Rated 4.05 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Best Liner Ever
How many times have you been halfway through putting on yoru makeup when you realize your liner needs sharpening? Or you sharpen it and the end isnt as smooth as you'd like it? This "Always Sharp" self sharpening liner is so convenient. Everytime you open the cap it is ready for easy application. Plus, the liner itself is amazing. It glides on so smoothly, that I can line my top lid with one or two strokes. Normally, some liners are great for big, dramatic winged eyeliner but they are too thick for everyday use. The tip is small enough I can gently line, but it manages to be perfect for all types of looks. I don't think I will ever buy a different type of liner again.
Most Helpful Critical Review Perfect colour!
This product would have been given the best score possible if the tip hadn't broken off 3 weeks after purchasing it I only used it to rim my upper lashes along the waterline..It's a delicate area that takes a bit of precision so it's not like you can apply a lot of pressure there!
Now there is no product left! The tip! that's all you get!. so although it was perfect for me-the colour I purchased was 'Violetta' (which I don't see listed in the colour samples) was beautiful on my brown eyes and I love that it's long lasting waterproof .it really stays in place and doesn't transfer to my lower rim- like most eye-liners,.I can't justify spending close to $25 for a 'tip' of product! disappointing for such a beautiful product :(
Reviewed by 1904 customers Love this product, best eyeliner stay on all day!
Mari from Naples, Florida
Use it when at the beach and pool all day no smears.
I hate it, I would never it a again
Cookie from Blue Springs Mo
No good at all,
Tip breaks off
Meaghan from Bismarck, ND
I really like this eyeliner. It applies well and stays on. the only issue I have is the tip breaks off every 4 or so uses and I have to sharpen it, making me feel like I'm wasting a lot of product.
MGumdrops from Riverside, Ca
Never have to try sharpening your eyeliner pencil again! Built in sharpener..., Amazing!!! Will purchase again.
No worth the price
Figgy from New York
I have problems with most eyeliners and mascaras. I gave this pencil a try but it smudged and disappeared just like the cheapest of the brands. Very disappointed.
I will buy in every color!
Momma of two toddlers from Fort Worth, Tx
I love this eyeliner. It is my go to. I used to use liquid eye liner. This gives me a soft yet sturdy line. I have brown, black and navy. I am looking to purchase the rest.
Not this color
Don't have a nickname from Lisle, Il
I love this eyeliner, but I do not like this color, My color Storm is not available in the store
I would NOT buy this again!
MOZ from Louisville, Ky.
this is soft and easy to apply, but comes off easily, especially in hot weather.
Kimber777 from Roseville
I used it only twice and when I opened it the third time it was flat at the tip and no way to get it to come out completely unusable. A waste of money
Happy to find this product.
Jan from Kentucky
Now I do not have to sharpen for each use. The design of the liner does it for you. Very smooth application, unlike other liner pencils. I will buy this again.
I have used this pencil for 2 yrs., best out there!
RD from PA - Pennsylvania
Self sharpener built inside! beautiful color, long lasting!
The liquid is better
Marie from Wahiawa
I just picked this up at the store. I decided to try it on only for the tip to come off as soon as I placed it on my skin.
I usually use the liquid liner but wanted to try something new. I wouldn't purchase this again based on this experience.
Stays on all day! Push stick inward to refill point.
CG from Maine
This stick should come with instructions. I had thrown two away, not knowing that I could push inward on the stick to pop out more product. I learned that from someone else's review. Knowing that now, this is my favorite stick for the money. The product stays on all day. You can use a thin or thick line.
I WANT to love this eyeliner!
Trishar from Reno, NV
If this product would last a bit longer I would love it and give it 5 stars!!!
Best eyeliner ever!
Exercise fanatic from Tucson, Arizona
This eyeliner is self sharpening so it always has a nice sharp line. I exercise a lot and this liner stays put and does not smear. I have an issue with my tear duct so my eye waters all day long but this eyeliner does not come off ,it stays and looks great through out my day.
Dar from Central Florida
It just finishes the look for the day. Makes your eyes look fresher
JH from Washington, DC
Smudged within an hour, giving me raccoon eyes. And, it was difficult to touch up throughout the day before getting home, since it's waterproof.
Elham from Burke, va
I love it, so creamy. And will stay long time
Candy from PA
This goes on so smooth and looks like a liquid eyeliner on my eyes. One of my favorites so far and it stays on a long time.
Love it! Great in a rush!
Starr from West Palm Beach, FL
I've been using these for years. Favorite is Silk Taupe. Glides on, no sharpening, hard to mess up, great that it's a lighter shimmery color.
JEMP from Wisconsin
I use this liner daily to tightline. I have all the colors. It does not irritate my very sensitive eyes, stays on until I remove it at the end of day, no flaking or fading. I love that you don't have to sharpen it.
not that great
ce9803 from indio
good thing I bought it on sale not the best eyeliner I don't think it's waterproof. does not stay on all day
Exactly as described
lexycat from Riverside, CA
I really like this eyeliner. It is exactly as it is described. It's waterproof and doesn't smudge easily. I have hooded eyes and often have to deal with my eyeliner transferring to the top of my eyelid. This one doesn't do that so I'm really happy with it. It didn't budge after a full day of work and running afterwards. Also it really does self sharpen in the cap. After a few uses, the eye liner broke, so that's why I gave it one star less. At first, I couldn't figure out how to twist up the rest of it, However, I did eventually figure it out and you simply have to put the cap back on and keep twisting. Anyway, I'm overall really happy with it and will continue to use it.
This is likely the worst eyeliner product I've ever tried
MiaT. from Austin, Texas
The cap says twist off, so you do, but it doesn't say how to dispense the product. You pump it, wow, can it just say that. The other problem is that when you do, there's very little product. I can't believe how little there is for the money. Will not buy again or recommend. The only thing is the color is perfect, a deep purple black.
I would buy this product again & again
Mar from Lisle, Il
Easy to use, Lasts 24 hours, doesn't irritate my eyes even when I wear my contacts.