Rated 4.35 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review What a steal!
This is my new favorite drug store eyebrow pencil! I love the precise tiny tip. It applies smoothly with great pigment. Doesn't have that waxy look which is great. The color I got (neutral brown) is a great tone and perfect match for my brunette hair. I did buy this in store and noticed they did not have a good color selection so this may be something you need to order online. And it has a spoolie attached which is always great. I got this for my niece and she loves it as well. I wear this everyday, all day and have not had any issues with fading or smearing of any kind. What a great product for such a great price...what a steal!
Most Helpful Critical Review I would buy this product if it had more shades
First off they only have 3 shades and none of them work for me I bought the shade neutral brown and it was more brown and it does do well with certain hair colors but not mine. I just would like this product better if they had my shade.In their other brow pencil I use deep brown. I would recommend this to certain friends
Reviewed by 101 customers It's okay.
tehya from California
I bought this pencil because it was affordable and I needed something new. Reading the reviews now, I'm kinda surprised they're all so good. It's an alright pencil if you're just starting out. The brunette shade is VERY warm toned and the cool brown is EXTREMELY cool toned. The product lasts okay, but I end up accidentally wiping some off and it smears pretty bad. Formula is alright, but when I try to draw a line, it can be patchy and I have to fix it with powder.
Exactly what I've been looking for!
SE Teachers Rock from NE
It's just perfect. The formula is easy to apply and doesn't budge. The slim shape allows natural looking, precise application. The color choices are nice.
I love it
Julia from Sacramento
Love how it goes on so smoothly
Best product I've ever used
Kiley from Philly
I've tried sooo many eyebrow products and this beats high-end for me. Can't beat the price and has really good pigment! I use everyday and will continue to repurchase!
For the price it's decent
Ivycakes from Illinois
I just use this to fill in small gaps. It works for that. It's not the worst or the best on the market but it serves its purpose.
Shannon from OH
Works great. Not sure why the bigger and not as good elf brown pencil/liner is so popular because this one is definitely better with the smaller strokes you can do
Tone Tone from Chicago, IL
I got the wrong color. I have not try it.
Momo333 from Cali
Finally found my holy grail. Not is it just the formula but its THE COLOR! Cool brown is PERFECT for cool/greybrown toned brows. I have never used a product that matches me this perfect without being a tacky dark shade. So happy this exists!
victoria from mn
i feel like i've tried every brow pencil out there. this is my new favorite! the tip is SUPER skinny so i can easily draw hair-like strokes in my brows. not too waxy but not so dry you feel like you're dragging your skin. for the price you can't beat it!
My favorite brow bencil
Morgan from EBENSBURG, PA
This is my go-to every day brow pencil. I absolutely love it. It shapes and fills patchy spots in my brows with ease. The color is exactly what I expected. The price is the best part.
kat from columbia sc
so cheap and good
Replaced my NYX Micro Brow pencil
Ang from New Jersey
Blew my mind with the quality and lasts all day for me. I use everyday and the amount of product lasts just as long as most high end brow products especially the micro fine ones......ABH, Benefit even NYX priced to high for what they are....drawing lines and filling in eyebrows!
Shannon from OH
Works great and at a great price. Recommend giving it a try.
NOT FOR BLONDES
KT from Fl
I bought the shade taupe. In the picture the color looks more of a light brown/dirty blonde color. I've used elf brow pencils in the shade taupe several times before and if I use a light hand and blend it out with the spoolie thing, it looks decent. My brows are a mix of dirty blonde and golden blonde btw. I hated this color!!!! It looks like I took a piece of charcoal and tried to fill in my brows!!!!!! My brows were an ugly shade of like dark grey and let's just say it's not at all flattering.
holy grail eye pencil
Kaitlyn from Ohio
I absolutely love this eyebrow pencil. I have used high end brow pencils and genuinely prefer this one, and it is at an even lower price point than most drug store pencils. I highly recommend it.
Great Pencil for the Price
Claire from Waleska, Ga.
I really like Elf products. This did not disappoint. The only reason I gave it a 4 is because the brush is basically not usable. It is very course. I have Light/Medium Brown hair and found the Taupe to be perfect.
sonshine1411 from Florida
This pencil has a super fine tip, which works great for thin brows so they don't get gunked up with product. It is pigmented and transfers well, but isn't too creamy to where it moves. Taupe is darker than I was anticipating, so the only missing star on this is review is needing more shades.
I used to use Benefit brow pencil,now I only use this
Sarabear from Mississippi
Amazing!! Not too creamy, but deposits enough color! Wonderful colors. I use with a waterproof clear brow gel (because I have curly hair and my brow hairs will curl if I dint use a gel) and it stays on all day!
jackie from San Francisco, CA
I have used Anastasia and Mac brow pencils. I was looking for a cheaper alternative to try out. This one gets the job done. It can be a little difficult to blend, and I wish it was a little more creamy. For the price it is good, and I would recommend as a cheaper alternative to other brow pencils.
Best Brow Pencil!!
Linds from Marion, OH
This pencil is so smooth and glides on! I have tried MANY brow pencils and this is my all time favorite!!
My favorite eyebrow pencil
KJ from Seattle
I prefer this pencil over several high-end formulas! I've been using this for months :)
New Favorite Brow Liner
karen from Lancaster
I am shocked at how good this brow liner is! I have purchased the ABH brow definer and the Benefit Brow Liner and this one still wins hands down! The price point is incredible, the product delivers, and it comes with a brow brush on the reverse end. I will definitely be purchasing more, and in bulk!
I love this pencil
Skye from Dallas, TX
My eyebrows are mirco-bladed but for a more dramatic look on date nights, I like to use this pencil. It has a brush on the end to tame the brow and the pencil is extremely easy to use. You really can't beat the price, either.
The only one I use.
Laney. from Indiana.
I seek this one, & only this one! No cons for me!
best pencil ever
GLAMOVERDOSE from Salinas
this pencil is by far the best I've ever tried. I've gone from pomade to pencil n this one is it!!! it's not waxy like the other pencil I like it better than the morphe one.