Rated 4.28 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review BEST MASCARA ON THE MARKET
This is hands down the best mascara I have EVER used! It is a wet formula, so be prepared for that, but I just can't believe the dramatic difference when I use this product! Someone is always asking me what kind of false lashes I am wearing, and I watch their mouths drop when I tell them that they are my real lashes and I just have amazing mascara!
Most Helpful Critical Review The Worst Mascara Ever!
I walked into Ulta and asked about a mascara that would help keep my eyelashes curled. I have long lashes but they tend to go flat after a while. This was recommended to me because it was being sold with a lash primer. The primer does help plump but this mascara is terrible. It flattens my lashes even more and refuses to curl. It's clumpy, smudges and the lash brush is way to large to get to the roots of the eyelashes. It's also an old fashioned bristle brush rather than the rubber kind most have. I can't believe I paid this much money for something that is going in the trash. Very disappointing!
Reviewed by 86 customers Raccoon Eyes
CC from Las Vegas, NV
My lashes look so pretty when I first put this on, but it is in no way whatsoever waterproof and therefore it runs if you sweat. I'm a waitress and this was a mess by the end of my shift, even with setting spray. Try something else!
dani from derby, KS
it burned my eyes! I have never has a reaction and I have tried many many mascaras! I got this in a gift set and thought it would be good. it applied well and my lashes looked SO GOOD but then my eye started itching and I was like "what is going on" and it was my mascara! I took it off for the most part but my eye is still burning 20+ minutes later. I know how to apply mascara and i did it the normal way. it's a no for me and it sucks because I can't return it because it came in a gift set.
Long time user
Neena from Albuquerque NM
I've been wearing this mascara since I was in high school. No matter how many others I try, I always come back to this one. Very stackable, great for length and volume. I always get compliments on my lashes when I wear this.
Amanda from Arizona
Did not like this at all. My lashes clumped together.
Jossi from Portland
It goes on very well and looks beautiful, but it transfers quickly. By the end of the day I look like I'm wearing liner on my bottom lid.
Low key the best mascara out there
SarahV437 from Illinois
This mascara doesn't clump, separates lashes beautifully, stays put, and makes my lashes look naturally amazing. I've tried them all and this is my absolute favorite. I'm so grateful I got it somewhere as a gift with purchase because I don't think I would have found this one on my own.
Stays put and looks gorgeous
AbbyBaby from Canada
This is the only "non tube" mascara that won't budge off my lashes until I take it off Every other mascara falls off my lashes and flakes or smears under my eyes by end of my work day - ugh. High end to low and in between and waterproof. The only other one that works for me is tube mascara (I use Lise Watier's Glam Mascara) that stays put and stays glossy. But this one beats the LW in terms of volume and sheer gorgeousness! This mascara is a minor miracle for me!
Sumptuous Extreme Lash Multiplying Volume Mascara
globug from Waterloo, IA
I use this product as the top coat to my Tarte Mascara that I use first. It makes my lashes look longer.
great but one con
Ulta23 from Stoneridge Mall
Great product but it clumps sometimes. I have long lashes and it really defines them and even leaves a little curl. i'd definitely buy again
Re-purchased many many times
Bren from Raleigh, NC
I love this mascara. It applies very smoothly, and if it goes on clumpy, the brush makes it very easy to smooth out. I usually put on 2 layers and my lashes look long and curly. Been using this for a long time! I was introduced to it in an Estee Lauder bundle, but when it ran out I continued to buy it individually. I would say a downside is that it's triple the cost of some drugstore mascaras that work perfectly fine.
Happy with product but better options
Lashes for miles from SC
Was my go to mascara for 1.5 years. Preferred this over Smashbox full exposure, Lights Camera Lashes, and Better than Sex. Easy to apply, did not irritate my sensitive eyes and skin, and gave length and volume. Also an important test/step for me is that it is easy to remove (I use Lancôme eye makeup remover) and not damaging to my lashes (A reason I switched off other high ends products because it was a pain to remove and I had more lash loss). However i switched to L'Oréal's lash paradise mascara because it did the same things that this mascara plus it curled and it doesn't smear as much. Only downsides of my switch are that the lash paradise dries out quicker and it isn't as conditioning to my lashes.
Worst mascara ever
Lucy from Sacramento CA
It's absolutely the worst mascara ever, I've used wet n wild mascaras and they don't get every where like this one within the hour it's in my under eyes, eyelids and my eyes start to feel uncomfortable because it gets inside. Other than that it does separate your lashes really beautiful.
Vane from Orlando
After 125th + layer I got the results I wanted. The formula is light weight, but it requires many layers to get that "Extreme Volume". I'm a big Fan of better than sex mascara, and I think I'll stick with them.
Best mascara on the market
Makeup Mermaid from Bellevue, WA
I have used hundreds of dissapointing and expensive mascaras before. Better Than Sex is up there, however this mascara completely tops anything I have ever EVER used! You have to be very careful when applying it because it is NOT forgiving if it gets onto your beautiful eyelid artwork. A little bit goes a long way and it's all in the art of the applicator and the way the formula goes on. If you're trying to do the no lash-lash look, apply one coat of this stuff, then get some baking (loose) powder on your finger and pat gently onto your lashes. Then go back in with a second layer, and it will literally look like you're wearing falsies!
My favorite mascara
NY to AZ from Phoenix, AZ
Long time L'oreal Voluminous user but have been using this for 4 months now after receiving it as a Christmas gift, and just purchased my first replacement. Love it! The brush is great, the look is n My one complaint is it comes out clumpy, usually the clump stays at top of packaging and even on a new one. wish Estee Lauder could improve the packaging.
Mascara Queen41 from Minneapolis
Not sure what all the hype is but this is one of the worst Mascaras I have ever used! It gets dried out and clumpy right away. You'd think with the nice big brush it would put some volume out, nothing my lashes fall flat, and clump. Gross, I'll stick MAC mascara nothing better.
Best Mascara I've used
Courtney from SW Virginia
I absolutely ADORE this mascara. I've tried all of the highest rated mascaras and this one is my favorite because you can actually get to the end of the tube before it dries out! :)
Picky One from Burleson TX
Though this is more pricey than I would like, it is very good and worth every penny. You will not be disappointed.
I have been using this product for years, so glad I can now
None from Charlotte, NC
Use this daily. Too many questions that are required on this survey.
Always a GO-TO for my makeup kit
Staci R. from Custer, Wa
I use it every day and it literally lasts me 4-5 months! I've tried Tarte Man-Eater mascara which is rated higher than this, and I returned it because it didn't do nearly what this mascara can do.
Great Lash Day
Spense from Knoxville, TN
Wow. This mascara does everything. It gives my long lashes a lift and curl while still adding volume. It does not clump or look spidery even after building up. I have used Better Than Sex for a while but I am switching to this. I think the formulas and brushes are similar but I like this one slightly more.
Rekkie from Nashville, TN
I love this mascara. I use it everyday and don't plan on switching.
I like the waterproof better
Donna from Naples FL
WORTH THE MONEY!!
NICOLE from PUTNAM VALLEY NY
AMAZING!!! BETTER THEN THE BETTER THEN SEX MACARA AND THE NARS CLIMAX COMBINED. SEPERATED, CURLED, LENGHTED MY LASHES!! HANDS DOWN BEST MASCARA AND I HAVE BEEN ON THE HUNT FOR A GREAT MASCARA SINCE I WAS 18. IM NOW 30. SO GOOD SO GOOD SO GOOD!!!
Best Mascara ever!
Katie from Fort Wayne Indiana
I have been searching for the perfect mascara for over 30 years and finally found it! I have short thin lashes and this lengthens and thickens without the clumping! It is well worth the money. It lasts a long time as well. I would highly recommend this!