tarte, which is nice and clean, but I craved the big, fluffy, black as night eyelashes. I switched to Stila on a whim and I haven't gone back. My eyelashes look like falsies and I feel that they don't advertise this mascara enough. This mascara is sexy, pitch black, and not too clumpy (however, all volume mascaras have some clump). A bottle of this usually lasts me about 2 months of everyday use before going dry. It never runs, and will stay on through an hour long CrossFit workout. I actually had to buy a new makeup remover to get it off because the pigment is off the charts, but it's absolutely worth it. If you're tired of the same old volume mascaras, give this one a try :)
I would NOT buy again
Lee from Alabama
Flakes all day and dries out
One of the best mascara's I have ever used.
Mom of Preemies from Chicagoland, IL
This is my "go-to" mascara. My lashes are longer, fuller and look real. You won't get that fake, crusty spider lash look with this. I gave it to my step daughter one Christmas and she is a convert.
Mascara on repeat!
Dermgirl from Ohio
I have used this since it came out. I always try the latest and greatest of the new mascaras and ALWAYS end up coming back to this one. It is the absolute BEST!
I will be buying this as long as they make it
T Town from Topeka, KS
Just love this mascara!
Hands down the best mascara ever
Rae from Tucson Az
I have used many low to high-end mascaras and this one is the best. My lashes usually suck I've used heated lash curlers, regular lash curlers and heated the regular lash curlers and my lashes go back straight with the weight of mascara. This is the only one I have ever used that I don't need a lash curler. It stays on all day. Stays on through my sweaty work days. I don't use waterproof and it works fantastic. My lashes stay up. The consistency is perfect not wet and not dry and clumpy. It last a long time! I don't have to do 10 coats to see a difference. It comes off easily. I'm not sitting for 5 minutes just trying to get it all off my eyes. I love this mascara and have been buying it for about 3 years now. I have tried others in between and always go back to this one. I'm usually not too hyped about the price but this one is worth every cent.
Sofia from Houston
I love this mascara. It's even nicer when the tube gets a little older and dries out some. It's very buildable and doesn't weigh down your lashes. Yeah the brush is a little hard to navigate but I've had more defined brushes like buxom and telescopic and this one still performs better
only mascara I use.
Mia from LA
I use it everyday and it doesn't flake or anything like that.
Always get asked what mascara I'm wearing
Dani from NY
I never have written a review, but I had to come on and give this product some love! I bought this once on a whim because it was on sale and I've been in love ever since! If you have def wear a primer under this, but if not thats fine too! IT LOOKS LIKE YOU HAVE FAKE LASHES ON, I love the look! I also love telescopic mascara so to lengthen and separate the lashes at the end I top it off with that mascara. IN LOVEE WITH THE WAY IT MAKES MY LASHES LOOK HUGE, advertising is not wrong on this one.
Best mascara for full, thick lashes!
Jill from CO
I have very fine, slightly short lashes, and this mascara makes them look super full and thick! It gives me just the right amount of length without looking spidery.
Love, Love, LOVE!!!
Sxyeyes from WAshington
I think of myself as a mascara snob... This has been my favorite mascara for the past couple years. This adds so much volume and length to my already long lashes. People are always complimenting my lashes. They usually assume I have on false lashes, I have to show them up close... these are the real thing!! Thanks Stila Huge!
Libby from Oregon
This is my favorite mascara. I've tried all kinds in the past and this one takes the cake. It makes my lashes huge! Personally, this mascara makes it so I don't even feel the need to try fake lashes. This is also the only mascara I've purchased multiple times because I don't want to try anything else.
My go to date night mascara
mlt from Maryland
This mascara clumps a little easier than some, so you have to be careful in your application, but it creates the thickest, fullest lashes of anything I've tried