Rated 4.32 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Pretty Liner
So I bought this liner in the shade Brooklyn Thorn because the end of the pencil that shows the color is my perfect lip nude, which I was trying to find in a liner. But the actual color from the product doesn't match at all. It is a very dull purple. If it were one shade more brown instead of purple it could easily be a nude for people like me with deep complexion. The online swatch it horrendously inaccurate. If you are using the site as a swatch reference, don't. The product itself is actually very good. It's a comfortable smooth formula that glides right on. I prefer this formula to my Makeup Forever lip liner. If I found my perfect lip nude in this formula, I would never buy another liner again.
Most Helpful Critical Review Quality isn't the best compared to the other lip liners.
I've bought quite of few lip liners that are the same collection and they worked great but this one was hard to apply and rubbed off quickly
Reviewed by 1469 customers Great pencil for the cost!
Miminms from Brandon, MS
This is always a good buy for the money and they have lots of different shades
Dryer than the Sahara desert
Bethamous from Maryville Tennessee
Honestly I was so disappointed by these because there is so much hype and positive reviews with them. I ordered about 5 of these at once and each one of them are so dry it hurts to apply because I had to press down so hard to get any color payoff.
It's a no for me!
Michi from Chesapeake, Va
I will return this
Jenn from Mankato
Kdcole from Indiana
I would have given this 5 stars, but it broke on my first application.
Love love love
Blair from USA
Perfect to layer over chapstick and still has that beautiful color
Loved it at first
Cristi from Nc
I really liked it at first but its so dry & keeps breaking, every time i tried to sharpen it it would just keep breaking even if it wasnt to a "sharp" point. I'll just stick to the normal nyx liners
would buy again diff color tho
mia from Houston TX
loved it just wish i would've choose a different color but other than that it's amazing and glides on the lips
I love all lip stuff NYX not crazy about this shade.
wvxraytech from Charleston, WV
Only because I couldn't test out the product first is the reason I bought the wrong shade. (stupid COVID rules)
Mel from OR
I'm a huge Nyx fan for lip liners, butter gloss, matte lip colors and eyeliners everything tbh. I love how smooth it on my lips
barley any pigment
ella from michigan
i was kinda disappointed bc everyone was talking bout it on tik tok but it barley had any pigment jon maybe bc the one i got is almost the same as my lips but it looks good tho i just wish it showed more
Great product for a great price.
LFT from Peoria, AZ
I have bought this MANY times.
A great medium tone neutral color that I use as both a lip liner AND a lip color.
You get what you pay for, but awesome color range
Emily from Huntsville, AL
It's a little scratchy, applies inconsistently, and very dry, but it gets the job done. Under a gloss, any problems disappear anyways. For $4, it's fine since some of the colors are difficult to find, but I prefer higher end formulas.
Not that this affects my rating, but I was hoping for a color closer to the discontinued matte lipstick Ultra Dare (my favorite blue-gray - not too dark, not too ashy!). Ace is more of a darkened teal and can read as almost black in certain lighting.
I think it's okay
Nini Kim from Chicago IL
I think the color didn't show much on my lips. I think I might buy a different lip liner. I do like the packaging and perhaps I'll try a different shade and see how it works for me!
Love love love will b buying again
Manda from TN
Smooth application beautiful color
Doesn't apply easily.
Carebear from Michigan
Probably wouldn't purchase again. Doesn't apply easily at all and not enough true pigment. I love NYX but this gave me serious "kid makeup kit" vibes.
Hillary from UT
I bought this on the recommendation of a youtuber, and I really cannot understand why these are seemingly so popular. It was the dryest lip liner I've ever used, and it was practically impossible to get any color pay-off. I returned it.
I wouldn't buy this again
T. Nicole from Houston, TX
I purchased this because I love the NYX brand. However immediately upon opening and attempting to use this liner, it was super dry, wouldn't transfer at all, and the the entire tip broke off. It's is obviously an old and likely outdated product.
Crayon is hard, makes it difficult to apply
SheltieMom from Simi Valley, CA
Tried to apply to lips, the wax part is too hard, making it difficult to apply.
Love and would buy again
Dion from Delaware
I love this lip pencil, it works well under glosses and helps lipsticks not bleed. I removed one star because the point is, well, pointy and uncomfortable to use but is perfect once you wear the point down.
Kalasmom3 from Holiday FL
The color barely shows up and only does it not last a bit but it bleeds. I exchanged it for the retractable lip liner from NYx which goes on nicely and shows up but also doesn't last long and bleeds. Guess NYX Liner isn't for me. too bad
Steph from Ohio
I got the shade Free Spirit; it's a very unattractive color on me. It's not at all what I expected from the website which described it as a medium nude with pink.
I'm light-medium complexion with neutral undertone. This liner's a warm orange... not an attractive nude pink.
The formula is great and easy to sharpen.
Great matte lip liner
luv2knit from Vancouver, WA
Love this lip liner from NYX. I have been looking for a matte liner which was not sparkly. This is excellent. Goes on smooth. I am not an expect makeup artist but I get this right every time. Love the price.
Fantastic lip liner
B from Tx
Goes on smoothly
Pigmented and long lasting
Adriana from California
LOVE LOVE LOVE this stuff. It last forever and is Matte without drying.