Rated 4.35 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Nyx Eyeliner
This eyeliner is smooth gliding and very deep in color. my only complaint is that it's not very forgiving so if you mess up as I am prone to do it is tough to remove fully.
Most Helpful Critical Review Worst at Sharpening
I like the pencil and the color. It is a little difficult to put on. Sharpening is the absolute worst. If I didn't want a point, then I would be good to go. If I do want a point, I will probably run out of pencil first. It's absolutely horrible. Definitely not worth it. I even wet the tip before sharpening as has been suggested.
Reviewed by 440 customers Beautiful
Chris from Las Vegas
psychodelic101 from Dandridge, TN
I'm all about eyeliners and bold, rich pigmented colors. I bought this on a whim & I'm totally in love with it. It not only has rich, bold color but it glides on effortlessly and lasts all day without smearing or fading. I now want all the colors! Will definitely get more.
I love this product. I will definitely buy again
Gingival cat lover from Goshen, Indiana
I wear it as eye shadow as well and like a eye pencil as well
Super long lasting
K from California
These liners are amazing. I've always had issues with eyeshadows and eyeliner staying on my oily lids but these have been a game changer. As soon as they set they're set! Better than urban decay 24/7 liners in my opinion.
Cassidy from Panama City, Fl
Glides on nice and smooth!
Looks and stays great, sharpens badly
Gail G from Oradell NJ
Too soft to sharpen. If you can even get a fine point it breaks. This won't last long at all
Nice. Good price.
ISpendTooMuchonVanity from Philadelphia, Pa
Use under eyes to brighten. I saw a tik tok that sad if you are over 30 you shouldn't use white.
Definitely will be buying in other colors
Willie from Redlands, California
Water proof for sure. Doesn't require touching up all day. Doesn't smudge.
Dipper from Kentucky
Have not been wearing lipstick be cause of COVID
Sadie from Peoria,IL
I use this eyeliner daily. It lasts through my whole work shift which can be an 8 hour waitressing shift. I was using Urban Decay eyeliner until I discovered this for more than half the price. I highly recommend this eyeliner. I use the pitch black and I'm very pleased with how dark it is.
patty from michigan
As a contact wearer, Ive finally found an eyeliner that I can wear on my waterline!! It doesnt smudge or transfer onto my contact lenses!
I think I'm going to like this product
Pam from NC
Glides on easily!
Allergic to this pencil
josie from St. Cloud, mn
Stays on but hurts my skin
If you need a reliable pencil liner, go for this one
Lou from MN
I got this liner, just needed a quick one for a costume I was planning on doing. Didn't read reviews, it was just the first one I saw, i knew nyx was a reliable, fairly cheap brand, so I picked it up. I'm so unbelievably glad I chose this liner. it is by far the BEST pencil liner I've ever used. It glides on the skin so perfectly, dries down quickly and once it dries, it stays. I literally put it on my hand and rubbed it super roughly under water and it wouldn't budge. This is absolutely AMAZING.
New Go To Tight Line Pencil
Myknee from Sacramento
I Needed A New Affordable Pencil To Tight Line My Eyes With And Was Intrigued By This One From Nyx. I Love It! It Glides On The Eyes So Smoothly And Stays On All Day. I Always Struggle To Find Something That Doesn't Transfer Onto My Outer Undereyes And This Holds Up Amazing.
Great colors, AWFUL SHARPENING. Come on, NYX!
Redhead from Georgia
I got orange, pink, and blue. The colors are beautiful and smudge proof. HOWEVER: how are we supposed to sharpen these things? A regular sharpener doesn't cut it - the case is plastic. COME ON, NYX! Either make it easier to sharpen (wooden pencils aren't THAT tough to make!) or give us a sharpener that works. I have the same problem with the Side On liners.
My new go to
Pamela from San Antonio
Love this pencil liner. It is my new go to for tight lining. Lasts all day and woks great with liquid to create a thick lash look. Bought on black and brown. Takes some effort to remove but that is probably my remover since it is not for waterproof
Good color, doesn't budge
SharonS from Tulsa, OK
Excellent liner! Doesn't budge for anything on the eyes. When I tested it on my hand, even washing dishes didn't fade it. When it came time to remove for the night, it came off without scrubbing using an oil-free eye makeup remover (micellar or cleansing wipes do not do it). The color is as advertised, and the shade I got is just the right amount of metallic shine. I think this is my favorite colored liner! I'm definitely getting more colors!
These are really good!
TXmom from Amarillo, Texas
This pencil is better than many high-end ones in my opinion. It stays on and I am planning to purchase more colors.
So Little Product, Impossible to Sharpen, Smudges
Paradoxylophone from United States
I got the olive colored one. Don't get me wrong, the color is great, but I see no way to get more product out, no way to sharpen without destroying the plastic pencil, and it does smudge. It really does have great staying power but that unfortunately also applies to the areas that it smudges all over making it almost impossible to remove without REALLY scrubbing. I so wish there were better affordable colored eyeliners.
Sweetthi523 from Davenport,IA
When I first applied it, the tip broke so then I had to sharpen the pencil & the color was SUPER pigmented. Downfall is the tip is dull from it being sharpened. Definitely would recommend liquid liner Vs pencil
Great color for hazel eyes
Owen's Gigi from Lexington, KY
This color is a great alternative to dark brown. It is not as harsh but still defines my eyes beautifully.
I don't think I will buy again.
SHARON from NC
Had to use a Q tip to push out the liner as the pencil did not wind in or out.
Won't buy this again
DJ from Columbia MD
Description says it won't smudge. It immediately smudged under my eyes and made a sparkly mess. color is much lighter than I expected
Allie from Arizona
I got the periwinkle and I love it. BUT it is almost impossible to sharpen and the plastic breaks off in weird pieces.