Rated 3.98 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Long lasting and fun colors!
I was really excited to try this product out because I LOVE colorful eyeliner. It adds such a fun pop to an otherwise normal or "boring" makeup look. I was excited to see I received a really pretty blue shade that would definitely serve as a color pop on my blue eyes. When they say that this stuff lasts it LASTS. I applied this at 6am before work and didn't use any sort of primer on my oily eyelids to see what the true lasting power of this liner was- when I got home at 6pm it was still perfectly intact with no flaking or smudging of any kind. The downside to that though is that it was still on my eyes after I hopped out of the shower and it needed a bit of tough love with some eye makeup remover to get it all off. If you have sensitive eyes and need this to come off after you've had your fun with it this might not be the product for you so keep that in mind. I liked the packaging and the tiny brush applicator was easy to use and create wings with. I can see this being an incredible product for people who preform on stage or for a bride who needs her makeup to stay in place all day. The bright colored ones could also be great for concerts or raves where makeup tends to be sweated off! Overall I recommend this product if you're looking for something long wearing that comes in a unique variety of colors!
Most Helpful Critical Review New eyeliner for product testing
I received this eyeliner to test from #influenster. Upon receiving the item, the packaging was fair. It did get me excited to open the product after seeing the images on the box. Removing the product from the box you see a black tube. Noticeably, the majority of the tube is a handle and a small portion has product in which the handle dips into. Removing the handle from the product pot and pulling it out, I immediately noticed it was a fine tip liner brush with a LOT of clumpy product on it. To be able to give a fair review, I wiped off the excess product and dipped the handle in once again to see how the product would come out a second time. Once again, when removing the brush, it was clumpy. I wiped off the excess in the pot this time and noticed the bristles are quite long and soft. This can be good, depending on your preference when applying eyeliner. I prefer a more sturdy brush that I have more control over. This, in my opinion, allows for more mistakes. But if you have a steady and experienced hand, I'm sure you will enjoy this. After applying the product, this leaves little room for mistake. It DOES NOT wipe off easily. Again, this is good and bad. My eyes are sensitive so using a lot of pressure on the lid to remove a product is not enjoyable. This is an ok liner. Workable, but really nothing special. It has long lasting stay power if that is what you're looking for. It was too clumpy and soft for me to really enjoy applying, the softness of the brush made me nervous not to mess up as I had a difficult time removing it. When lining my eyes I like a thin line, not but dramatic raccoon eyes or cat eye wings. So honestly if you're into a more dramatic look it may very well work better for you.
Reviewed by 511 customers This caused a literal mental breakdown.
Maria from Fargo ND
this eyeliner makes me cry daily. application is terrible, i cant get a straight line because of the brush, the formula is horrible and watery, and once it dries i cant get it off my skin. i usually like Nyx, but this is the worst product i've ever used in my life.
It's definitely waterproof
Ally from Worcester, MA
Overall it's fine. I don't know if it was just the one I bought or all of them are like this but it was super gluey and sticky to apply. It also took forever to take off. So I guess a pro is that this wouldn't come off if you sky dived into the ocean.
Ava from Michigan
this product is absolutely lovely! It's my first time trying eyeliner, so I was expecting something good since I heard of it from Avani. This met the expectation completely. The only thing I would care to mention is that when it says waterproof and smudge proof it means it. It barely came off with my makeup remover. But I would assume that's a good thing. Over all love the product!
Lemons from Texas
I literally can't get this eyeliner off and came to the reviews in search of anyone else with the same issue, my eyes are sensitive and I made the mistake of not trying the liner of my hand first. I've tried a reusable makeup rag, a water based makeup remover, a pil based makeup remover and even makeup wipes and they barely take off anything. Its insane, but this would be GREAT for any outdoor activities or underwater actives, it won't smudge or come off but if you mess up putting it on there's no going back. I've had a black spot next to my eye for the past 2 days
I Ike it
Chelsea from Ca
Stays on pretty long.
This! I have been waiting for this all my teen and early 20'
Norman from Tucson , az
This thing last . I have read the comments hating on this product because it's hard to take off, use coconut oil then wash your face with a deep cleanser. You shouldn't be rubbing the life out your eyelids and if you gets scans you have anger issues that's not the products fault. I love this stuff! I waited from 2000 to now for something like this. It's also cheaper than the other expensive products I've bought.
I bought in White, no good
KK from Chicago
Usually love Nyx liquid liners. The white one was not good though. Pretty patchy and super flakey immediately after drying. Debated throwing it out after first use, but I'll keep it for special fx and Halloween makeup. As for everyday use though, meh.
Allie from Denver
My fav liner of ALL time. Such great quality low price!
Live this eyeliner!
Siren from Naples, FL
The only thing that removes it, is a Very strong make up remover!
I would buy this in every color !!
brinizzle from nixa, MO
I used this product for a halloween look. I loved it! I will be buying this product in more colors !!
I will not buy this product again
Marie from Texas
This was not the best product.... had to return it the quality was not its best
Easy to apply, no flaking, great colors
Ladi from College Station, Texas
Great eyeliner. Easy for even a beginner to use. Stays on and doesn't flake (I have a bad habit of touching my face... but it stays on!)
Liz from San Diego
Would not purchase this again.
Sara from YO ohio
This formula is super gooey and even though it had a fine tip end, crisp lines are virtually impossible to get. Not a fan at all.
J from Tampa
I WOULD GIVE 0 STARS IF I COULD
Rachel from virginia beach
i would like to start off by saying my face is looks absolutely horrible after trying to remove this make up. I have never had an issue w any kind of make up before and i'm not the type to right reviews but this had to be done. i used this product on my face as it says you can and an hour later i took a make up wipe to my face...nothing comes off... i go to my sink and use face wash...nothing comes off...two days later and i am still left with make up and SCABS on my face from trying to remove this product after trying make up wipes, face soap w an electric face brush, vaseline, oil, and baby wipes. I 100% DO NOT RECCOMEND
Dee Dee from Ohio
Finally found a waterproof liquid eyeliner with a brush in a beautiful shade of blue. I've been looking for a long time. Reasonable price.
Great for the price
SC Mom from South Carolina
I ran out of my favorite premium brand eyeliner and needed something immediately. I am overall really happy with this, it was less than half the price of what I usually purchase and easily 90% as good, so it has great value for the money. It has a thinner consistency, so you have to have a very steady hand; but there is a decent amount of pigment so you can get a nice looking line. It isn't quite as waterproof as my favorite eyeliner, but it gets good wear. Overall at this price it's great.
Love this liner
JILLBEAN from MINNESOTA
I have tried a ton of liquid liners. All the expensive brands but this one beats out all the others and is so reasonably priced.
Lin from California
I got this in white because I wanted to try some white eyeliner, and someone on Tiktok recommended it. There is no control over the product on the applicator and it went on extremely messily. It looked patchy.
Both the product and the applicator could use some work.
Bright white, but is very hard to take off
Bella from San Pedro, CA
This product was very expensive in store and to me, not worth it. It crusts and is hard to remove with makeup wipes or face wash.
You are better off using actual paint and your own brush.
Alexis from Virginia
The color is beautiful and it doesn't smudge as promised, but it applies like a cheap, thick paint. It does not evenly distribute, and when you add layers, it has that feeling of trying to add wet mascara on top of layers and layers of dry, clumpy mascara. It is impossible to get a sharp wing as well, which was really frustrating, and it smears all over the top of your lashes. I did decide to sleep with just the eyeliner on to see it's hold, it definitely stayed in its place, it took several times to try getting it off, it felt like I was slicing my eyelids. Because of the color and it being the only eyeliner that has never smudged, it gets two stars rather than the one. I did end up returning this, sadly.
Killin the eyeliner game!
Killin the eyeliner game! from Colorado
From their vivid brights to this Epic Liquid Liner, I have loved them all! I always use liquid and finding the right applicator + smudge free liner is not as easy as one might think but this one is my perfect match. Not overly priced either!
not the best liner, not the worst
Maya from York, PA
I bought this product instead of the Nyx Vinyl Liner, and I don't like it much. the brush doesn't carry a lot of product on the brush, so its annoying to keep redipping the brush. My eyeliner takes longer with this, and the lines arent as smooth because the brush becomes dry after traveling a few millimeters and makes my eyeliner look weird. The reason I'm still using it is because I have extremely watery eyes and I smudge the Nyx Vinyl Liner, so by using this for my inner corners and the vinyl liner for the rest of my eye. It gets the job done, but I wont say to buy a liner that you need another liner for.
This is my go to eyeliner.
Linda from FL
This eyeliner lasted through a sweaty workout followed by a sweaty bike ride and even more sweaty gardening. This has outperformed the more expensive brands.