Product Reviews Rated 4.65 out of 5 stars
23 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review ONLY longwear eyeliner that STAYS I LOVE this eyeliner! I use it on my waterline and it is literally the only eyeliner out of the tons and tons I have tried that actually stays put. Finally!!! I never write reviews, but I've been really blown away by how great this works and lives up to what it says it does. I only bought the black, but I wear it all day without it ending up under my eyes. It doesn't irritate my contacts or eyes. Really a great bargain!
Most Helpful Critical Review Not as great as expected Was sold based on the reviews, but definitely not anything special. Used with a primer and setting spray, and still had raccoon eyes after 3 hours. The only pro is that the bronze is an amazing color for anyone with green eyes, and definitely made mine pop. Not the worst I've had but definitely doesn't stay as well as I hoped.
Reviewed by 23 customers Doesn't Smudge But Not 24 Hr. Wear 4
RescuePrincess from Vero Beach, FL
Generally, I only wear eyeliner on my waterline and decided to try a less expensive 24 hr wear liner. I have to say I was at an outdoor event for work the other day and was rained on multiple times and this eyeliner did not budge. No smudging at all. I would love to give this liner 5 stars but the staying power is not great. On a normal day, this liner will not last through my work day. It fades soon after lunch, which is frustrating. I definitely recommend for outdoor events because even in the Florida humidity and inclement weather, it did not move but definitely not a 24 hour liner.
👍 5
Evie from NYC
This stuff does not move and it's even harder to remove.
Stayed on all day 5
Dabrat1978 from Charlotte NC
Best pencil for waterline I've tried. I have to use waterproof makeup due to heat near my face at all day. Stayed on even after I took a nap on my day off ! Lol took me a minute to figure out you sharpen it. I kept turning the bottom. Worked fine with an Ulta pencil sharpener.
Love this product! 5
Gail79 from PA
Best waterline eyeliner I've used to date. Stays put & goes on smooth.
Not as great as expected 2
SM from Medford
Was sold based on the reviews, but definitely not anything special. Used with a primer and setting spray, and still had raccoon eyes after 3 hours. The only pro is that the bronze is an amazing color for anyone with green eyes, and definitely made mine pop. Not the worst I've had but definitely doesn't stay as well as I hoped.
It stays on! No raccoon eyes. 5
DiveLady from Ohio
I had tried to use eyeliner on the insides of the lids and have always been frustrated that it comes off and smears under the eyes within an hour no matter how expensive.
I am amazed at both the price as well as the staying power. Just make sure to let it dry for 30 seconds per the instructions and it will stay until you take it off.
Great pencil 5
tizziebz from PA
It is a long lasting eye pencil. Good on waterline.
Best waterline eyeliner! 5
Marissa from Pennsylvania
I've tried SO many black eyeliners, from drugstore to high-end and this is the only one that lasts on my waterline! Will be repurchasing again & again!
Love 5
Your friend from Nj
Great product! Nice dark pigmentation and works well. Stays on all day without running under my eyes from my waterline. I will continue to use.
STAYING POWER 5
Makeup Diva from NC
Love, love love!! Staying power. I have to be careful with what products I use due to allergies. No problem with this one.
The mini-hype is real on this! 5
ScruffDaPup from Lexington, KY
This is one of the longest lasting eyeliners I've used. I have watery eyes and very few last on the waterline, but this one--if you layer it just a little, lasts overnight--and possibly the next day! It is very hypoallergenic--one of the best. (The ABH one is slightly better, but this one is a more flattering black, IMO) Please, Ulta restock this!
Red eyeliner 2
Angee from Minneapolis
I bought both black and bronze. The bronze is a red color that I returned. The black is ok, It's stays on.
Only eyeliner I'll use now 5
aubrey from California
Use on the waterline and it stays put, goes on buttery so now dragging feeling, intense pigment, stays on all day through allergies even.
Almost smudge proof 4
Trish from NorCal
I have very sensitive skin and eyes but because I am very pale, I really need eyeliner and mascara. Anything that melts into my eyes is agony. This eyeliner goes on very smoothly without tugging my eyelids and stays put better than any other product that I don't have to tug at my eyes to put on (pencil might stay better but I'm done with the pulling at my eyelids). It can smudge slightly right after application but it has been a billion degrees here lately and this has not ended up in my eyes!
Love this liner 5
Nicatnite99 from Atlanta
This is a beautiful bronze with a rose gold shift. I love it for the lower lash line and waterline in particular. It stays put and the color stays true. Will definitely repurchase!
WOW! 5
Terable13 from Clearwater, Florida
I needed a waterproof eyeliner for when I'm at the beach and this this not disappoint! I fell asleep in it and it was still there the next day, even after a day of sun, beach, sand, and sweat. I'm impressed! And the price is right. I think this is my new favorite for waterproof pencil eyeliner, even better than Tarte.
Finally! 5
Lsan from Florida
I have tried every waterproof eyeliner, from expensive luxury brands to drugstore, and this is the ONLY one that works (note: I live in Florida, where it's currently averaging 95° on a daily basis). It's also easy to glide on and makes the perfect line. I highly recommend!
A MUST HAVE 5
Blessed from North Carolina
So glad that I found this eyeliner, love it! I have dry eyes and at times my eyes water terribly. I have tried LOTS of eyeliners and have never found one that will stay where it should. I purchased in the black and after I saw that it was going to work I bought the bronze. Only wish that there were more colors to choose from.
ONLY longwear eyeliner that STAYS 5
Caitlin from Connecticut, USA
I LOVE this eyeliner! I use it on my waterline and it is literally the only eyeliner out of the tons and tons I have tried that actually stays put. Finally!!! I never write reviews, but I've been really blown away by how great this works and lives up to what it says it does. I only bought the black, but I wear it all day without it ending up under my eyes. It doesn't irritate my contacts or eyes. Really a great bargain!
Thrilled with this purchase. 5
Tru Blonde from OH
First of all, I love the color. As a fair skinned, blued eyed blonde, it's very hard to find colors that aren't overbearing or overly dramatic. This is just the right shade of brown/bronze for as natural a result as I could hope for. It stays on and is safe to use on the waterline without causing an issue with contacts. If I needed a more defined look, it could be a problem since it's a soft pencil and even sharpening doesn't give a tine tip. But this suits my needs wonderfully and at an affordable price. I'll definitely get a few more to have on hand.
GREAT LINER!!!!!! 5
KITTTYCAT from Georgia
THIS LINER STAYS ON BETTER THAN ANY LINER I HAVE EVER USED, I CAN NOW QUIT BUYING THE EXPENSIVE DIOR LINER I HAVE USED FOR YEARS . LOVE,LOVE,LOVE IT!!!!!!!
My new favorite eyeliner! 5
Pili from Pittsburgh, PA
Fantastic quality, long lasting, and easy to apply! Forget the luxe brand rip-offs, this is the only eyeliner you need
quality eye liner 5
neeknee from california
My new favorite THE BEST brown!!! longest lasting, quality eyeliner.This is a re-order for me. I went back for the black and bronze pencils. Really nice for for tightlining your eyes - no flaking or irritation. great size pencil for the money.
