Product Reviews Rated 4.24 out of 5 stars
29 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Amazing This eyeliner is amazing! I've used so many eyeliners including a $20 pencil one from MAC and none of them are as amazing as this one.It lasts at least 6 hours without budging. The formula is very creamy and easy to apply. I would recommend putting a setting powder underneath your eye and then wiping it off before applying to the bottom lid. After applying I usually have to blink a few times since it makes my eyes water a little.My only complaint is that I accidentally broke the tip of it once and it was hard to sharpen after that.I highly recommend especially if your one to wear makeup all day.
Most Helpful Critical Review "ROSE GLOW" NOT COLOR AS ADVERTISED...... I LOVE these liners from Pixi but am disappointed with the Rose Glow color, it is shown as a rose-ish color and that is what you would expect to get especially since the packaging is rose colored but the actual liner when placed on the back of my hand and on my eyes is straight gold, nothing even remotely looks rose or even rose-ish. It is a beautiful gold color and it is smooth and creamy just not the color that it is being sold as. It should be called GOLD GLOW. Won't ever be using this :-(
Reviewed by 29 customers Easy to Use 5
MariC from Bordentown, NJ
Pencil glides on easily and smoothly. Lovely intense color.
Good 5
Nina from Troy
Stays long
YOU CAN SHARPEN IT 5
Nelly from Wi
It's great and guess what? ITS NOT A WIND UP YOU SHARPEN IT!! yes!! With any eyeliner sharpener!! Wow what a concept imagine...
Best eyeliner 5
Robin from Virginia
The has got to be one of the best eyeliner i have ever used.
Smooth and easy pencil 4
Jax from San antonio, TX
I bought. It GLIDES on...and its super bendable. I liked so much, I went back for another color.
Dull sharping 3
Older user from Washington
My biggest review fault hard to sharpen, wastes the pencil and color
Got charged more and pencil doesn't wind up 2
Carol from Florida
The color is pretty - coppery.It wears off. The pencil doesn't push up when I wind the bottom...am I supposed to sharpen it? It doesn't seem like a sharpening pencil when the bottom twists.
It's Ok 3
Indian Beauty Addict from Morris Plains, NJ
This on the face doing some special effects makeup for fine details is great and it glides like a dream. As an eyeliner, it smudges easily and breaks easily. I prefer Stila or KVD liqiud liners.
Would buy again 5
Rosa flor from Dallas Texas
I used it under and top of eye. I live it because it glides on smoothly and fast. It's a little bit shimmering so just have to rub it off twice when washing my face.
Favorite eye pencils. I have many colors. 5
RebeccaLG from Wisconsin
Top of my eye line for a lift of my 51-year-old eyes. Sometimes I put it underneath for more definition as well.
"ROSE GLOW" NOT COLOR AS ADVERTISED...... 1
Di from Maryland
I LOVE these liners from Pixi but am disappointed with the Rose Glow color, it is shown as a rose-ish color and that is what you would expect to get especially since the packaging is rose colored but the actual liner when placed on the back of my hand and on my eyes is straight gold, nothing even remotely looks rose or even rose-ish. It is a beautiful gold color and it is smooth and creamy just not the color that it is being sold as. It should be called GOLD GLOW. Won't ever be using this :-(
Excellent! 5
Sand Witch from Kennebunkport, ME
This is the best eyeliner I've ever used - just bought three more colors.
This is good 5
Lovesmakeup444 from Missouri
This eyeliner is just as good as UD gel pencils but cheaper! There is only a few, dark shades available so that is a little disappointing. I hope they come out with more colorful ones!
Pretty Color - Doesn't Last 3
Georgia Mom from Marietta, GA
My first Pixie purchase. I love the bronze color. It goes well with my complexion and eyes. It also goes on smoothly without tugging. Unfortunately, the liner doesn't last more than a few hours. If you're willing to reapply during the day, then I can recommend it.
no 1
GreenEyes from FL
I love the color and creaminess of the eye liner , this is the second one I have purchased and every time i try to sharpen them they break and crumble so there is a lot of waste for the cost of this item
My new go-to eyeliner 5
Tannin86 from St. Paul, MN
I was amazed at how silky and smooth this eye liner is. LOVE IT!
So GOOD 5
Zeus4President2020 from North Dakota
Sooooo silky and creamy to apply, and it stays all day. I use this more than all my liquid liners combined. Seriously, this is a fantastic liner.
Love it! 5
O'Jean from Chicago, IL
Goes on like a dream and stays put until you want it off. Then comes off without a fight. Inexpensive but feels luxurious! Love it.
Stays put! 5
Lazymamma50 from Reno NV
This liner is great! Stays put and doesn't slide off - will be back for other colors!
I would buy this product again 5
Michele from Ohio
Love this product! Easy to use!
Stays put and lasts long! 5
anshpo from Ohio
I have this in three colors now. The Noir Black smudges like crazy and I have a bronze that wears all day. So I wasnt sure if another dark color would last or not. Once it sets, it's not moving. So definitely smudge or blend it out immediately if that's your thing. The color is really pretty and it doesnt irritate my sensitive eyes. You do lose a lot of product when you sharpen it. I wish it was a retractable pencil instead. If you freeze it for about 10 mins first it will sharpen easier. It is a very soft pencil. Definitely my favorite gel liner even if it isnt waterproof.
My go to eyeliner! 5
Kendra from Washington
I love this eyeliner. Got it as a sample initially & fell in love with the creamy highly pigmented color that doesn't move all day. I wear makeup under hot lights for multiple hours per day and this eyeliner never fails me. it doesn't disappear or need reapplying even after 8+ hours. The black is dark and the liner actually stays put in the waterline. It continues to wow me! The actual pencil sharpens well & lasts forever.
For the price, you can't do better!
Nice! good! Great? 4
strandedmermaid from El Paso TX
It's a good eyeliner, but I'm very oily all the waterproof eye liners in the world smudge on me. This one is in my top 5 tho great application and rich color, good price.
Almost perfect 4
Beauty Within from South Carolina
Overall, this is a very good eyeliner. It's creamy, glides on beautifully with a one swipe, non irritating, has intense black color and will last until you take it off. Even after 12 hours of wear, it still performs very well. I took off one star because it runs a little after about 4 hours and a little concealer is needed to remove the smearing. Despite, this it's a very good eyeliner, especially for the price. Would definitely buy again.
Very creamy 4
Pats from Puerto Rico
Excellent pigmentation, very creamy and soft. The only thing is that it smeared on me so I didn't find it very waterproof. Overall great but i don't think i would repurchase.