Rated 4.2 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Favorite Eyeliner!!
Love love LOVE this eyeliner! Super pigmented and easy to use ! Reminds me of Kat Von D Tatoo liner except more affordable and in my opinion a little better!
Most Helpful Critical Review Not bad! A little liquidy...
I normally use Kat Von D Ink Liner, but I was out and low on money, so I bought this. It's a good product and stays on a long time, and does create great, precise lines. However, if you've got a shaky hand or are inexperienced with eyeliner, I probably wouldn't recommend it. It's super liquidy, and can easily get in your eye, and if you're not super careful, it can kind of get everywhere. It does this weird thing where it kind of flicks off my eyelashes and gets all over my face. If you're a makeup person and know how to use liquid liner, I'd recommend this, but if you're inexperienced, I'd try something else.
Reviewed by 2044 customers Not for oily eyelids
k from United States
It applies nicely but always smudges on my eye by the end of the day.
Makeup Lover from Los Angeles
I love this dupe for Kay von Dee's tattoo liner. It stays on my upper waterline and doesn't smudge.
. from _
really loved this product. the tip is super fine and makes it easy to create a precise line, the pigment is also pretty good
Not quite what I hoped for
Aprildancer from Holland MI
I was hoping this was waterproof because occasionally I have a slight watering in the outer corner of my eye. Not waterproof in my experience. Also, the line is a little heavier and Loreal Super Slim has better lining capabilities.
Jo from Clovis ca
Awesome goes on great and stays on all day!! Smudge proof as well
Vanessa from USA
Absolutely love this eyeliner! It's so easy to use and pigmented! It stays on through the day and is rather easy to come off when the day is done
No I would not buy again.
Cess from Turlock
I did not like that the eyeliner smears and does not stay on long.
My holy grail
Steph T. from Alabama
This eye liner is the only one I can consistently do a wing with. It goes on smoothly with the brush tip applicator (felt tips tend to drag and skip along my lids), and it allows for a precise wing if that's what you're into. These can be a little inconsistent with the amount of product they dispense, though. Some need a shake before use, others you store vertically with the tip up. Not sure where the inconsistency comes from, but the payoff is more than worth it for me- I've used 5 of these completely and just purchased my 6th!
B from Miami, FL
Came off on its own within a couple hours
I would buy this again.
Lee Anne from Granbury Texas
Upper eyelid,goes on smooth.
Karik from Nevada
For its price it's not bad. Definitely my everyday go to. I've tried so much eye liners and this is one of my top three. It doesn't smudge and easy to apply :)
Great liquid eyeliner for the price
Gabby from San Antonio
I don't know why everyone is saying that this eyeliner isn't true black or it isn't long lasting. I usually use the Stila stay all day but it's $22 bucks lol. This one isn't as perfect as stila but it's pretty close for it being so reasonably priced. I'd try it out if you're looking for a top eye eyeliner. IT IS DEFINITELY NOT FOR THE BOTTOM OF THE EYE!! (No liquid eyeliners are)
It REALLY works for me!
RedStick Review from Baton Rouge
I personally love this liner. I've tried many different types/brands of liquid liner, and normally do a wing-tip look. I read other reviews saying that it was leaking or bleeding rather badly. I have found that it CAN do that, but realized it would only leak if I shook it out of habit (which I used to HAVE to do with my more expensive liners😒), and it would bleed if I applied too much pressure or left it in the heat. I found that applying either powder or powdered eyeshadow along your lash line first helps prevent it from feathering out. I also definitely do NOT have any trouble with it staying on, even in the water! It also lasts me at least twice as long as comparable ones I've used that are more than 3x the price!!
kvd tattoo liner EXCEPT BETTER
Rui from louisville, KY
the brush tip makes this liner easy to use and extremely precise. formula is waterproof and stays on even if you sob in it. extremely black and mostly matte finish when dry. I LOVE THIS EYELINER
I will buy this again!
JoBeth from Tupelo, MS
Flows easily and precisely and doesn't smudge!
Don't Waste Your Money
Kay from Cleveland, OH
Wow, what a terrible product. It does not go on consistently, instantly flakes off, and leaves my lids feeling horribly sticky. Also, the color pay off is terrible. It's like a like brown with patches of dark brown.
cindyg1972 from Parma, OH
This product is great for upper eyelids but not good for below lash line on lower lids. Setting spray did not help it any. Also liner from upper lid will bleed into your eyes. My eyes were bloodshot from this liner when I returned home from work. I work long hours as a nurse, so this was not ideal for me. I love many other Nyx products, however this is not one. Unfortunately I couldn't figure out how to return it due to coronavirus.
My tried and true remains Stilla Stay all Day Waterproof liquid eyeliner with micro tip. It is $22 but worth every penny!
A little confused
Randi from Destin, FL
I have this eyeliner in brown for my more natural days. I love it during application, but within a few hours my little winglettes are always half gone. I'm a little confused on how people are saying this is long lasting.
Great at first, but then starts to leak a lot
Holly from Pennsylvania
I really loved this eyeliner at first for its color and easy application, but after a few weeks of using the first one I purchased, it began to bleed A LOT. I bought a second one thinking the first one was faulty, but the same thing happened. I will probably switch because of the mess it can make. With it also being waterproof, it's harder to remove once it bleeds everywhere.
Good for eyelid application
J to Ulta from Dallas, Texas
It helped a lot with eyelid looks as it stayed better.
Not a True Black on Darker or Deeper Skin
Dreatheartist from USA
I'm an African American woman (390 in Fenty Foundation) and this liner in black looks like a watery dark brown on my skin. My Wet n' Wild liquid liner is a much darker, heavily pigmented true black.
The one positive is that the liner is truly waterproof.
Great but Bleeds
Brandi from Victorville, CA
It's a good liner, doesn't flake and is solid black. It's not watery, even the MAC girl who did my makeup usedy liner and was amazed by how opaque it was. Unfortunately though, it bleeds out between the felt tip and plaatic like a mother. I thought it was a faulty one, so I purchased it again but the second one bled as well. It doesn't bleed for the first couple weeks oddly enough. It got so much drippage in my eye, I thought I was going to permanently damage my vision. Even with all the ink leaking, it does last a long time. I usually use Almays liquid liner, but this ink I like more for the blackness.
Paula from Nashua
This eyeliner is so good ! Easy to handle, pigmented . Would buy again !
Bleeds so bad!
Blossy from NYC
I really wanted to love this eyeliner, but it's so fickle. Sometimes I'm able to create a smooth line, but most times I can't even do one stroke without it bleeding ALL over. It's annoying.
I would buy it again
Eve from Corona
It's easy for me to liner on my eyes. Love it.