Rated 4.19 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review The creamiest liner ever?!?
I received a complimentary collection of liners and lipsticks for review and testing purposes. My opinions are mine and mine alone! I've been struggling to find a lip liner that glides on lips without dragging, that gives good color payoff- without breaking the bank! These liners are creamy- I'm not the best at lining my lips, but these pencils glide effortlessly, making it a cinch! The color can be light or rich- they're blendable and buildable. They can be worn with a light balm or gloss, or they can be paired with a lipstick for full-on glam. I'm in love! Will definitely be getting more and recommending to clients!
Most Helpful Critical Review Great color, bad product
Purchased liner, #110 MATTE'S IT, a few weeks ago. Love the color, but the product itself is a waste of money. It's supposed to be sharpened, but almost impossible as the outer shell makes it hard to turn and sharpen as advertised.
Reviewed by 450 customers Can't sharpen
MASMM from Flint MI
I am returning the product. I trie to sharpen with a lip sharpener but it did not work. They should make it a non sharpening pencil.
Love the color but hate that you can't sharpen
Atamu12 from undisclosed
You can't sharpen the pencil without buying a separate tool and they don't advertise that! Terrible
Love, hate relationship
NotAgain000 from undisclosed
I bought two of these lip liners. I love the color, its so smooth. But I can't use all the product without buying a sharper. I wish they would have put it on the packaging that you had to buy another tool just to sharpen and get use of all the product in the liner. It's like they're taking tips from Apple. SMH. Wonderful product, poor execution.
I would buy this product again!
Dhaf from Alabama
Wish it came with sharpner
Great product, poor design.
Jeri from California
Finally I found a lipliner that was the PERFECT color and would line well, stay all day and look great on my 58 year old lips. HOWEVER, there is NO WAY to dial up/push up the product once used down. I have no problem purchasing the separate sharpener. But to purchase a product with the assumption you can use the entire product and you can't is very disappointing! I even broke open the pencil housing in sheer frustration and there is PLENTY of product in the pencil. Just no way to advance the crayon out of the pencil. L'oreal, I've used your products for over 40 years with continued success. Please reengineer this product!
Bako from Bakersfield CA
First use and it broke. I only had a small amount out too. I'm taking it back.
Pity about the plastic coating!
Birdsong from Cumbria
Colour vibrant but having to sharpen the 'pencil' there is waste.
Jennifer from Alabama
Would never buy this again. Won't roll up and won't sharpen well.
Waste of money
Haleygrice0727 from Carrollton, GA
I really don't understand why they would make a plastic or "plastic coated" lip liner need to be SHARPENED. I bought two liners and used each once before they were in need of sharpening and no sharpener I have tried has worked. If there is one specific sharpener that works for this product then it should be included in the package or boldly stated on the package. Even if the cost of the liner were to go up because the sharpener was included I would still purchase because the actual liner is a perfect color and great consistency. Do not recommend the cost for a one time use though.
ClassicBeauty from Houston
Went down a rabbit hole of trying to purchase every-single-last-made lip liner of a retired favorite. Happened across a recommendation of this one, 'Matte's It' in particular. Bought when Ulta had a sale and I'm so glad I did! This lip liner glides smoothly and lines precisely. It also has great saturation and wears all day. I apply a plumping gloss on over and it looks gorgeous; constantly asked what I'm wearing. Awesome quality for the price. Oh, and I personally do not struggle with sharpening.
Maybe it was just this one liner but it sucked
Celeste from Chicago, Illinois
I was lightly applying the liner when the color part fell out of the liner. Then I went to sharpen it because it says "sharpenable" but the pencil is literally made out of plastic. How am I supposed to sharpen that?
Dee12 from Gatineau
It would be nice in you sold the lip liner sharpener with the pencil. If I had known a sharpener was needed with this pencil I wouldn't have bought it.
It's plastic! I ruined it trying to sharpen it.
Love, Love, Love!!
bigbeauty from Ontario,Ca
I love Loreal
I will throw these pencils away !--- don't work!! TOO hard
JR from Florida
Feels high end, way creamy & long lasting
Rosebud from Utah
This is a great drugstore liner that feels & performs high end!! Very smooth and creamy. Only con is that it's hard to sharpen..!
SophieGP from Chilliwack BC
What a waste of money! I used it once or twice and now I can't use it anymore because I thought I would be able to twist it to get the rest of it but it's not adjustable. I see now that we have to sharpen it but why then does it not come with its own sharpener? Anyway I'm very disappointed with L'Oreal and I'm a Very good customer normally but I will not buy any more!
CillaM from San Antonio TX
It so sad that I finally found a perfect color thinking it was a twist up lip liner! There is no sharpener that works and I'm now left with practically no use of a brand new product!! Not worth the purchase! Will not buy again.
MATTE Lip LINER
Lin 327 from Greenville, SC
Once this pencil used up the tip there was no way to push up a new tip. It needed to be sharpened and was useless!! A waste of money. The color is great but impossible to use without sharpening the tip with difficulty!!!!!
Worst Lip Liner Ever
krisa from Orange County, CA
This liner does not sharpen. I have wasted nearly half of the liner just to find a sharp tip that I can use. I will NEVER buy this liner again. Don't waste your money!
Perfect Matte lipliner!
Marie from SC
Nice and creamy matte color goes on smooth.
L'Oreal Colour Riche Matte lip liner
Midwest Colorado Girl from Denver, Colorado
This product does not sharpen! Today is the 3rd time I have purchase this lip liner thinking I did not do something right during sharpening. It is not me, it is the poor design of the product plus it is misleading as it looks like it is a twist rather than requiring sharpening. It is a total waste of money. Plus disappointing that you would make something like this which does not fit your style or class. There will not be a 4th time buying your lip liner.
This is the BEST lip pencil EVER!
Lipliner from Texas
I go just outside my lip lines, and it not only stays on all day, it also creates a fuller lip.
Best Lip Liner
FashionQueen28 from Central Florida
I purchased the lip liner in "Matte's It" and when I put it on. The formula felt so creamy and moisturizing and my Fenty Gloss bomb felt great with the lip liner. I bought two and got one free and I don't regret it.
DonnaH1971 from Royal Oak MI
I have been using Loreal for years. I love the color but plastic pencil is horrible. Twist up there is no waste this design plastic breaks of and I used several make up sharpeners. The worst area is the imprinted lettering.
Needs a sharpener
DotW from Blacksburg, VA
Bought this thinking it was a twist up liner. Very disappointed. I dislike ones that need sharpened but even worse the sharpener I have doesn't work on the plastic casing. Waste of money. Do not want to spend more money to buy the Loreal sharpener as I never plan to buy this product again. Money down the drain.