Rated 3.38 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review tenderheart!
I have tried to find this color everywhere, and it is no where to be found, this color will compliment any skin tone, and any color eye-shadow, blush etc.....It just makes me look beautiful like no other color! it is for everyone! and its nice and moist, and re- applies beautifully!!! I recommend you try it too!
Most Helpful Critical Review So very disappointed
Extremely disappointed, hate it. I think it's a cheap way to waterdown your prior product that was working just great, btw. I also think you fail your customers when you don't educate your stores that this item was being changed and the colors are just not available for months to buy - Heather Moon is my only go to color. Send out some communication so buyers are educated and can answer these questions when you decide to pull something off the shelf and change it.
Aside from not being able to find any inforamtion for months on why this product was no loger available and undersand what was going on, after seeing what you've done with this product, huge fail #2 - you clearly didn't check with your existing customer base to try 'testing' your product before launching it.
And in response to your one 'merchant response' to a customer who indicated the new product doesn't stay on like the prior 'long lasting' one:
"For a little more staying power, try using our Quickliner for Lips underneath to keep the lipstick in place all day without feeling matte! Our online Consultants are happy to help you select a shade and assist with an exchange/return if needed. Click the "Talk to a Consultant" icon to be connected."
What a sad response. Who wants to spend more money for another product?? You took out lisptick and replaced it with something no one needed changed or wanted. You didn't reduce the price but then suggest purchasing a liner?? Forget it.
Go back to the original long lasting line and leave it alone. It was working the way it was, and if you wanted to change things up, you should have spent more time, if any, with a focus group and roll one or two colors out before changing over an entire line.
As soon as I can find a comparable color, I'm out. Loyalty is fleeting today and you have to do more to want to make customers stick around. I strongly recommend pulling this new line and putting the original one back in place.
Reviewed by 575 customers I love this nude on fair skin!
Jlpeace2 from Mount Laurel, NJ
I am fair skinned and red headed. This appears slightly darker than a nude on me adding a faint touch of color but still looks neutral.
It stays on under my mask!
Harlow from Denver
This lipstick should get 5 stars - it's moisturizing but has staying power, it stays on under my face mask! That is amazing. A different grape is my favorite.
Yes, I would buy this product again.
Roz from AZ
It is lipstick. I use it on my lips.
It's only OK
Wolfie from Boston
I have both this lipstick and the old formula in Silvery Moon. This new formula seems very thin! The color doesn't go on as easily as I'd like; I have to run it over my lips several times before I can see it. I don't like the Pop colors, so if I want to stay with Clinique, this is pretty much my only choice ...
Best I've found for sensitive lips!
Bebe from Charlotte
I love this lipstick! For several years I've searched for a lipstick that doesn't cause sensitivity yo my lips and cause them to crack and peel, along with a color that works. Finally, this! I love it!
Mandi T from Clarkston, WA
I absolutely LOVE this lipstick! I got the raspberry glacé shade and it is such a lovely shade. The formula itself is very comfortable on the lips. It's not sticky or waxy and it doesn't have a smell. It is glittery so if you don't like that this lipstick isn't for you. I'm ready to order more shades!
Cristina from NY
I love these lipsticks, especially the ones with a bit of shimmer (my favorite is Raspberry Glace)!
Anna from LA
I like it. I like this color. And it can keep long
Linda from MI
Just a bit darker than natural lip color.
EK from New Mexico
I really loved the old dramatically different formula, it is the lipstick that I used on my wedding. I wanted to try the new formula and a different color, and was very disappointed. I wanted to love it, but could not, it looks so glittery on my lips and emphasis my lip lines. The center color doesn't contour my lips. The old formula made my lips look and feel hydrated.
Extreme Pink! Love it!
Jenny from Claremore OKLAHOMA
What is the closest color you have now to Extreme Pink?
Every Day A New Color!
The Office Girl from Chicago, IL
I purchased 3 or 4 colors and I change them up every day!! I love to have a different color during the day or every day. The metal tube is a good size to fit in my pocket and the top stays on too! Love it!
New Color for me
Lady Linda from Wheaton, IL
I like the Clinique products. I do not skimp on my lips. I like the color and know I am putting a healthy product on my lips.
Worth trying... you will love it!
Jana from Minnesota
I have been using this lipstick for a year;it never disappoints!
Suey from Scottsdale
Wouldn't buy any other color.
My lips never get dried out like other lipsticks
Els439 from Bradenton
I have 3 or more lipsticks. Plus I have two almost lipsticks. Almost raisin and almost pink
Why did they change their lipsticks!
Saltysue from N. Myrtle Beach, SC
I've used clinique lipsticks for 45 years! They were great until now. Feel very cheap. Goes on thin and colors aren't as good. High impact lipstick was the best they made.
I love this lip stick and the color. It is my favorite color
Cleo from Mankato, MN.
This lilp stick is my favorite lip stick.. I love the color.
I would buy this again
Mac from Lakewood Ohio
Clinique makes the best lipsticks this one stays moist
BRING BACK THE ORIGINAL
Nico from Massachusetts
The new formula goes on unevenly, concentrating most color around the edges of my lips where it makes me look old and tired. I used Dramatically Different lipstick for a good 25 years very happily--it was the only lipstick I use. The new formula looks bad, wastes product (is that the point, perhaps?), and is disliked by most people who've tried it. I won't buy Clinique lipstick again unless the original formula is reinstated.
Seaster from Sunny Carolina
Love the formula and the color Silvery Moon. Will be back to try other colors.
Why did you change the formula???
Alison from NC
I agree with Mary from WI on July 12, 2020!! I was introduced to the "original" formula lipstick in 2000 for my wedding portrait & fell in love with it!!! BEST LIPSTICK EVER!!! Finally found a lipstick that didn't dry my lips out, gorgeous colors, lasts forever! A couple of months ago went in to buy a tube & it had the new formula. DRIED MY LIPS OUT & they PEELED non stop!!! Horrible!! The consultant told me that I must be allergic to something in the new moisturizing dot in the lip stick! So glad I keep all my lipsticks because she then sold me a retractable brush so now I can use all my "old" lipsticks (dig into the tube with the brush,) & even though they may be "old" they are PERFECT for me & my lips & my lips haven't peeled a day since!!! Extremely extremely disappointed that we don't have the option to purchase the "old" formula!
Perfect lip color!
Kath from St Louis
Have used Raspberry Glacé for many years and it is always the perfect color for all occasions.
It keeps my skin in good condition every day.
Gemini from Portland
It's great. It keeps my skin in the best shape.
Clinique has ruined dramatically different lipstick line
Mary from WI
I have been loyal to your lipstick brand for decades....even when you dropped my favorite colors because your lipstick was smooth and creamy with a shimmer. BUT you recently changed the formula by adding a core among other things and now I hate it. It clumps and cracks drying on my lips making it look hideous and my lips uncomfortable. WHY did you alter perfection? Unless you revert to your previous formula (which I doubt) I will not buy it again. Searching for a new brand.