Rated 4.02 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Quite good
I am very picky about mascara. I have long eyelashes, and so I look for a mascara that will hold the natural curl of my lashes and that will provide volume and a bit more length. I hate wet mascaras and I hate natural bristle wands.
I really like this mascara! I got it as a free gift with purchase and I'm glad because I probably wouldn't have tried it otherwise.
The brush is exactly what I like, silicone bristles that are fairly close together. The brush is a nice size; I wouldn't mind if it were a little smaller because I'm kind of messy when applying mascara, but it's not too big). The mascara is not too wet but not too dry. Most importantly, it adds both volume and length and it holds the curl of my lashes. It removes easily at night, and it doesn't smudge. My lashes look long and full and feathery, and I really like how they look.
I do comb through my lashes after application just because I like them to be really separated, but that's probably not a necessary step. As my tube has gotten older, I've noticed a bit of flaking but it's minimal as long as I don't touch my eyes during the day. I don't use this on my bottom lashes because the bristles aren't quite long enough to keep me from smudging mascara on my face, but I already have a bottom lash mascara that I like so that's not really a negative for me.
The only thing that keeps me from giving this a perfect rating is the price. I typically buy drugstore mascara because mascara doesn't last as long as something like foundation or eyeshadow (and also because I'm so picky that I don't want to spend a lot of money on something I end up hating). I haven't decided whether I'll repurchase this mascara once my tube runs out. If it were cheaper, I'd repurchase it in a heartbeat.
Most Helpful Critical Review Not for my eyelashes sadly...
I read through quite a bit of the reviews and I truly feel bad leaving this, but I feel that maybe the reason I'm getting such horrid results is because I have rediculously long lashes. I love to amp them up even more, but honestly, this mascara makes me look like flakey spider eye lady in 10 mins. I only put one coat and i waste a lot of product just getting the gunky excess off the wand. It's like too much product comes out and so it just clumps in one area. Then I'm using my finger to try to spread it more evenly. So I do feel if you have thick, already long lashes, the odds are hte product is going to hate your lashes. I will say it comes off easily and does not dry out my lashes. So I feel the argan oil claim is at least true. I tried the magnetic one, literally jsut now and it did not clump at all. It separated my lashes perfectly. While they don't look as full and long as THIS mascara made them, I don't have any of the cons so far that I did with this mascara. So ladies, if you already are gifted in the lash department go for the magnetic mascara by PUR. lol'
Reviewed by 348 customers Good but not great
Aria from Texas
It has a nice smooth formula and lengthens lashes well, but it doesn't hold a curl AT ALL and clumps easily
DB4 from Coral Springs, FL
This is my second time buying this product. I have really short eyelashes and this mascara makes them long and look thicker. It also has Aragon oil.
Great for allergy prone people
KJ from Tennessee
I am allergic to soooo many products. The sales assoc. recommended this and it works great for me.
No allergic reactions and I can finally wear mascara again!!!
It does clump up and hard to apply 2 coats, thus I would choose another mascara if I didn't have allergy problems,
Way Better Options at this price point
Glendeetz from CA
Nothing special. Can't really handle more than one coat without clumping. Does not provide any curl. Lash separation is not great. For the price there are so many better options.
The best mascara
Sherri the dancer from Robbinsville NJ
I've used this product for years. It is the best mascara!! It goes on easily, and makes your lashes look so full and long.
MY NEW FAVORITE MASCARA
KimmyH from Lantana, TX
LOVE this mascara! I've tried a lot of mascaras and have always preferred a bristle brush, however this is the first silicone brush I have found that works perfect. I can see that it has helped my lashes grow as I have received compliments on how full they look. LOVE, LOVE this mascara!!
Decent mascara, but nothing special.
The Jertiol from Portland, OR
This is an okay mascara, it does give me longer looking lashes, but it does smear/crumble off a little after a while.
did not get desired result
Debbie from Little Rock
I used this product with and without a primer. I am not happy with the result. I purchased the product with points and am disappointed that I wasted the points on this product.
Lee from Burlington, NC
I like this mascara, the bristles are silicone and separate the lashes very well especially lower lashes. I will buy it again.
Not at all what was promoted in the store!
Sissy from Houma LA
The sales people highly recommended this product on the day I visited the store. I think it was just that they were promoting this product brand that day because it is not at all what they stated. It clumps very badly and does smear by end of day.
Michelle from Chicago, IL
I bought this mascara after my lashes were damaged from lash extensions. The brush is great for thin lashes and provides a ton of extra length! I highly recommend this product and will keep buying this mascara.
Never buy this!!
Redhead from Texas
The worst mascara I have ever bought!! Big chunks come off the brush if you even call it a brush. No grooves for lashes to be pulled through. I had to return.
Better than any other super expensive mascara I have tried
Cathy from Nh
I have short Straight lashes, this mascara really makes my lashes look full and long. I did use an eyelash curler first.
I finally found it!
Heather from Atlanta, GA
I am sure that I am not the only person to say I have tried DOZENS of mascaras, but for me it is true. Better Than Sex, Bad Girl Bang, drug store brands, waaaayyyy too many. All I wanted was a mascara that made my lashes pop but didn't make me look like I had spider eyes, and that would stay on all day but didn't take a chisel to remove. I know, a lot to ask...but this one delivers. Coats all of my lashes with a great brush, doesn't flake off, and makes my eyes look great! Can't believe I finally found it!
All time favorite
Shelly from Iowa
This has been my mascara for years! I received as a free sample and absolutely fell in love. My lashes are naturally very straight and this mascara curls them beautifully without a lash curler! It makes them look so incredibly long. Absolutely no smudging as your wear it.
my #1 product
longlashes from Athens, GA
if I could only pick one product to have for the rest of my life, it would be this. this mascara goes on smooth and doesn't clump at all. I'll feel my lashes throughout the day and they STILL FEEL SOFT EVEN WITH MASCARA ON. I wish there was a way to rate it even higher. I've looked at so many lists of "best mascaras" and can't believe this has never been on it. I've tried Too Faced Better Than Sex and Lancôme Monsieur Big and Maybelline (orange tube), and none came even close to comparing. I will fight for this mascara until the day I die, 100% best product on the shelf.
the golden conch of mascaras
Medina from Georgia
I have always had naturally long lashes, and this moisturizes my lashes, and also one of the ONLY mascaras that don't irritate my eyes and cause them to water. When i ran out, I attempted to use a drugstore one for a month and noticed how my lashes fell off more often and how irritated my eyes got.
For those complaining about the wand (despite my love for it): you could always get a wand of your choosing and use it instead of this one... lol not that hard
Brush broke before I could use
Jessica from Indiana
I was excited to use but my brush head came off in the bottle when trying to get the excess mascara off. love the formula with a different head.
That Wand Though
Amanda T. from Cape Coral, FL
I got this in my Ipsy glam bag and just have to warn others. The wand is awful. I have naturally longer lashes and it goes on terrible. My lashes get all dumped together and it feels heavy. No bueno! Which is shame because I wanted to love this SO BAD because it's vegan. -deep sigh- Very disappointed!
This is my new favorite!!!
Linda from Tucson
I put this on after the lash conditioner and WOW!!! It really does make my lashes better!!
jayhawk from lawrence, ks
I received this as part of a set and I love it. It lengthens my lashes and stays PUT. I haven't had issues with clumping. I have tried all kinds of mascara and this works well.
Kam from WI
I bought this mascara strictly because of the sale, and I had tried some other things form Pür which I really liked. I have to say, despite the mixed reviews that almost prevented me from buying it, I am really enjoying using this mascara. It goes on well, it doesn't clump, and the brush head is really nice. It's easy on for both your upper and lower lashes. I'm really happy with this find and will probably buy it again even not on sale.
Stephanie from phoenix
I was hoping to like this but it makes my lashes stick together (doesn't separate), seems to get all over everywhere and is kinda hard to remove.
Can you say Clump, Clump and more Clump??
K. from Gainesville, FL
This was a waste of money.
Terrible brush head
Dani from New york
Dont get me wrong the formula of this mascara is amazing but the actual brush to apply it is just horrible. The bristles are not long enough and because of that, it actually does clump the mascara.